
measure the acceleration of a cart for several net forces at constant mass, graph acceleration against force, and use the graph to support Newton’s second law.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. You push an empty shopping cart and a full one with the same push. Which speeds up faster? Now you push the empty one twice as hard. What happens? Write a one-line prediction for each.
If you double the net force on a cart while its mass stays the same, its acceleration will
The investigation question. Newton’s second law claims that acceleration is proportional to net force when mass stays the same. HS-PS2-1 asks you to analyze data to support that claim. Today you collect the data.
The set-up. A low-friction cart (or a smooth toy car) sits on a level table. A string runs from the cart over a pulley, or a smooth rounded table edge, to a hanger holding washers. When released, the falling washers pull the cart. The pulling force is the weight of the hanging washers: weight = mg, so 0.050 kg of washers pull with 0.050 × 9.8 = 0.49 N.
The trick for constant mass. The cart and the hanging washers accelerate together, so the mass being accelerated is the whole system: cart plus all the washers. If you just added washers to the hanger, you would change both the force and the mass. Instead, start with all the washers on the cart, then move them one group at a time from the cart to the hanger. The total mass stays constant (say 0.600 kg) while the force increases. This is controlling a variable by design.
Measuring acceleration. The cart starts from rest and accelerates steadily, so the distance it travels is d = ½at2. Rearranged: a = 2d ÷ t2. Mark a 1.00 m run, release the cart from rest and time it. Worked example 1: a run of 1.00 m in 1.14 s gives a = 2(1.00) ÷ 1.142 = 2 ÷ 1.30 = 1.54 m/s2. Timing by hand has a reaction-time error of about 0.1–0.2 s, which matters a lot when the time is only one second; so time each run three times and average, or film it on a phone and read the time from the video.
What to expect. With a total mass of 0.600 kg and no friction, the prediction is a = F ÷ 0.600. Illustrative results from one trial run:
| Hanging mass (kg) | Net force (N) | Average time for 1.00 m (s) | a = 2d/t2 (m/s2) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.050 | 0.49 | 1.66 | 0.73 |
| 0.100 | 0.98 | 1.14 | 1.54 |
| 0.150 | 1.47 | 0.93 | 2.31 |
| 0.200 | 1.96 | 0.80 | 3.13 |
Worked example 2: reading the graph. Plot acceleration (y) against net force (x). The points fall close to a straight line. A best-fit line through these illustrative data has slope 1.63 and a small negative intercept (about −0.07 m/s2). A straight line means acceleration is proportional to force, the claim. The slope is 1 ÷ mass, so the mass from the graph is 1 ÷ 1.63 = 0.61 kg, close to the 0.600 kg on the balance. The small negative intercept is evidence of friction: a little of the pulling force goes to overcoming friction before the cart accelerates. Naming that is part of a good analysis.
Cause or just correlation? Because you chose the force and held everything else constant, a change in acceleration that follows a change in force is evidence of cause and effect. If you had only watched different carts roll by and noticed that faster-accelerating ones had bigger hangers, other differences (mass, friction) could explain the pattern. That would be a correlation, not proof of cause.
Lab procedure: Acceleration and Net Force at Constant Mass. Question: how does a cart’s acceleration change when the net force on it increases while the total mass stays the same? Materials: a low-friction cart or smooth toy car, a balance, 8–10 identical steel washers (about 25 g each) with a paper-clip hanger, string about 1.5 m long and a clamp-on pulley (or a smooth rounded table edge covered with tape), a meter stick, masking tape, a stopwatch or phone camera, a padded box and an end stop, goggles for every student.
| Hanging mass (kg) | Net force (N) | Time 1 (s) | Time 2 (s) | Time 3 (s) | Average time (s) | Acceleration (m/s2) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total mass of cart + all washers: ______ kg
No lab space? Use the provided video of the cart runs with an on-screen timer, or the PhET Forces and Motion: Basics simulation (Acceleration screen, friction off), to collect four force-acceleration pairs at constant mass.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 4 (CC BY 4.0).
Use your data table and graph. Check each calculation with a teammate.
Finish the lab analysis in your notebook.
Your line probably crosses the force axis slightly to the right of zero. Explain what this tells you about friction, and calculate the percentage difference between 1 ÷ slope and your measured mass.
Use your results to explain why a heavier vehicle needs a stronger crash cushion to stop in the same time.
Force causes acceleration, and mass resists it. Next class: what happens when two objects collide?
Exit ticket: identify the largest source of error in your timing and one way to reduce it.
Timing: Poly ran this lab over two 50-minute periods. Day 1: set-up and data. Day 2: graphing, the CER and the causal-versus-correlation discussion.
Materials (per team): cart, balance, 8–10 washers, hanger, string, pulley, meter stick, tape, stopwatch or phone, padded box, end stop, goggles.
Listen for: students adding washers without removing them from the cart; forcing the line through the origin and hiding the friction intercept; treating a single run as reliable.
Support / stretch: give pre-labeled axes and a partly filled table. Stretch: repeat with a heavier cart and compare slopes to show a ∝ 1/m.