
use Coulomb’s law to calculate electric forces, compare them with gravitational forces, and argue that both follow an inverse-square pattern while differing enormously in strength.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Rub an inflated balloon on your hair or a wool cloth and hold it above tiny bits of paper. Record what happens and write which force won: the balloon’s pull or the whole Earth’s gravity.
Two rubbed balloons hang side by side on threads. They will
A quick observation. Rub an inflated balloon on your hair or a wool cloth. Hold it above small bits of paper: they jump up to it. Tiny charges on the balloon lift the paper against the gravity of the entire Earth. Hang two rubbed balloons on threads side by side: they push apart. Bring a charged balloon slowly toward a thin stream of tap water: the stream bends. What force can be that strong from so little charge?
Charge. Rubbing moves electrons from one material to the other. The object that gains electrons becomes negative; the one that loses them becomes positive. Like charges repel and unlike charges attract. Charge is measured in coulombs (C); one electron carries −1.602 × 10−19 C, and a rubbed balloon typically carries somewhere around a few tens of nanocoulombs (illustrative), billions of electrons’ worth.
Coulomb’s law. The electric force between two charges is
Fe = k q1q2 ÷ r2
with k = 8.99 × 109 N·m2/C2. Look at the pattern: it is the same shape as Newton’s law of gravitation, with charge in place of mass. Both are inverse-square laws. Two differences matter. First, the sign: put in the charges with their signs, and like charges (+ × + or − × −) give a positive result, meaning repulsion, while unlike charges give a negative result, meaning attraction. Gravity’s result is always negative, because mass is never negative. Second, k is about 1020 times larger than G.
Worked example 1. Two small spheres each carrying 1.0 × 10−6 C (1 microcoulomb) are 0.10 m apart: F = 8.99 × 109 × 10−6 × 10−6 ÷ 0.102 = 0.90 N, positive, so they repel. Move them to 0.20 m and the force drops to one-quarter, 0.22 N.
Worked example 2: inside a hydrogen atom. The electron and proton are about 5.29 × 10−11 m apart. Electric attraction: 8.99 × 109 × (1.602 × 10−19)2 ÷ (5.29 × 10−11)2 ≈ 8.2 × 10−8 N. Gravitational attraction, with the electron’s mass 9.109 × 10−31 kg and the proton’s 1.673 × 10−27 kg: about 3.6 × 10−47 N. The electric force is about 2.3 × 1039 times stronger. That is why electric forces, not gravity, hold atoms and molecules together and explain every bond from Physical Science I.
Worked example 3: the ratio does not depend on distance. Divide the two laws: Fg ÷ Fe = (Gm1m2/r2) ÷ (kq1q2/r2) = Gm1m2 ÷ kq1q2. The r2 cancels. Move the electron twice as far from the proton and both forces drop to one-quarter, but their ratio stays about 1 to 2.3 × 1039.
So why does gravity rule the sky? Large objects are almost perfectly neutral: their positive and negative charges cancel, so their electric forces on distant objects cancel too. Mass never cancels, because there is no negative mass. So at the scale of planets and satellites, gravity is the force that is left. The balloon is the exception that proves the rule: a tiny imbalance of charge easily beats Earth’s gravity on a scrap of paper.
Building the argument. Make a comparison table: the two laws side by side, what each depends on, whether it can repel, and the numbers from the worked examples. Then argue a claim such as “Electric and gravitational forces follow the same mathematical pattern but electric forces dominate at the atomic scale while gravity dominates at the planetary scale.” Support it with the calculations and the balloon observations, and answer the counter-claim “gravity must be stronger, since it holds planets in orbit.”
| Gravitational force | Electric force | |
|---|---|---|
| Equation | ||
| Depends on | ||
| Can it repel? | ||
| Hydrogen atom value (N) | ||
| Dominates at which scale? |
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 18 (CC BY 4.0).
Calculate first, then argue.
Complete the comparison table and the argument.
Fill in the comparison table. Then explain, using the sign of each equation's result, why gravity always attracts but the electric force can attract or repel.
Same pattern, very different strengths. Next class: where the energy goes when objects interacting through fields move.
Exit ticket: why does the ratio of gravitational to electric force between two particles not change when they move farther apart?
Materials: balloons (latex-free available), wool cloth, paper bits, thread, a sink or bottle for a thin water stream, devices for the sim, calculators.
Note: 2 × 10−6 × 2 × 10−6 × 9.0 × 109 ÷ 0.09 = 0.40 N for the fill-in. Balloon static works poorly on humid days; have the sim ready.
Listen for: “gravity is the strongest force”; forgetting to square the distance; dropping the signs of the charges.
Support / stretch: give a two-column law card. Stretch: find the distance at which two 1 μC charges repel with 1.0 N.