analyze the Mayflower Compact as an early example of colonial self-government and explain how its meaning grew over time.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Your class is dropped off at a camp, but it is the wrong camp. No counselors are there, and the camp’s rules do not apply to you. What would your group need to do on the first night?
Why did the Mayflower passengers write an agreement before going ashore in 1620?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Self-government. Self-government means people make their own rules and choose their own leaders. In England’s colonies, self-government grew partly because the king and Parliament were an ocean away. Colonists often had to solve problems themselves.
Two early examples. In 1619, Virginia’s House of Burgesses met as the first elected lawmaking assembly in England’s American colonies. In 1620, the Mayflower Compact created a self-governing body at Plymouth. Both were limited: only some men took part, and Native nations who already governed these lands had no voice in them.
Worked example 1: sourcing the Compact. Ryan asks who, when and why. Who: 41 adult male passengers. When: November 1620, before going ashore. Why: they lacked legal permission for where they landed and feared disorder. He concludes, “The Compact was a practical fix that also showed a big idea: government by agreement.”
Worked example 2: watching a meaning change. Lena notices that the reading says later writers interpreted the Compact “to suit their views.” She writes, “The Compact’s meaning grew over time. In 1620 it solved an immediate problem. By 1802, John Quincy Adams treated it as a famous example of a social compact.” Lena kept the two time periods separate.
Connecting the ideas. The Compact fits Locke’s idea of consent, but it came 70 years before Locke’s book. That tells us the practice of governing by agreement grew in the colonies alongside the philosophy, not only from it.
For our exhibit. Visitors may have heard the Mayflower Compact called the beginning of American democracy. Our panel can show what it actually did, who signed it, who was left out, and why people later saw it as a symbol.
Use the reading. Point to the evidence for each answer.
Write a museum label.
Write a 60-word museum label for the Mayflower Compact. Include what it did in 1620, one limit, and why people later treated it as a symbol.
Self-government grew in many colonies. Next we turn to our own state and William Penn’s plans for Pennsylvania, including the Great Law of 1682.
Exit ticket: how does the Mayflower Compact connect to the idea of consent of the governed?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, label 5.
Accuracy: the signing date is November 21, 1620 (November 11 Old Style). The Compact stayed the basis of Plymouth’s government until the colony joined Massachusetts in 1691. The House of Burgesses first met in 1619. The Wampanoag people already lived and governed in the region; avoid any suggestion the land was empty.
Likely misconceptions: that the Compact was a constitution; that all passengers signed; that it created democracy for everyone.
Supports: give a who/when/why organizer. Stretch: ask why political writers in the late 1700s would want to claim the Compact for their side.
Answer guide: labels should include the practical purpose, the 41 signers or exclusion of women, servants who did not sign, and Native nations, and the later symbolic meaning. Exit tickets should link agreement to forming a government.
Library of Congress, In Custodia Legis blog, Nathan Dorn, The 400th Anniversary of the Mayflower Compact (2020) · U.S. government work, public domain
In November 1620, the Mayflower reached the waters off Cape Cod. The ship held 102 people, about a third of them children. The passengers had a patent, or official permission, to settle somewhere south of Long Island Sound. They had landed far to the north, and the trip south seemed too dangerous.
Some passengers feared that without official approval, people might ignore rules or leave. So 41 of the 50 adult men on board signed an agreement. They promised to join together into a “civil Body Politick,” a community that governs itself, and to make laws and choose officers for the colony’s general good.
The Library of Congress points out that the Compact does not set out a full plan of government. Its first purpose was practical. The earliest surviving copy was printed in London in 1622, and William Bradford later copied it into his history of Plymouth.
The Compact’s fame grew in the late 1700s. Writers read it to fit their own views. In 1802, John Quincy Adams praised it as a rare example of a social compact, people agreeing together to form a government.
Source: Library of Congress, In Custodia Legis blog, Nathan Dorn, The 400th Anniversary of the Mayflower Compact (2020) (blogs.loc.gov)