show what I have learned in Unit 2 by reading and listening to new passages, writing a short informative response and turning in my final label set.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have read like a researcher and written like a curator. Read both passages twice: once for the main ideas, once with your pencil. Underline anything you might use as evidence. Then listen to the recording of Text A.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to read closely and use evidence from the passages.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How this check works. Part A is a reading and listening check on the two passages. Part B is a short informative paragraph. Part C is your final label set with your checklist and revision log. Take your time, and use evidence.
Reminders for Part A. When a question asks for evidence, quote exactly. When it asks for a central idea, write what the whole passage develops, not one detail. When it compares authors, think about which facts each chooses and how each explains them. When it asks about the recording, think about what your ears get that your eyes do not, and the reverse.
Worked example 1: Hana separates fact and claim. A practice question asks what Carnegie did after Edwards spoke. Hana writes: Carnegie says he agreed to pay every two weeks: “Mr. Edwards, that shall be done.” His statement that these were the company’s most profitable investments is his own judgment. She keeps the event and the opinion apart.
Worked example 2: Caleb uses two sources. Caleb writes: Carnegie describes a company that lowered workers’ costs; Crowell found that a Carnegie Steel Company row had no drinking water in its houses. Then he adds context from 2.23: the two authors wrote about different years and places.
Reminders for Parts B and C. Use our ten-item checklist.
| # | Label checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My title names my topic and makes a visitor curious. | B |
| 2 | My opening introduces the topic clearly and previews what the label will explain; my most powerful sentence is near the start. | B |
| 3 | I develop the topic with relevant facts and concrete details from at least two sources. | C |
| 4 | I define at least one technical word for my reader. | C |
| 5 | I include one short, accurate quotation in quotation marks and name who said or wrote it. | C |
| 6 | My graphic (picture, map or timeline) helps the reader, and its caption has a credit line. | C |
| 7 | I organize with a clear strategy: definition, classification, comparison and contrast, or cause and effect. | D |
| 8 | Transitions connect my ideas, and my last sentence answers “So what?” for a visitor. | D |
| 9 | I use precise words and topic vocabulary, vary my sentences and keep a consistent, formal voice. | E |
| 10 | Grammar, capitals, punctuation and spelling are correct, and my label can be read aloud in about 60 seconds. | F |
Constraints: main label 150 to 220 words; caption 15 to 40 words; two or three Words to know. Every fact must come from a source you can name. Your title and your first name will appear on the label. Also write one timeline entry and one map label for the class exhibit.
Part A: Reading and listening check. Work alone. Answer from the passages and the recording.
Part A short responses, then Parts B and C.
Short response: How do Carnegie and Crowell present the relationship between a steel company and its workers’ daily lives? Quote one piece of evidence from each text, explain it, and say why a museum visitor should hear both views.
Listening response: describe one way the reader’s delivery in the recording (pace, pauses, tone) changed the impact of Carnegie’s words for you, compared with reading them silently.
Part B (on-demand writing, about 15 minutes): Write a short informative paragraph (100-150 words) for a museum visitor about how workers’ daily needs (pay, food, water) were met, or not met, in the steel era. Introduce the topic, use at least one fact from each passage, include one exact quotation with its author, use two transitions, keep a formal voice and end with a so-what sentence.
Part C: Submit your final label set (title, main label, caption with credit line, Words to know, timeline entry and map label) with your checklist marked and your revision log. Read your main label aloud to your teacher with a timer.
Researchers who wrote about the steel valley left their work for us to test. Today you tested it, and your own.
Exit ticket: which part of the check felt strongest for you, and which skill do you want to keep practicing?
Pacing: warm-up and two readings 10 minutes, recording 3, reminders 2, Part A 17, Part B 8 (finish in the next lesson if needed). Collect Part C at the end; schedule the timed read-alouds during Parts A and B or the next morning.
Recording: LibriVox, Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie, section 18, “Problems of Labor,” read by William Tomcho (librivox.org/autobiography-of-andrew-carnegie-by-andrew-carnegie; LibriVox recordings are public domain in the U.S.). The section runs about 25 minutes; Text A begins with “Employers can do so many desirable things” and, estimating from its place in the chapter, starts about 17 to 18 minutes in and ends near 20 minutes. Cue it before class and listen for the first sentence. The recording also reads the two paragraphs cut from the print passage (coal at cost and a savings plan); students are not asked about them. Part 1 used section 17; this section is new.
Source notes: Text A is exact from the Gutenberg file, including its spelling “Cooeperative” (the original printed “Coöperative”). Text B is a paragraph of Crowell’s report not shown in 2.18 or 2.20. Carnegie sold his company in 1901; Crowell describes a Carnegie Steel Company property under U.S. Steel in 1908, and Carnegie writes about his own management years. Credit students who note this difference in time.
Coverage: Part A covers CC.1.2.7.A (Q1; summary in the short response), B (Q2, Q8), C (Q3), E (Q6), F (Q4, Q5), G (Q9 and the listening response), I (Q7 and the short response) and L (independent reading of new passages). Part B and Part C are scored with the rubric below for CC.1.4.7.A-F.
Supports: read the passages aloud for students with reading accommodations (Part A then measures comprehension, not decoding). Provide the recording with captions off and a pause after each paragraph if needed. Allow typed responses.
Scoring Part A: Q1-Q9 are 1 point each (9 points). The short response is scored 0-4: 1 for a clear comparison, 1 for each of two accurate quotations explained, 1 for a reason a visitor should hear both. The listening response is scored 0-2: 1 for naming a feature of delivery, 1 for explaining its effect. Total 15; 11 or more meets the standard.
Label set and Part B rubric. Score each row 4 (exceeds), 3 (meets), 2 (approaching) or 1 (beginning). Use rows 1-4 and 6 for Part B.
| Row | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Informative purpose (CC.1.4.7.A) | Examines the topic clearly and accurately for a public audience; every fact is sourced | Explains the topic clearly; facts are accurate | Some facts unclear or unsourced | Tells a story or argues instead of informing |
| 2. Introduction (B) | Title and opening name the topic, hook the visitor and preview what follows | Topic is clear at the start with a preview | Topic appears late; no preview | The reader cannot tell the topic |
| 3. Development (C) | Relevant facts from two or more sources, a definition, an exact quotation with its author, and a useful graphic with a credited caption | Facts, a definition and a quotation; caption has a credit line | Few facts; quotation or caption incomplete | Little or no evidence |
| 4. Organization (D) | A clear strategy, varied transitions and a concluding section that answers so what | A clear strategy, some transitions, a fitting conclusion | Order sometimes confusing; ending repeats or stops suddenly | Hard to follow; no conclusion |
| 5. Style (E) | Precise topic vocabulary, varied sentences, a consistent and formal voice | Mostly precise and formal; some variety | Several vague or informal words; sentences sound alike | Vague or informal throughout |
| 6. Conventions (F) | Few or no errors; exhibit style followed | Minor errors that do not get in the way | Frequent errors | Errors make it hard to read |
A label set totaling 18-24 is ready for the exhibit. Below 18, confer and allow one more revision before display. The timeline entry and map label count within rows 3 and 6.
Answer key: Q1 = A (index 0), Q2 = C (2), Q3 = B (1), Q4 = D (3), Q5 = C (2), Q6 = B (1), Q7 = D (3), Q8 = A (0), Q9 = B (1). Sample short response: “Carnegie presents a company that listened to its workers: after Billy Edwards spoke, Carnegie said, ‘Mr. Edwards, that shall be done,’ and the men started a cooperative store. Crowell presents a company row where the ‘town pump’ was ‘the sole supply of drinking water’ for 568 people. A visitor should hear both, because an owner’s memories and an investigator’s report show different sides of the same industry.” Sample Part B: “In the steel era, a worker’s daily needs depended partly on his employer. At Carnegie’s Braddock mills, worker Billy Edwards asked to be paid every two weeks so families could avoid store debt, and Carnegie agreed. In contrast, at Painter’s Row in 1908, F. Elisabeth Crowell found that the ‘town pump’ was ‘the sole supply of drinking water’ for 568 people. As a result, families walked as far as 360 steps for water. Payday and water may seem small, but for steel families they shaped every day.”
Project Gutenberg, Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie (1920), eBook #17976, Chapter XVIII; with Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part II: The Place (February 6, 1909), eBook #46025, F. Elisabeth Crowell, “Painter’s Row” · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text; LibriVox recording public domain in the U.S.
Text A is a new passage from chapter XVIII of Andrew Carnegie’s autobiography, “Problems of Labor.” Carnegie remembers a meeting with his steelworkers at which a worker named Billy Edwards spoke up. Your teacher will play this part of the free LibriVox recording of the book, read by the volunteer William Tomcho. The recording includes two short paragraphs that the printed passage cuts at […].
Text B is a new paragraph from F. Elisabeth Crowell’s 1909 report on Painter’s Row, the company houses you studied in 2.18 and 2.20.
Words to know: supplies are food and other goods for the home; wholesale means in large amounts at a lower price; stock here means shares of ownership; institution means an organization; concessions are things given up or granted in a deal; the letter of the bond means the exact words of an agreement; settlement here means a group of homes; sole means only.
Text A: from Andrew Carnegie, Autobiography, Chapter XVIII, “Problems of Labor”
PROBLEMS OF LABOR
Employers can do so many desirable things for their men at little cost. At one meeting when I asked what we could do for them, I remember this same Billy Edwards rose and said that most of the men had to run in debt to the storekeepers because they were paid monthly. Well I remember his words:
“I have a good woman for wife who manages well. We go into Pittsburgh every fourth Saturday afternoon and buy our supplies wholesale for the next month and save one third. Not many of your men can do this. Shopkeepers here charge so much. And another thing, they charge very high for coal. If you paid your men every two weeks, instead of monthly, it would be as good for the careful men as a raise in wages of ten per cent or more.”
“Mr. Edwards, that shall be done,” I replied.
It involved increased labor and a few more clerks, but that was a small matter. The remark about high prices charged set me to thinking why the men could not open a cooeperative store. This was also arranged–the firm agreeing to pay the rent of the building, but insisting that the men themselves take the stock and manage it. Out of that came the Braddock’s Cooeperative Society, a valuable institution for many reasons, not the least of them that it taught the men that business had its difficulties.
[…]
It was such concessions as these that proved the most profitable investments ever made by the company, even from an economical standpoint. It pays to go beyond the letter of the bond with your men. Two of my partners, as Mr. Phipps has put it, “knew my extreme disposition to always grant the demands of labor, however unreasonable,” but looking back upon my failing in this respect, I wish it had been greater–much greater. No expenditure returned such dividends as the friendship of our workmen.
Text B: from F. Elisabeth Crowell, “Painter’s Row,” 1909
PAINTER’S ROW
Not one house in the entire settlement had any provision for supplying drinking water to its tenants. Mill water was piped out to the rows,–an ugly, dirty fluid, which, however tired or thirsty they were, the people would not put to their lips. I asked the question at every doorstep and got the same reply. They went to an old pump in the mill yard,–360 steps from the farthest apartment, down seventy-five stairs. This “town pump” was the sole supply of drinking water within reach of ninety-one households, comprising 568 persons.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie (1920), eBook #17976, Chapter XVIII; with Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part II: The Place (February 6, 1909), eBook #46025, F. Elisabeth Crowell, “Painter’s Row” (gutenberg.pglaf.org)