analyze how English documents from Magna Carta to the English Bill of Rights of 1689 influenced rights in American government.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. The Eighth Amendment says “excessive bail shall not be required” and bans “cruel and unusual punishments.” Where do you think the writers got that wording?
Which older document used almost the same words?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A century of conflict. In the 1600s, English kings and Parliament, England’s lawmaking body, fought over power. A civil war broke out in the 1640s, the same war Hobbes lived through. Later, in 1688, English leaders invited William of Orange to England and King James II fled. In early 1689, Parliament offered the throne to William and Mary. This change is called the Glorious Revolution.
The English Bill of Rights, 1689. Before taking the crown, William and Mary accepted a list of rights that Parliament then passed into law. It said the monarch could not collect taxes or keep an army in peacetime without Parliament’s consent. It called for free elections of members of Parliament and freedom of speech in Parliament’s debates. It protected the right to petition, or make requests of, the monarch. It banned excessive bail and cruel and unusual punishments.
Worked example 1: finding an echo. Tomas places the English Bill of Rights next to the U.S. Bill of Rights. He finds the right to petition in the First Amendment and the ban on cruel and unusual punishments in the Eighth. He writes, “American writers reused English protections they already trusted.”
Worked example 2: noticing a limit. Ava notices that the English Bill of Rights limited the monarch but gave Parliament great power. She asks, “Who limits Parliament?” She learns that Americans later answered that question differently, with a written constitution that limits every part of government, including the legislature.
A chain of documents. Magna Carta (1215) put the king under the law. Coke and the Petition of Right (1628) defended that idea. The English Bill of Rights (1689) made Parliament’s role in taxes and armies the law. Colonists carried these ideas across the Atlantic and used them when they argued with Britain.
For our exhibit. A chain or timeline helps visitors see that American rights grew from a long history, not from a single moment.
Use the reading and the mini lesson chain. Talk it through before you answer.
Draft a chain panel.
Draw a four-link chain: Magna Carta, Coke, English Bill of Rights, U.S. Bill of Rights. Under each link, write one sentence about what it added.
English ideas crossed the ocean. Next we see colonists governing themselves, starting on a ship off Cape Cod in 1620.
Exit ticket: why did colonists believe they had the right to argue against laws like the Stamp Act?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, chain panel 5.
Accuracy: the English Bill of Rights received royal assent in December 1689; its rights limited the crown, not Parliament. The U.S. Bill of Rights was ratified in 1791. The Petition of Right (1628) is named in the mini lesson as context.
Likely misconceptions: that the English Bill of Rights protected freedom of religion for all (it did not); that Americans invented every right in their Bill of Rights.
Supports: provide a side-by-side chart of three English rights and three American amendments. Stretch: ask why Americans wanted a written constitution that limits the legislature too.
Answer guide: good links include petition (First Amendment), excessive bail and cruel and unusual punishment (Eighth), and due process (Fifth). Exit tickets should mention the charters’ promise of English rights or Coke’s arguments.
National Archives, Magna Carta Legacy · U.S. government work, public domain
Magna Carta did not reach America by itself. The National Archives explains that the colonies’ charters, written in the early 1600s, promised settlers and their heirs “all the rights and immunities of free and natural subjects.” In other words, colonists were told they kept the rights of English people.
A key link was Sir Edward Coke. He served as Attorney General and Chief Justice in England and led members of Parliament against King Charles I. Coke argued that even kings must obey the common law, the law built up from court decisions over many years. In 1628 he told Parliament that Magna Carta “will have no sovereign,” meaning no ruler stands above it.
Coke’s books on English law were widely read by American law students, including John Adams, Thomas Jefferson and James Madison. When Britain passed the Stamp Act in 1765, colonists used Coke’s arguments against it.
Colonial lawmakers also wrote liberties from Magna Carta and from the English Bill of Rights of 1689 directly into their own laws. The page concludes that these English protections have a direct legacy in the American Bill of Rights.
Source: National Archives, Magna Carta Legacy (archives.gov)