plan an exhibit panel around one big idea about why people create government, using criteria that keep it accurate, fair, clear and connected.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A neighbor walks into our exhibit and asks, “Why do we even need a government?” You have one minute to answer. Jot two sentences, then read today’s short reading and see if the Declaration of Independence would agree with you.
According to the Declaration of Independence, where does a government get its fair power?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Civic investigators, welcome to Build. In the first half of this unit you studied why people create governments and which older ideas shaped ours. Now your evidence goes to work. We are building The Roots of Government Exhibit for a real audience: families, neighbors and new voters at an East Allegheny community civics night.
Our exhibit has five team panels. Why Government? explains the arguments of Thomas Hobbes, John Locke and the Declaration. Roots of the Rule of Law covers Magna Carta, the English Bill of Rights and the Mayflower Compact. Pennsylvania’s Changing Constitutions follows our state from the Great Law of 1682 to the Constitution of 1968. Who Holds Power? compares systems of government. Ideas That Traveled shows how American ideas reached other nations. A shared Document Timeline and a Flag Display tie the room together.
A big idea is a claim, not a topic. “John Locke” is a topic. “Locke’s idea that government needs the consent of the people shows up in the Declaration of Independence” is a big idea. A visitor can learn it, and you can prove it with a source.
Worked example 1: Maya’s big idea. Maya first writes, “Government is important.” Almost everyone already agrees, and it proves nothing. She checks the reading and revises: “The Declaration says people create governments to protect their rights, and a government’s fair power comes from the people’s consent.” Now she can point to the exact paragraph.
Worked example 2: DeShawn’s panel plan. DeShawn’s team takes Why Government? Their plan lists a headline, a main label, one document card, one “Then and Now” card and a source list. Hobbes argued that without government, life would be dangerous and short. Locke argued that people have natural rights to life, liberty and property, and that government should protect them. DeShawn marks which evidence note supports each card, and he puts a question mark on any card that still needs a source.
Our criteria and constraints. The class will judge every panel by these rules all through Build and Prove It.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every claim traces to a named primary or official source. |
| Fair | We name people who were left out of rights, show real disagreements fairly and never tell visitors which side to take. |
| Clear | A neighbor can read it without help. |
| Connected | It links an old idea or document to U.S. or Pennsylvania government today. |
| Constraints | One panel per team. Main label of 120 words or fewer. Every quotation copied exactly and credited. Nothing that supports or opposes a party, candidate or current policy. The flag displayed by the Flag Code. No costumes or role-play. |
Work with your team and keep the reading open.
Fill in your own panel plan.
List the five parts of your panel: headline, main label, document card, Then and Now card and sources. Next to each, write the evidence you already have or put a question mark.
In 3 to 4 sentences, explain one major argument for why people need government. Use Hobbes, Locke or the Declaration as your evidence.
A strong exhibit makes a promise to the audience: we will tell you something true, and we will show you how we know.
Exit ticket: the Declaration promised rights to “all men,” but many people were left out in 1776. How will your panel be fair about that?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, team guided practice 13, panel plan 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that a topic is the same as a claim; that the Declaration created the U.S. government (it explained independence; the Constitution came later); that “all men are created equal” applied to everyone in 1776.
Supports: offer the frame “Visitors should know that ___ because ___ (source).” Provide the criteria table as a handout; it stays on every team table through 1.27. Part 1 introduced these same five panel names and criteria in 1.01, and its cards feed these panels. Stretch: ask students to write the question their big idea answers.
Answer guide: a strong big idea is one arguable sentence tied to a named source. The open response on the necessity of government (assesses 5.1.9.A:1a) should name one argument (Hobbes: order and safety; Locke: protecting natural rights; Declaration: securing rights by consent) and explain it with evidence. Fairness exit tickets should name a group, such as enslaved people or women, and say the panel will state who was excluded.
National Archives, Declaration of Independence: A Transcription · U.S. government work, public domain
On July 4, 1776, the Continental Congress approved the Declaration of Independence. It explained to the world why thirteen colonies were breaking away from Great Britain.
The second paragraph states a theory, or big explanation, of government. It says that all men are created equal and are born with rights that cannot rightfully be taken away. The writers called these rights unalienable and named life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. People create governments to protect those rights. A government gets its fair power from the consent, or agreement, of the people it governs.
Then the Declaration makes a bold claim. When a government works against these goals, the people have the right to change it or replace it. The writers add that people should not do this for small or short-lived reasons.
Most of the rest of the document lists complaints against King George III. The colonists used these complaints as evidence that the king had abused his power again and again.
In 1776 these promises did not reach everyone. Enslaved people, women and Native nations were denied many of these rights, and Americans have argued about the meaning of “all men are created equal” ever since.
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal” Declaration of Independence, National Archives transcription
Source: National Archives, Declaration of Independence: A Transcription (archives.gov)