choose a strategy to organize my label (definition, classification, comparison and contrast, or cause and effect) and use it to group my facts.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Finish this sentence two ways: “Many people moved to the Pittsburgh area to work in the mills because …” Then underline the word that shows cause.
In 1917, a researcher counted Black workers in twenty Pittsburgh-area industries. Compared with 1915, what do you predict he found?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Facts need a shape. A pile of true facts is not yet a label. Our standard names four strategies for organizing information. Choose the one that fits your purpose statement, then group your facts to match.
Definition explains what something is and how it works (“A blast furnace is …”). Classification sorts examples into types (“Four Types of Housing Ills”). Comparison and contrast shows how two things are alike or different (furnace crews and steel pourers). Cause and effect explains why something happened and what followed (the war stopped immigration, so mills recruited workers from the South).
Signal words help visitors follow. Cause and effect: because, as a result, so, due to, on this basis. Comparison: while, both, unlike, however. Classification: one type, another kind. Definition: is, means, called.
Worked example 1: Tomas uses cause and effect. Tomas’s topic is the migration of Black workers to the mills (card H). He groups his facts in a chain: cause (European immigration stopped), action (labor agents recruited workers in the South), effect (2,550 Black workers in 1915, 8,325 in 1917, in the industries surveyed). Each sentence of his label moves one link forward.
Worked example 2: Grace uses comparison. Grace compares two jobs from cards A and B. She makes a T-chart: furnace crew (twelve-hour days, seven days a week, the long turn, lower pay) and steel pourer (eight hours, six days, well paid). Her label describes one job, then uses “Steel pourers, however,” to turn to the other.
People, events and ideas interact. Epstein’s passage shows a world event (the war) changing what employers did (sending agents) and what thousands of people chose (moving north). Good informative writing shows those connections, not just a list.
Read Epstein closely, then practice the strategies.
Organize your draft.
Make a graphic organizer for your label (a cause chain, a T-chart, a category list or a definition web). Put each fact from your research chart where it belongs.
Write a short informative paragraph (60-80 words) that explains, using Epstein’s numbers, how the number of Black workers changed from 1915 to 1917 and why. Use two cause-and-effect signal words.
Behind every number in Epstein’s chapter are people who made a hard choice to move.
Exit ticket: which strategy fits your label best, and why does it fit your purpose statement?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture 9, guided practice 11, organizer 6, closure 2.
Discussion note: Epstein’s study names Black migrants with the term of 1918. Say plainly that the term is historical, that we use Black or African American, and that quotations stay exact. The National Park Service style guide (read in 2.24) capitalizes Black when it refers to culture or identity. Epstein writes about the migrants as an outside researcher; invite students to notice whose voices are missing and how a label could honor the workers as people with their own reasons for moving. The cut passage skips Professor Tyson’s note and census details.
Math check: 8,325 − 2,550 = 5,775, as Epstein writes. His 227 percent is his own rounding of about 226.5 percent; quote it as his figure if students use it. His 14,000 is an estimate, not a count, and a label should say so.
Likely misconceptions: that cause and effect only means one cause; that classification and comparison are the same; that an estimate is a fact.
Supports: provide blank organizers for all four strategies. Read the passage aloud while students follow. Stretch: combine two strategies (for example, a definition followed by a cause chain).
Answer guide: sample paragraph: “When the war stopped most European immigration, Pittsburgh’s mills needed workers. As a result, labor agents recruited in the South. In twenty industries that Abraham Epstein surveyed, the number of Black workers rose from 2,550 in 1915 to 8,325 in 1917. Because he could reach only about 60 percent of employers, he estimated the total at 14,000.”
Project Gutenberg, The Negro Migrant in Pittsburgh by Abraham Epstein (University of Pittsburgh, 1918), eBook #67349 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In 1917, Abraham Epstein, a University of Pittsburgh economics student, studied the thousands of Black workers and families who had recently moved from Southern states to the Pittsburgh district. His study was published in 1918. Epstein uses the word Negro, the term used then; today we say Black or African American, and we quote him exactly. This movement was part of what historians call the Great Migration.
The introduction explains a cause: when World War I stopped most immigration from Europe, the mills needed new workers. The chapter then gives numbers from a survey of employers and explains how he estimated a total. Notice the words that link causes, effects and evidence.
Words to know: migration means moving from one region to another to live; cessation means a stop; labor agents were people hired to find and sign up workers; a canvas here means a survey that asks many people; concerns here means businesses; a ratio compares two amounts.
INTRODUCTION
Our great steel city of the North calls many unskilled workers to its mills. The migration of Negroes to fill the gaps in the ranks of this labor force, opened up by the cessation of European immigration following the war has been under way for nearly eighteen months. Expanding steel production continues to call for more workers. From the first labor agents of railroads and steel mills as well as private employment agencies have been at work gathering in the new army of laborers.
[…]
CHAPTER I.
From a canvas of twenty typical industries in the Pittsburgh district, it was found that there were 2,550 Negroes employed in 1915, and 8,325 in 1917, an increase of 5,775 or 227%. It was impossible to obtain labor data from more than approximately sixty percent of the Negro employing concerns, but it is fair to assume that the same ratio of increase holds true of the remaining forty percent. On this basis the number of Negroes now employed in the district may be placed at 14,000. This means that there are about 9,750 more Negroes working in the district today than there were in 1915, an addition due to the migration from the South.
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Negro Migrant in Pittsburgh by Abraham Epstein (University of Pittsburgh, 1918), eBook #67349 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)