show what I have learned about how the Constitution divides and limits power, protects rights and has been shaped by courts, writings and symbols.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have been reading the Constitution like a civic expert for weeks. Read today’s passage first. You will use it as evidence on the checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to use evidence from the reading and from our unit.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
This checkpoint is your chance to show your thinking. It covers systems of government, limits, federalism, local government, the branches, checks, rights, court cases, famous writings, symbols and the framers. Read each question fully, and use the reading and your notes from the unit.
For written answers, use claim, evidence, reasoning. State your answer. Give a fact or quotation. Explain how it supports your answer.
Worked example 1: Zara answers a limits question. Question: how does the Bill of Rights limit government? Zara writes: “It lists things government may not do. The First Amendment says Congress shall make no law ‘abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.’ So even a law most people want cannot take that right away.”
Worked example 2: Caleb answers a federalism question. Question: what does the Tenth Amendment do? Caleb writes: “It reserves powers not given to the United States to the states or the people. This is one reason Pennsylvania can make its own rules about things like driver’s licenses.” He answers with a reason, not just a fact.
Stay nonpartisan. Some questions ask you to weigh two sides. You will be graded on your reasoning and evidence, not on which side you choose.
Part A. Answer on your own. Use the reading and your notes.
Part B. Answer each question in 2 to 4 sentences with evidence.
1. Explain the difference between a limited and an unlimited government. Use the Bill of Rights reading as evidence. Then compare one advantage and one disadvantage of a federal system and a unitary system.
2. Explain how local, state and national governments are each organized and how a local policy is made. Use Allegheny County as your example.
3. Compare the powers of Congress, the President and the federal courts, and explain one way each branch checks another.
4. Interpret how either Brown v. Board of Education or Mahanoy v. B.L. changed a principle of government. In Mahanoy, explain how the law protected an individual right and the common good.
5. Interpret how the Declaration of Sentiments or the Gettysburg Address affected civic life. Then explain why Juneteenth or Constitution Day was created and the ideals it honors.
6. Explain the role of one Pennsylvania framer from both a national and a Pennsylvania view. Then identify and explain two systems of government that are not a republic.
Look back through your answers. Add evidence wherever you can.
Which answer best shows your growth as a civic thinker? Why?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how the Constitution divides and limits power.
Pacing: reading 6 minutes, directions and examples 5, Part A 11, Part B 16, closure 2. Allow extended time as needed.
Evidence map: Part A: republic 5.3.9.K:1a; Articles 5.1.9.I:2a; County Council 5.3.9.A:1a; veto and override 5.3.9.B:2a; Marbury 5.1.9.L:1a; Wilson 5.1.9.H:1a; 1791 and fill-blank 5.1.9.I:1a. Part B: Q1 5.1.9.I:1a and 5.1.9.I:2a; Q2 5.3.9.A:1a; Q3 5.3.9.B:1a and 5.3.9.B:2a; Q4 5.1.9.L:1a and 5.1.9.J:1a; Q5 5.1.9.M:1a and 5.1.9.K:1a; Q6 5.1.9.H:1a and 5.3.9.K:1a.
Supports: read aloud, allow oral responses, provide sentence frames and a three-branch diagram template. Grade reasoning on any opinion question, not the side chosen.
Answer guide (3 points each): 3 = correct answer, specific evidence and clear reasoning; 2 = correct with limited evidence; 1 = partly correct or unsupported. Q1: limited government follows a constitution and protects rights; federal balances levels but invites disputes, unitary is uniform but may ignore local needs. Q2: Congress/President, General Assembly/Governor, County Council/County Executive; idea, public comment, vote, carried out. Q4: Brown ended separate but equal in public schools; Mahanoy limited school power over off-campus speech while allowing action on bullying or threats. Q6: autocracy is rule by one; oligarchy is rule by a few.
National Archives, The Bill of Rights: A Transcription · U.S. government work, public domain
Many Americans would only accept the new Constitution if rights were added to it. On September 25, 1789, the First Congress proposed 12 amendments. The states ratified ten of them by December 15, 1791. Those ten became the first ten amendments, which we call the Bill of Rights.
The National Archives copy is the version Congress sent to the states, so the amendments are numbered Article the third through Article the twelfth. The first proposal was never ratified. The second was finally ratified in 1992, more than 200 years later, as the Twenty-seventh Amendment.
The First Amendment protects freedom of religion, speech, the press, peaceful assembly and petitioning the government. Other amendments protect people accused of crimes, such as the right to a speedy and public trial and protection from unreasonable searches. The Tenth Amendment says powers not given to the national government, and not forbidden to the states, belong to the states or the people.
The document was signed by Frederick Augustus Muhlenberg of Pennsylvania, the first Speaker of the House, and by Vice President John Adams, who presided over the Senate.
Source: National Archives, The Bill of Rights: A Transcription (archives.gov)