
evaluate the evidence that light behaves as a wave and as a particle, use photon energy to explain why different frequencies affect matter differently, and judge the validity and reliability of published claims about electromagnetic radiation.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. You can get sunburned on a cool, cloudy day, but not from sitting near a warm lamp for hours. Write one idea about why.
Which will make glow-in-the-dark material glow more: a very bright red light for 60 seconds, or a dim blue light for 30 seconds?
Two models, one light. Light, radio, microwaves, X-rays and ultraviolet are all electromagnetic (EM) waves: oscillating electric and magnetic fields that travel through empty space at c = 3.00 × 108 m/s. They differ only in frequency and wavelength. But “wave” is only half the story, and HS-PS4-3 asks you to evaluate the evidence for both models.
Evidence for the wave model. Waves interfere: where two sets of waves overlap, crests meet crests and add, and crests meet troughs and cancel. Light does this. The rainbow bands you see on the surface of a DVD, and the bright and dark fringes when light passes through two narrow slits, are interference patterns. Light also diffracts, spreading out as it passes through a narrow opening, and it refracts, bending as it changes speed entering glass or water. A particle model cannot easily explain interference.
Evidence for the particle model. Glow-in-the-dark material is “charged” by light: electrons in it absorb light energy, jump to higher energy levels, and slowly release it as a glow. Shine a bright red LED on a patch for 30 seconds, then turn off the lights: it barely glows. Shine a dim blue LED on another patch for 30 seconds: it glows brightly. A wave model predicts that brighter light, carrying more energy, should charge it more, whatever the color. It does not. The explanation, first proposed by Einstein for the photoelectric effect in 1905, is that light arrives in packets called photons, each with energy E = hf, where h = 6.626 × 10−34 J·s. In the photoelectric effect, light shining on a metal knocks electrons out only if its frequency is above a threshold, however bright it is.
Worked example 1: photon energy. An electron absorbs one photon at a time. A red photon (700 nm, f = c ÷ λ = 4.28 × 1014 Hz) carries E = 6.626 × 10−34 × 4.28 × 1014 = 2.84 × 10−19 J, about 1.77 eV, not enough to lift the electron; making the light brighter only sends more red photons, each still too weak. A blue photon (about 450 nm, 2.76 eV) does. So both models are needed: light travels and interferes like a wave, and it delivers energy to matter in photon-sized amounts.
Photon energies across the spectrum (calculated with E = hf; 1 eV = 1.602 × 10−19 J):
| Radiation | Frequency | Photon energy |
|---|---|---|
| FM radio, 101.7 MHz | 1.017 × 108 Hz | 4.2 × 10−7 eV |
| Cell phone, 1.9 GHz | 1.9 × 109 Hz | 7.9 × 10−6 eV |
| Microwave oven, 2.45 GHz | 2.45 × 109 Hz | 1.0 × 10−5 eV |
| Red light, 700 nm | 4.28 × 1014 Hz | 1.77 eV |
| Ultraviolet B, 300 nm | 1.00 × 1015 Hz | 4.13 eV |
Worked example 2: comparing photons. A typical carbon-carbon bond takes about 3.6 eV to break. A single UV-B photon (4.13 eV) can break a bond in DNA, which is why sunburn and skin cancer are linked to UV exposure and why weather services publish a daily UV Index. A cell-phone photon carries 4.13 ÷ (7.9 × 10−6) ≈ 500,000 times less energy, far too little to break any chemical bond. Radio and microwave radiation can still transfer energy by heating when it is intense (that is how a microwave oven works, and why exposure limits exist), but it does not break bonds.
Evaluating claims. Published claims about radiation range from well supported to baseless. Judge each on validity (does the reasoning match the physics?) and reliability (is the source expert, is the evidence from many studies, is it consistent?). “UV exposure increases skin-cancer risk” is supported by physics (photon energy) and by large bodies of medical evidence from national health agencies. Claims that cell-phone signals break DNA fail the physics test, and major health agencies report no consistent evidence that normal phone use causes cancer, while research continues. Always check: who says so, based on what evidence, and does it fit the photon model?
Lab procedure: Charging Glow Material with Different Colors of Light. Question: does the color (frequency) or the brightness of light determine whether it can charge glow-in-the-dark material? Materials: a glow-in-the-dark sheet or stickers cut into four equal patches; LED flashlights in red, green and blue (or a white phone flashlight with red and blue transparent filters); a dark room or a shoebox viewer; a timer; aluminum foil to cover patches not being tested.
| Patch | Light color | Distance (cm) | Time (s) | Glow, observer 1 (0–3) | Glow, observer 2 (0–3) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Red | 10 | 30 | ||
| 2 | Green | 10 | 30 | ||
| 3 | Blue | 10 | 30 | ||
| 4 | Red, brighter and longer | 2 | 60 |
No lab space? Use the teacher’s recorded demonstration or the provided photographs of glow patches under each light, and complete the analysis; use the PhET Bending Light simulation to explore the wave behavior (refraction) of different colors.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapters 15 and 21 (CC BY 4.0).
Use your glow rankings and the photon table.
Finish the lab analysis in your notebook.
Claim: what determines whether light charges the material, color or brightness? Evidence: your rankings. Reasoning: explain with E = hf, and explain why the wave model alone predicts the wrong result for patch 4.
Use your result to evaluate the claim “any light, if bright enough, can damage skin cells the way UV does.”
Light travels like a wave and delivers energy like a particle. Next class: how waves carry information as bits.
Exit ticket: name one piece of evidence for each model of light, and explain why scientists keep both.
Timing: Poly ran this lab over two 50-minute periods. Day 1: the glow lab and photon energy. Day 2: wave evidence, the photon table and claim evaluation.
Materials (per team): glow sheet cut into four patches, red, green and blue LED lights or filters, foil, a timer, a shoebox viewer if the room cannot be darkened.
Facts note: keep health claims to what major health agencies report: UV is a known skin-cancer risk; no consistent evidence links normal phone use to cancer, and research continues. Do not cite specific study numbers.
Listen for: “brighter light means more energetic photons”; “all radiation is dangerous”; treating the two models as competitors where one must be wrong.
Support / stretch: give a claim-evaluation checklist (who, what evidence, fits the physics?). Stretch: calculate the photon energy of green light at 530 nm in eV.