compare how a 1917 steel chemist and a 1909 researcher present the twelve-hour shift, analyzing how word choice and connotation shape each author’s interpretation.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Sort these words into positive and negative feelings: efficient, drudgery, routine, romantic, low-waged, exhausting. Which ones could describe the same job?
A steel company chemist and a researcher who interviewed workers both describe twelve-hour shifts. What do you predict?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Emphasis through space. How much room a writer gives a fact shows how important it is to him. Spring gives the twelve-hour shift part of one sentence. Fitch gives it two paragraphs and a worker’s voice.
Emphasis through connotation. Words with similar meanings can carry opposite feelings: routine versus drudgery, economical versus cheap. An author’s choice shows his attitude.
Worked example 1: what the words celebrate. Ava notes that Spring calls the old pig beds “gloriously beautiful” and the hand-fed era “romantic,” then praises machines that charge the furnace “more economically than even low-waged laborers can do it.” He ends, “Truly this is an age of efficiency.” She concludes that Spring admires the process and its progress more than he considers the laborers.
Worked example 2: what the words protest. Marcus reads Barr: “how can a man get any pleasure out of life working that way?” Fitch notices the piano that “spoke of other things than endless drudgery.” Barr says, “I only have these things to think about, not to enjoy.” Marcus concludes that Fitch presents the long day as a cost to family life.
Fair comparison. Spring is not wrong that machines did more work; Fitch is not wrong that long shifts hurt families. They interpret the same industry through different purposes: explaining a process versus showing workers’ lives.
A comparison frame. Both ___ and ___ mention ___. However, ___ emphasizes ___, using words like “___,” while ___ emphasizes ___, using words like “___.” This difference shows ___.
Compare as you go: S for Spring, F for Fitch.
Text-dependent comparison.
Prompt: How do Spring and Fitch present the twelve-hour shift differently? Write a paragraph of 7-9 sentences using the comparison frame. Checklist: (1) a claim naming both authors, (2) two quotations from each, (3) at least two words analyzed for connotation, (4) a reason their purposes differ.
Reading life: find one sentence in your independent book that shows the author's attitude through word choice. Copy it and name the attitude.
Efficiency and exhaustion: both are part of the story. Next we see how a whole 1909 report was organized and practice summarizing it fairly.
Exit ticket: write one neutral word and one loaded word for a twelve-hour shift.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 9, paragraph 10.
Text note: Spring’s opening sentences come from the start of chapter IV, before the part read in 2.06 (no sentence is repeated); today’s cuts skip the casting machines and his note that modern plants use almost no hand labor. Barr’s paragraphs come from Fitch’s report (anchor book).
History check: the twelve-hour day remained common in steel until the early 1920s. Spring wrote in 1917, Fitch in 1909.
Likely misconceptions: that Spring is a villain; that a technical text has no point of view; that connotation is only about positive or negative, not about what a writer chooses to notice.
Supports: word bank of connotation words; the comparison frame on a card. Stretch: Spring says machines charge furnaces more cheaply than “low-waged laborers.” What might that mean for those laborers’ jobs?
Sample response: Both Spring and Fitch mention twelve-hour shifts, but they interpret them differently. Spring mentions that a buggy-pusher works “on twelve-hour shifts at the top” in part of one sentence and moves on to praise machines that work “more economically than even low-waged laborers.” His closing, “Truly this is an age of efficiency,” shows admiration for progress. Fitch, however, lets Jim Barr ask, “how can a man get any pleasure out of life working that way?” Barr says he is “so tired at night” that he can only “eat and sleep.” Spring’s purpose is to explain a process, while Fitch’s is to show workers’ lives, so the same hours sound like routine in one text and like a loss in the other.
La Verne W. Spring, Non-Technical Chats on Iron and Steel (Frederick A. Stokes, 1917), chapter IV, Project Gutenberg eBook #73090; with John A. Fitch, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #73090 and #46029
About the texts. Text 1 returns to La Verne W. Spring’s 1917 chapter on the blast furnace, which we read in 2.06, but today’s parts are new: the opening ride up the furnace tower and the end of the chapter, where he describes new machines. Text 2 returns to John A. Fitch’s 1909 report. Jim Barr is a skilled worker who came from England as a boy.
What to notice. Both texts mention twelve-hour days. Spring names the hours in one sentence and moves on. Fitch builds a whole scene in Barr’s parlor. Circle words with strong connotations in each.
Words to know. Skip-hoists are machines that carry materials up and dump them into the furnace. Pig beds are sand molds for cast iron. Economically means at lower cost. The long turn is a 24-hour shift. A parlor is a front sitting room. Drudgery is hard, dull work.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
Text 1: La Verne W. Spring, Non-Technical Chats on Iron and Steel (1917)
Up the dark tower shoots the elevator with its “buggy” of coke. Its speed is not conditioned to the comfort of man, who is not supposed to be a passenger, except the occasional laborer whose duty as buggy-pusher requires his presence on twelve-hour shifts at the top.
[…]
But the romantic period of the hand-fed furnace and the gloriously beautiful pig beds at casting time are rapidly passing; in fact, are almost past. Modern “skip-hoists” carrying automatically dumped buckets or cars charge the furnace more economically than even low-waged laborers can do it.
[…]
Truly this is an age of efficiency.
Text 2: John A. Fitch, “Some Pittsburgh Steel Workers” (1909)
Jim Barr is a man thirty-five years old who came from England when he was a small boy. It has been only during the last ten years or so that Barr has worked in a steel mill, but he has lived in the steel district longer than that. He occupies a skilled position in one of the mills where he works every day but Sundays from seven in the morning until six in the evening, and on alternate Sundays he has the long turn of twenty-four hours. This Sunday work, he told me, came in after the union had been driven out, and the twelve-hour day is more general now than it was under unionism.
“Tell me, how can a man get any pleasure out of life working that way?” Barr asked me almost with a challenge. We were sitting before the grate in his comfortable and tastefully furnished parlor. There were pictures on the wall, a carpet on the floor, and the piano in the corner spoke of other things than endless drudgery. He seemed to interpret my swift glance about the room, for he went on, “I’ve got as good a home here as a man could want. It’s comfortable and I enjoy my family. But I only have these things to think about, not to enjoy. I’m at work most of the day, and I’m so tired at night that I just go to bed as soon as I’ve eaten supper. I have ideas of what a home ought to be, all right, but the way things are now I just eat and sleep here.”
Source: La Verne W. Spring, Non-Technical Chats on Iron and Steel (Frederick A. Stokes, 1917), chapter IV, Project Gutenberg eBook #73090; with John A. Fitch, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)