
show what I learned about energy conservation, energy at large and particle scales, thermal energy transfer and energy-device design, using data questions, a scenario set and short constructed responses.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Back to the phenomenon: a pumped-storage plant returns less electricity than it uses. In two sentences, explain why this does not break conservation of energy.
When hot and cold water mix in a perfectly closed system, the energy lost by the hot water equals the energy gained by the cold water.
Engineers, this is the unit checkpoint. It has three parts: multiple choice on data, a scenario set where several questions share one situation, and short constructed responses scored 0 to 3. Show units and equations. Use g = 9.8 m/s2 and cwater = 4.18 J/(g·°C).
How a 0–3 answer is scored. 3: a correct claim, correct calculation or evidence, and reasoning that names the science idea. 2: correct claim and evidence with weak reasoning, or a small calculation slip. 1: a partly correct claim with little support. 0: incorrect or blank.
Data set A (sample data): mixing water in lidded foam cups.
| Mixture | Hot | Cold | Predicted final (°C) | Measured final (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 100 g at 44 °C | 100 g at 14 °C | 29.0 | 28.4 |
| 2 | 150 g at 44 °C | 50 g at 14 °C | 36.5 | 35.8 |
Data set B (sample data): a 0.060 kg ball dropped from 1.20 m. Rebound heights: 0.84 m, 0.59 m, 0.41 m.
Scenario (sample data) for questions 9–12. A community program compares two solar water heaters for outage kits. Each sits in 1,000 W/m2 sunlight for 1 hour (3,600 s) and heats 2,000 g of water. Heater M has a 0.50 m2 opening and warms the water by 43 °C; it costs more and takes an hour to build. Heater N has a 0.40 m2 opening and warms the water by 26 °C; it is cheap and takes 20 minutes to build.
Part A and the scenario set: answer on your own.
Part B: constructed responses, each scored 0–3.
13. Plan an investigation to show that thermal energy flows from hot to cold water until temperatures are equal. Define the system boundary and initial conditions, list the data you must collect, explain how you would reduce losses, and say how you would revise the plan if your energy lost and gained differed by more than 10%. (0–3)
14. Use data set B to build a computational model (a table or spreadsheet rule) for the ball's energy after each bounce. Use it to calculate the energy transferred out on the first bounce, and state one assumption that limits the model. (0–3)
15. Draw and explain a model of a solar oven that shows energy at the large scale (light, thermal energy of water and air) and at the particle scale, and use it to show that the total energy is conserved. (0–3)
16. A team's oven reached a 17 °C rise and 8% efficiency, and its window fogged. Describe how the team should evaluate it against the class criteria, propose one evidence-based change that improves its efficiency, and name the change's trade-off. (0–3)
Unit 3 complete, engineers. Next unit: waves, light and a few seconds of warning that can protect people.
Exit ticket: which question was hardest, and which idea from this unit do you want to practice again?
How confident are you that you can use energy conservation, energy models and thermal transfer to analyze systems and evaluate energy devices?
Materials: printed checkpoint with data sets A and B and the scenario, calculators, scoring guide for items 13–16.
Setup: about 40 minutes, then a short review. Item tags: 1–4 and 13 HS-PS3-4 (1a, 2a, 3a, 4a, 5a, 5b, 5c); 5, 6, 8 and 14 HS-PS3-1 (1a, 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b); 7, 12 and 15 HS-PS3-2 (1a, 2a, 3a, 3b); 9–11 and 16 HS-PS3-3 (1a, 1b, 2a, 3a, 3b, 4a). Use the tags to plan re-teaching.
Scoring 13–16 (3 points): 13 names lidded cups as a nearly closed system, masses and both temperatures, and a revision such as nesting cups or faster pouring; 14 uses f ≈ 0.70, gives 0.706 − 0.494 ≈ 0.21 J, and names the constant-fraction or no-air-resistance assumption; 15 links absorbed light to faster particle motion and balances energy in with all stores and losses; 16 compares 17 °C and 8% with the 20 °C and 10% targets and targets the fog.
Support / stretch: read items aloud on request and provide an equation card. Stretch: for the scenario, calculate how much larger N’s opening would need to be to match M’s temperature rise at N’s efficiency.