
use the impulse relationship to explain how increasing stopping time reduces force, test padding materials, and break a collision-safety design problem into smaller problems.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Why do you bend your knees when you land from a jump? Write your answer, then try to use the word time in it.
An egg dropped from the same height lands on a hard floor and on foam. Its momentum change is
From momentum to force. Combine Newton’s second law with momentum. Acceleration is change in velocity over time, so F = ma = mΔv ÷ Δt. Multiply both sides by the time:
F × Δt = mΔv = change in momentum
The product of force and time is the impulse. For a given change in momentum, which is fixed by the mass and the speed at impact, force and stopping time trade off: stretch the time and the force shrinks in proportion. In a two-object collision, the same equal and opposite forces act for the same time, so the impulses on the two objects are equal and opposite: whatever momentum one loses, the other gains.
Worked example 1: the car. A 1,500 kg car at 25 m/s must lose 37,500 kg·m/s of momentum. Against rigid concrete in 0.10 s: F = 37,500 ÷ 0.10 = 375,000 N. Into a crash cushion over 0.50 s: 75,000 N, one-fifth. With steady deceleration the car travels half its speed times the time while stopping: 12.5 × 0.50 = 6.25 m of crushing cushion. (Illustrative figures.) Sand barrels work this way: each barrel the car hits flings its sand forward, taking some momentum, so the car slows in stages instead of all at once.
Worked example 2: the egg. A 60 g (0.060 kg) egg dropped from 1.5 m hits the floor at about 5.4 m/s (from v = √(2gh)), so its momentum is 0.060 × 5.4 ≈ 0.33 kg·m/s. If a hard floor stops it in 0.002 s, the average force is about 160 N; if foam stops it in 0.05 s, about 6.5 N. The same egg, the same drop, twenty-five times less force.
Where impulse shows up. Crumple zones in the front of a car are designed to fold, lengthening the stop for the passenger compartment. Airbags and seatbelts that stretch slightly spread a passenger’s stop over more time and more body area. Bike helmet foam crushes, stretching a head’s stop. A soccer player’s “soft” first touch pulls the foot back with the ball. In every case the momentum change is unchanged; the time is longer, so the force is smaller.
Breaking down a design problem (HS-ETS1-2). Engineers split a complex problem into smaller ones that can be solved and tested separately. For the design challenge: (1) How will the cushion attach to the cart? (2) Which material lengthens the stop most for its mass? (3) How will the egg be held so it does not hit the cart itself? (4) How will the design stay within the mass and size limits? Each sub-problem has its own quick test. The padding test answers sub-problem 2.
Lab procedure: Padding Materials and Impact Force. You cannot measure the force on an egg directly, but you can compare padding materials with a proxy: a larger force makes a deeper dent in clay. Question: which padding material most reduces the force of an impact? Materials: a slab of modeling clay about 2 cm thick on a tray; a 100 g mass that can be dropped safely (golf ball, or washers taped in a sealed bag); padding samples of equal area (4 layers of paper towel, bubble wrap, craft foam, folded cardboard); meter stick; ruler or toothpick marked in millimeters; masking tape; goggles.
| Surface | Padding mass (g) | Dent 1 (mm) | Dent 2 (mm) | Dent 3 (mm) | Average (mm) | Reduction per gram |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bare clay | 0 | n/a | ||||
| Paper towel | ||||||
| Bubble wrap | ||||||
| Craft foam | ||||||
| Folded cardboard |
No lab space? Use the provided class dent-depth data set and the PhET Collision Lab (Explore 1D, sticky collisions with a heavy ball).
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 8 (CC BY 4.0).
Use the impulse equation FΔt = mΔv and your dent data.
Analyze your padding data.
Claim: which material best reduces impact force? Evidence: average dent depths. Reasoning: explain with impulse how the material changes the stopping time. Then say which gives the best reduction per gram, and why that matters with a 100 g limit.
Dent depth is a proxy for force, not a force measurement. Name one way it could mislead you.
Same momentum change, longer time, smaller force. Next class we pull the unit’s science into one model and brainstorm cushions.
Exit ticket: a 1,000 kg car at 20 m/s stops in 0.40 s in a cushion. Find the average force, then explain what would happen to it if the cushion were half as long.
Timing: Poly ran this workshop over two 50-minute periods. Day 1: impulse and the padding test. Day 2: analysis and the sub-problem breakdown.
Materials (per team): clay slab on a tray, 100 g mass, four padding samples cut to equal area, meter stick, ruler or marked toothpick, balance, goggles.
Listen for: “soft materials absorb the momentum” (they spread the same momentum change over more time); confusing impulse with force.
Support / stretch: give a force-time card showing a tall narrow spike and a short wide hump with equal areas. Stretch: estimate the stopping distance of the egg on foam from d = ½vΔt.