
measure a ball’s rebound heights, build a spreadsheet model that calculates the energy of the ball after each bounce, and argue where the energy that leaves the ball goes.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A tennis ball dropped from 1 m bounces back to about half a meter. Write two places its “missing” energy could have gone.
A ball keeps 70% of its height on the first bounce. On the second bounce it will keep about
The observation. Drop a tennis ball from 1.00 m and it bounces back to perhaps 55–60 cm, then lower, then lower still, until it rolls to a stop. Energy is conserved, yet the ball clearly has less of it each bounce. Where does it go? This lesson uses a computational model, a spreadsheet, to track the energy of one part of the system when the energy changes of the other parts are known.
Measuring. Tape a meter stick to a wall. Drop the ball from 1.00 m and film it on a phone, then step through the video to read the height of each rebound at its highest point. Three drops, averaged. Illustrative data for one ball: 100, 72, 52 and 37 cm.
From heights to energy. At the top of each bounce the ball is momentarily at rest, so all its mechanical energy is gravitational potential energy, mgh, measured from the floor as the reference level. Worked example 1: for a 0.058 kg tennis ball dropped from 1.00 m: 0.058 × 9.8 × 1.00 = 0.568 J. If it rises to 0.55 m, it has 0.058 × 9.8 × 0.55 = 0.313 J. So 0.568 − 0.313 = 0.255 J left the ball during that one bounce.
Finding the pattern. Divide each height by the one before it. For the illustrative data: 72 ÷ 100 = 0.72, 52 ÷ 72 = 0.72, 37 ÷ 52 = 0.71. The ball keeps about the same fraction of its energy each bounce, here about 72%. That constant fraction is the heart of the model: if the fraction is f, each height is f times the previous height.
Worked example 2: building the spreadsheet model. Column A: bounce number 0, 1, 2, … Column B: height. Put the drop height in B2 (1.00), then in B3 type =B2*$E$1, where E1 holds the fraction f, and fill down. Column C: energy of the ball, =0.058*9.8*B2. Column D: energy transferred out at each bounce, =C2−C3. Change f in E1 and the whole model updates. A ball with f = 0.64 dropped from 100 cm is predicted to reach 64, 41, 26, 17 and 11 cm. Graph height against bounce number and overlay your measurements: if the model is good, the points sit on the curve.
Where the energy goes. During each bounce the ball and the floor squash and spring back. Not all the elastic energy returns: some becomes thermal energy (the ball and floor warm very slightly), and some becomes sound (you hear the bounce). A little is lost to air resistance on the way up and down. Add those up and you account for the whole difference. Energy is conserved for the system of ball, floor and air, even though the ball alone loses energy.
The model’s limits. The model assumes the same fraction every bounce and ignores air resistance. It will drift from your data if the ball warms up, if the floor is uneven or for very small bounces. A good argument names these assumptions.
Building the argument. Your claim should say where the ball’s energy goes and that total energy is conserved. Evidence: the measured heights, the energy calculations, and the model’s fit (the graph and the table should tell the same story). Reasoning: energy transfers between objects and into thermal energy and sound. Expect the counter-claim “the energy just runs out” and answer it by naming the other parts of the system.
Lab procedure: Bounce Heights and a Spreadsheet Model. Materials: two different balls (a tennis ball and a rubber or foam ball), a balance, two meter sticks taped vertically to a wall, a phone with slow-motion video, a laptop or tablet with a spreadsheet, goggles.
| Ball | Mass (kg) | Drop (m) | Bounce 1 (m) | Bounce 2 (m) | Bounce 3 (m) | Average f | Energy lost on bounce 1 (J) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.00 | ||||||
| 2 | 1.00 |
No lab space? Use the teacher’s provided bounce video with a scale, or the illustrative data above, and build the same model.
Use your data and your spreadsheet. Check formulas with a teammate.
Extend your model.
Add a column to your spreadsheet for the total energy transferred out of the ball so far. Show that the ball's energy plus the energy transferred out always equals the starting 0.568 J (or your ball's value), and state one limitation of the model.
The ball loses energy; the system does not. Next class: we build a device that captures energy from sunlight.
Exit ticket: name the two balls' retention fractions and explain which ball would make a better energy-storing toy, and why.
Materials (per team): two different balls, balance, two meter sticks and tape, a phone with slow-motion video, a device with a spreadsheet, goggles.
Setup: a hard, level floor next to a bare wall. Model the spreadsheet once on the projector, including the absolute reference $E$1.
Listen for: “the energy runs out”; subtracting heights instead of energies when masses differ; reading the bounce height from the top of the ball in one trial and the bottom in another.
Support / stretch: give a spreadsheet template with the formulas partly filled. Stretch: add an air-resistance correction column and see whether the fit improves for small bounces.