explain Thomas Hobbes’s argument for why people need government, using a primary source excerpt and its context.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Thomas Hobbes lived through the English Civil War, a long war in the 1640s in which English people fought each other over who should rule. How might living through years of war shape a person’s ideas about government?
Hobbes imagined life with no government at all. What do you think he predicted?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
The state of nature. Philosophers in the 1600s asked a thought question: what would life be like before any government existed? They called this imagined condition the state of nature. Their answers became arguments for why government is necessary.
Hobbes’s argument in three steps. First, people are roughly equal in their ability to harm each other. Second, they compete for the same things and fear one another. Third, without a power over everyone, this fear becomes a “war of every man against every man.” So, Hobbes concluded, people agree to give up their freedom to a strong ruler in exchange for safety. This agreement is a kind of social contract.
Worked example 1: finding the claim and the reason. Keisha reads the excerpt and writes, “Claim: people need a government with great power. Reason: without a common power there is no law, and people live in fear.” She turned a hard text into a claim and a reason.
Worked example 2: sourcing the author. Omar notices that Hobbes published Leviathan in 1651, right after England’s civil war. He writes, “Hobbes had seen his country torn apart, which may explain why he valued order so highly.” Omar connected the author’s time to the author’s view, a key move in sourcing.
The catch. Hobbes’s solution was a ruler with no limits. Many Americans later agreed that people need government for safety, but they rejected unlimited power. Hamilton’s sharp criticism shows that the founders read Hobbes and argued with him. Next lesson, John Locke offers a different answer.
For our exhibit. A strong panel explains a thinker’s argument fairly, even if we do not agree with all of it. Visitors should understand why Hobbes’s ideas made sense to people who had lived through war.
Use the reading and the excerpt. Your team should agree before you answer.
Draft a mini panel for our exhibit.
In three or four sentences, explain Hobbes's argument to a visitor who has never heard of him. Include when he wrote, what he feared, and what he thought the solution was.
Hobbes said people need government for safety. Next, John Locke agrees government is needed but asks a new question: what rights does government exist to protect?
Exit ticket: what is one strength and one weakness of Hobbes's solution?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, panel draft 5.
Accuracy: the phrase “war of every man against every man” is Hobbes’s own wording in Leviathan chapter XIII. Present Hobbes fairly; he wanted peace, not cruelty.
Likely misconceptions: that the state of nature was a real time in history Hobbes studied (it is a thought experiment); that Hobbes supported a particular modern party or leader. Avoid modern comparisons.
Supports: give a three-box organizer: fear, solution, cost. Stretch: ask students to find the line in the excerpt that best shows Hobbes’s reasoning.
Answer guide: strong panels mention 1651 and the civil war, the fear of conflict without a common power, and the solution of a strong ruler. Exit tickets might name safety as a strength and unlimited power as a weakness.
National Constitution Center, Founders' Library: Leviathan, or the Matter, Forme and Power of a Common Wealth Ecclesiastical and Civil (1651) · Copyright National Constitution Center; 1651 excerpt is public domain; summarized in our own words with a link
Thomas Hobbes was an English thinker who lived from 1588 to 1679. Besides writing about government, he translated ancient Greek works, including Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey. His most famous book is Leviathan, published in 1651. A leviathan is a giant sea creature, and Hobbes used it as a symbol for a powerful government.
The National Constitution Center explains that Americans knew Hobbes best for two ideas. The first is his picture of humanity’s natural state, meaning how people would live with no government. The second is his defense of absolute sovereignty, which means a ruler whose power has no limits.
In the excerpt, Hobbes argues that where there is no common power, there is no law, and where there is no law, nothing is unjust. People would live in constant fear. Life would be lonely, poor, harsh and short.
Not every founder agreed with him. In 1775 Alexander Hamilton attacked Hobbes’s view that right and wrong are made by people, calling it an “absurd and impious doctrine.”
Source: National Constitution Center, Founders' Library: Leviathan, or the Matter, Forme and Power of a Common Wealth Ecclesiastical and Civil (1651) (constitutioncenter.org)