compare John Locke’s argument for government with Hobbes’s and explain the ideas of natural rights and consent of the governed.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. List three things that you believe belong to you simply because you are a person, not because anyone gave them to you.
Locke said people in a state of nature are…
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Same question, different answer. Hobbes and Locke both asked what life would be like without government. Hobbes saw fear and war. Locke saw people who were free and equal but whose rights were not secure. For Locke, government is needed to protect rights better, not to take them away.
Three big ideas. Natural rights: people have rights to life, liberty and property by nature. Consent of the governed: a government’s power is fair only if the people agree to it. Limited government: government may not do whatever it wants; it must stay within its purpose.
| Question | Hobbes | Locke |
|---|---|---|
| State of nature | War of all against all | Free and equal, but rights at risk |
| Why government? | Safety and order | Protect natural rights |
| Limits on rulers | Few or none | Rulers who abuse power lose authority |
Worked example 1: comparing two thinkers. Aiden writes, “Both Hobbes and Locke thought people form governments by agreement. But Hobbes’s people give up almost all their freedom, while Locke’s people keep their natural rights and can replace a government that abuses them.” He named a similarity and a difference.
Worked example 2: tracing an idea forward. Grace reads Locke’s idea that no one can be ruled “without his own consent.” She remembers “We the People” from the Preamble. She writes, “The Preamble says the people establish the Constitution, which fits Locke’s idea of consent.” She is careful to say the ideas fit, not that she has proof the writers copied Locke.
Other Enlightenment voices. Locke was part of the Enlightenment, a period when thinkers used reason to question old ideas. Another, the French writer Montesquieu, argued in 1748 that liberty is safest when government power is separated into different branches. We will meet that idea again in Unit 2.
Use the reading and the comparison table. Talk before you answer.
Make a comparison card for the exhibit.
Create a two-column card titled “Why Government?” with Hobbes on one side and Locke on the other. Give each thinker's view of the state of nature, his reason for government, and his view of limits on rulers.
Thinkers gave reasons for government. But ideas about limiting rulers are much older than Locke. Next we travel back to 1215 and Magna Carta.
Exit ticket: in one sentence, what does consent of the governed mean, and where have you already seen this idea?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, comparison card 5.
Accuracy: the Two Treatises were printed in late 1689 with 1690 on the title page; use 1690 as the source does. Montesquieu’s The Spirit of the Laws was published in 1748. Locke’s “property” often meant life, liberty and estate together.
Likely misconceptions: that Locke’s ideas applied to everyone in his own time (many people, including enslaved people and women, were denied these rights); that “consent” means every person votes on every law.
Supports: pre-fill the table’s row labels. Stretch: ask where Locke’s right to replace a government might be risky, and why he set conditions on it.
Answer guide: strong open responses cite fear and safety from Hobbes and rights and consent from Locke. Either choice is acceptable if supported by evidence. Exit tickets should define consent and link it to “We the People.”
National Constitution Center, Founders' Library: A Letter Concerning Toleration (1689) and Two Treatises on Government (1690) · Copyright National Constitution Center; 1690 excerpt is public domain; summarized in our own words with a link
John Locke was an English thinker who lived from 1632 to 1704. His Two Treatises on Government appeared in 1690. The National Constitution Center notes that from 1760 to 1800, Locke was one of the authors Americans cited most often when writing about government.
Locke described the state of nature differently from Hobbes. He said people are naturally free to run their own lives and are equal, with no one holding more power than another. Reason teaches that no one should harm another person’s life, health, liberty or possessions. These are natural rights, rights people have just by being human.
Locke argued that no one can be placed under another’s political power without his own consent, or agreement. When people join together in a community, they agree that the majority’s decisions will bind everyone.
Locke also set a limit. If lawmakers try to destroy the people’s property or rule by arbitrary power, they lose their authority. The people may then set up a new government. Before the American Revolution, colonists looked to Locke on natural rights and the right to revolution.
Source: National Constitution Center, Founders' Library: A Letter Concerning Toleration (1689) and Two Treatises on Government (1690) (constitutioncenter.org)