reflect on how I grew as a reader and writer this unit and answer the driving question with evidence from our texts and my own story.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Open your writing folder and lay out three things: your first story map from 1.15, your peer-conference notes and your published story. Write one sentence about the biggest difference between the plan and the final story.
What does our driving question ask us to think about now?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Looking back. Reflection is the last step of the writing process and the first step of the next piece. Writers ask: What did I set out to do? What did I actually do? What will I do differently next time?
David’s crossroads. O. Henry shows how a place pushes a choice: “Vernoy was no place for him. Not one soul there could share his thoughts.” The small village feels too small for his dreams. But the place also pulls him back: a light in Yvonne’s window makes “a weakness” shake his purpose. Then the road itself “turned into a puzzle.” Notice how O. Henry uses the dash in “that morning might–But, no!” to show David cutting off his own thought.
Answering the driving question. Across the unit we met characters whose places pushed them: a Country Mouse who fled a dangerous mansion, a girl in the woods who must choose between a reward and a secret, children trapped in a hot train, a reformed safecracker in a small bank, a traveler on a long uphill road and the characters you read in Part 1. A strong answer to the driving question makes a claim and supports it with evidence from at least two texts and from your own story.
Worked example 1: Aiden reflects on revision. Aiden compares his story map with his final draft. “My plan had the crossroads in the last paragraph. After my conference, I moved it to the middle and added a scene after it, so my conclusion could reflect instead of just stopping. My log shows I cut 94 words of summary from the opening.” He names the change, the reason and the evidence.
Worked example 2: Priya answers the driving question. Priya writes: “Places shape our choices by deciding what is possible and what is at stake. In ‘A White Heron,’ Sylvia’s love of the woods keeps her silent. In ‘Roads of Destiny,’ David leaves because ‘Vernoy was no place for him.’ In my story, the only bridge out of town floods, so my character has to choose between waiting and wading. A place can push us away, hold us back or force us to decide fast.”
Goal setting. End with one specific goal for Unit 2, where you will write informative museum labels: for example, “Use precise words and cut wordiness in every label.”
Use the passage, then look back at your own work.
Write your unit reflection.
Answer the driving question in a paragraph: How do the places we live shape the choices we make? Make a claim, cite evidence from at least two texts in this unit (quote at least once) and connect it to your own anthology story.
Writer’s reflection: name the checklist item where you grew most and show the evidence (a before-and-after sentence from your revision log). Explain how feedback or your audience changed your story. Then set one specific goal for Unit 2.
Like David at the fork, you are at a new beginning. Unit 2 takes our writing from stories to the real history of the Mon Valley.
Exit ticket: finish the sentence “The next time I write a story, I will …” and explain why.
Pacing: warm-up 5 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 8, guided practice 8, reflection writing 15, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that reflection means saying the story is good or bad; that a goal can be general (“write better”); that the driving question has one right answer. Push for evidence from the revision log.
Content note: the full story of “Roads of Destiny” follows each road to a violent end for David; students read only the opening and the fork, which is all this lesson needs. The poem’s spelling mould and the story’s honour, quarrelled and ploughman are older or British spellings printed in this edition.
Supports: provide a reflection frame (I planned … / After feedback I … / My evidence is … / Next time I will …). Allow students to record a spoken reflection. Stretch: write a short epigraph, like David’s poem, for your own story.
Assessment: the reflection assesses CC.1.4.7.T (revision for purpose and audience); the driving-question paragraph assesses CC.1.3.7.A and C (theme and how setting shapes characters) and confirms CC.1.4.7.M.
Answer guide: sample driving-question paragraph: “The places we live shape our choices because they decide what is safe, what is possible and who is near us. The Country Mouse chooses ‘peace and security’ after the city’s cat and dog frighten her. David leaves because ‘Vernoy was no place for him.’ In my story, the dark path behind the store is why my character gives up her art class to walk her brother home. A place can push us away, keep us close or make us decide what matters most.” Sample goal: “In Unit 2 I will check every label for wordiness, because my reflection showed I cut most of my extra words only at the end.”
Project Gutenberg, Roads of Destiny by O. Henry (1909), eBook #1646 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
“Roads of Destiny” is the title story of O. Henry’s 1909 collection, the same book that holds “A Retrieved Reformation.” It is set in a French village named Vernoy. David Mignot is a young shepherd who writes poems. The story opens with one of his poems; he believes he will find his destiny, meaning the future that is meant to happen, out on the roads of the world.
After a quarrel with Yvonne, a young woman of the village, David decides to leave home that night. This passage follows him out of Vernoy to a place where the road splits. O. Henry then tells what happens on each road David could take, so the story itself becomes a set of crossroads.
Words to know: resolved means firmly decided; rued means regretted; a league is an old measure of about three miles; a champaign is a wide, flat stretch of open country; a furrow is the straight groove a plow cuts in a field.
I go to seek on many roads
What is to be.
True heart and strong, with love to light–
Will they not bear me in the fight
To order, shun or wield or mould
My Destiny?Unpublished Poems of David Mignot.
[…]
And then he remembered that he and Yvonne had quarrelled that day, and that he had resolved to leave his home that night to seek fame and honour in the great world outside.
[…]
He passed his father’s herd of sheep, huddled in their nightly pen–the sheep he herded daily, leaving them to scatter while he wrote verses on scraps of paper. He saw a light yet shining in Yvonne’s window, and a weakness shook his purpose of a sudden. Perhaps that light meant that she rued, sleepless, her anger, and that morning might–But, no! His decision was made. Vernoy was no place for him. Not one soul there could share his thoughts. Out along that road lay his fate and his future.
Three leagues across the dim, moonlit champaign ran the road, straight as a ploughman’s furrow. It was believed in the village that the road ran to Paris, at least; and this name the poet whispered often to himself as he walked. Never so far from Vernoy had David travelled before.
THE LEFT BRANCH
Three leagues, then, the road ran, and turned into a puzzle. It joined with another and a larger road at right angles. David stood, uncertain, for a while, and then took the road to the left.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Roads of Destiny by O. Henry (1909), eBook #1646 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)