
Seconds of Warning
How can a few seconds of warning reach people before the shaking does, and how do we explain the waves and devices that make it possible?
The mystery: Earthquake early-warning systems can send an alert to phones a few seconds before strong shaking arrives, because the alert travels as a digital signal far faster than the slower seismic waves that do the damage.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
describe waves by amplitude, wavelength, frequency and speed, use v = fλ and wave speeds in different media, and calculate how much warning an earthquake alert can give.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Lightning flashes, and you hear the thunder a few seconds later. Write why the light reaches you first, and what the delay could tell you.
Which town gets more warning time from an earthquake early-warning system: one 20 km from the epicenter or one 120 km away?
The human impact first. Earthquakes are not only a physics problem. Large earthquakes around the world have cost many lives, and many families remember one. Some of you may have felt an earthquake or have family who lived through one. If this topic is hard for you, tell your teacher; you can work on the calculations with a partner.
The phenomenon. Several countries now run earthquake early-warning systems that can send an alert to phones, through apps and emergency alert channels, a few seconds before strong shaking arrives. The warning is not a prediction; the earthquake has already started. How can a message outrun the shaking? The answer is in the speeds of different waves.
What a wave is. A wave is a disturbance that transfers energy from place to place without transferring matter. A stadium wave moves around the stands, but each fan stays in their seat. Describe a repeating wave with: amplitude, the size of the disturbance; wavelength (λ), the distance between matching points on neighboring cycles; frequency (f), the number of cycles passing a point per second, in hertz (Hz); and speed (v).
The wave equation. In one second, f cycles pass, each one λ long, so the wave moves f × λ meters: v = fλ. Worked example 1: a sound wave at 440 Hz (the A that orchestras tune to) in air at 343 m/s has λ = 343 ÷ 440 = 0.78 m. The medium sets the speed; the source sets the frequency. Sound travels about 343 m/s in air at room temperature, about 1,480 m/s in water, and faster still in rock.
Seismic waves. An earthquake sends out two kinds of body waves. P waves (primary) are compressional: the rock is squeezed and stretched along the direction of travel, like a pulse along a spring. S waves (secondary) are shear waves: the rock moves side to side. In the crust, P waves typically travel about 6 km/s and S waves about 3.5 km/s (typical values; they vary with the rock). The P wave arrives first and usually shakes gently; the S wave and the surface waves that follow cause most of the damage.
Worked example 2: warning time. Take a town 60 km from the epicenter. P wave: 60 ÷ 6.0 = 10 s. S wave: 60 ÷ 3.5 = 17.1 s. Sensors near the epicenter detect the P wave within seconds, computers estimate the location and magnitude, and the alert travels through networks at nearly the speed of light, effectively instantly over 60 km. So the town could get up to about 7 seconds of warning before the S wave, minus a few seconds of processing. At 100 km: 16.7 s and 28.6 s, about 12 seconds apart. Close to the epicenter, the gap shrinks toward zero; people there may feel the shaking before any alert arrives.
Checking a claim. Suppose someone says “towns farther away get more warning because the alert travels farther.” The math shows the real cause: the S wave’s arrival time grows faster with distance than the P wave’s, so the gap grows. Using the equation, not just the pattern, separates the cause from a coincidence.
What a few seconds buy. Enough time to drop, cover and hold on; for a surgeon to lift a scalpel; for trains to begin slowing; for elevators to stop at the nearest floor. Your questions today: which parts of an early-warning system can we model in the lab (wave speeds, yes)? Which need data from a geological survey? Which need a model of how information travels?
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapters 13 and 14 (CC BY 4.0).
Work with a partner. Show the equation, the numbers and the units.
Start your Engineering Notebook.
Make a table of P and S arrival times for towns 20, 60, 100 and 150 km from an epicenter, and graph arrival time against distance for both waves on one set of axes. Shade the warning gap and explain why it grows with distance.
Add three questions to the class question board: one you could test in class, one that needs published data, and one that needs a model to answer.
Different waves travel at different speeds, and that gap is the warning. Next class we meet our client and set up the project.
Exit ticket: in two sentences, explain why a person 15 km from an epicenter might get no warning at all.
How confident are you that you can use <em>v</em> = <em>f</em>λ and wave speeds in different media to calculate warning times?
Materials: a long spring toy to demonstrate P- and S-type pulses, chart paper for the question board, devices for the PhET sim or printed values for the no-device version.
Sensitivity: some students or families may have lived through an earthquake or another disaster. Open with the human-impact paragraph, keep the tone calm, focus on how warning systems help people protect themselves, and let students pass on sharing.
Facts note: 6 km/s and 3.5 km/s are typical crustal values; real speeds vary with rock type and depth.
Listen for: “bigger waves travel faster”; “the system predicts earthquakes”; mixing km and m in the calculations.
Support / stretch: give a calculation frame (time = distance ÷ speed). Stretch: derive a formula for the warning gap as a function of distance, and find the distance at which the gap equals a 5 s processing delay.