compare confederal, federal and unitary systems and explain which powers belong to the national government, the states, or both.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Who decides the age to get a driver’s license: Congress or the Pennsylvania government? Who prints the money in your pocket? Make two quick guesses, then read.
Which level of government do you think prints U.S. money?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three ways to share power. A unitary system keeps nearly all power in the national government, which can create or change local governments as it chooses. A confederal system, like the Articles of Confederation, keeps most power in the member states and gives the center little. A federal system, like our Constitution, divides power between the two levels.
Each system has trade-offs. Unitary systems can act quickly and keep laws the same everywhere, but local needs may be ignored. Confederal systems protect local control, but the center may be too weak to defend the nation or pay its debts. Federal systems try to balance both, but people may argue over which level should decide.
The text sets the line. The Tenth Amendment says, “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” Article VI says the Constitution and federal laws made under it are “the supreme Law of the Land.”
Worked example 1: Aaliyah sorts powers. Aaliyah sorts five cards. Declare war: federal. Set driver’s license rules: state, because it is public safety inside Pennsylvania. Collect taxes: shared. Make money: federal. Ratify amendments: state. She notes which card the reading lists directly and which one she reasoned out.
Worked example 2: Ravi compares systems. Ravi writes: “Under the Articles, Congress could not collect taxes, so it had to ask the states for money. Under the Constitution, Congress can tax. That shows the change from a confederal system to a federal one.”
Fair wording. Americans have argued since 1787 about how much power each level should have. Our page explains the rules and notes that people disagree; it does not take a side.
Use the reading and the Tenth Amendment.
Write the comparison section of the page.
In 60 words or fewer, compare one advantage and one disadvantage each of confederal, federal and unitary systems.
Choose one power and explain why the framers gave it to the federal government, the states, or both. Use the reading as evidence.
Federalism means a new voter has more than one government to know and more than one place to take part.
Exit ticket: name one thing your state government does that affects your daily life and one thing the federal government does.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 13, comparison writing 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that states are simply branches of the national government; that federal means the same thing as national (here it names the shared system); that shared powers mean the two levels always agree.
Supports: pre-printed power cards for sorting; a Venn diagram template. Stretch: find one power in Article I, Section 8 and one limit on states in Article I, Section 10, and copy each exactly.
Answer guide: unitary: quick, uniform, but may ignore local needs; confederal: local control, but weak center (Articles could not tax); federal: balance, but disputes over who decides. Driver’s licenses are a state power students may reason out from public safety; accept a clear reason.