plan an explainer page for new voters with a clear big idea, an exact quotation from the Constitution and criteria that keep it accurate and fair.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Picture a neighbor who just turned 18, or an adult who just became a U.S. citizen. They ask you, “Who actually makes the laws, and who carries them out?” You have one minute. What would you say? Read today’s short reading, then decide.
The original Constitution has seven articles. Which branch do you think Article I is about?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Civic writers, welcome to Build. In the first half of this unit you investigated how the Constitution divides and limits power. Now that evidence goes to work. Our audience is real: new voters and new citizens in our community who want a plain guide to how their government works.
Our explainer has the five sections we chose at the end of Make Sense. Structure shows what kind of government the Constitution creates and who wrote it. Separation and Checks shows the three branches and how each checks the others. Federalism shows national, state and local government, including Allegheny County. Rights shows the limits on government and the court cases that test them. Change shows amendments and the famous words and symbols that moved people to act. Each team owns one section, and each section answers one question a new voter might ask.
A big idea is a claim, not a topic. “Congress” is a topic. “Congress makes federal laws, but the President and the courts can check it” is a big idea. A reader can learn it, and you can prove it.
Worked example 1: Marisol’s big idea. Marisol first writes, “The President is the most powerful person.” She checks Article I and Article II and revises: “The President carries out laws, but Congress writes them.” Now her claim matches the text, and she can quote Article II, Section 1, which begins “The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America.”
Worked example 2: Devon’s page plan. Devon’s team takes Separation and Checks. Their plan lists a headline, a main text, one exact quotation, one diagram and a source list. Beside each part they write which note from their evidence folder supports it. Any part with no evidence gets a question mark, so they know what to look up.
Our criteria and constraints. Every page will be judged by these rules. Notice the fair rule: our job is to explain how government works, not to tell anyone how to vote.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every fact traces to a named source. Quotations from the Constitution are copied exactly from the National Archives transcription, with article and section. |
| Clear | A new voter can read it without help. Hard words are defined. |
| Fair | It explains how government works without telling anyone how to vote or which party to support. Real disagreements are shown from more than one side. |
| Useful | It shows a new voter where power sits and how a person can take part. |
| Complete | It names who holds the power, what the power is, what limits it, and gives one real example. |
| Constraints | One section per team. Main text of 150 words or fewer. At least one exact quotation. Use roles, such as “the President” or “a county council member,” instead of the names of people in office now. |
Work with your team and keep the reading open.
Fill in your own page plan.
List the five parts of your page: headline, main text, exact quotation, diagram and sources. Next to each, write the evidence you already have or put a question mark.
Compare the powers of Congress, the President and the federal courts in three short sentences, one per branch. Use the first sentence of Articles I, II and III as your evidence.
A strong explainer makes a promise to its reader: we will tell you something true, and we will show you where it comes from.
Exit ticket: what is one thing a new voter might wrongly believe about who makes laws? How could your page help?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 8, team guided practice 14, page plan 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that the President makes laws; that the Supreme Court is part of Congress; that it is fine to modernize the spelling of a quotation. If part 1 of this unit used slightly different words for the criteria, post both versions side by side and point out that they ask for the same things.
Supports: provide a three-column organizer (branch, article, first sentence) and the frame “New voters should know that ___ because ___.” Stretch: ask students to find one power in Article I, Section 8 and copy it exactly.
Answer guide: a strong big idea is one arguable sentence tied to a named article. The comparison should say Congress makes laws, the President carries them out, and the courts decide cases. Assign the five sections so each team owns one; use two teams per section in larger classes. Nonpartisan rule: students explain roles and processes and never endorse a party, candidate or policy.
National Archives, The Constitution of the United States: A Transcription · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Archives keeps the original Constitution and posts a word-for-word copy, called a transcription, online. The transcription keeps the old spelling and capital letters of the parchment, so you will see words like “chuse” and “defence.” When we quote it, we copy it exactly.
The Constitution opens with the Preamble, which begins “We the People.” It lists goals such as justice, peace at home, defense and liberty. Then come seven articles.
The first three articles each open with one key sentence. Article I gives the power to make laws to Congress, which has two parts: a Senate and a House of Representatives. Article II gives the power to carry out laws to a President. Article III gives the power to decide cases to one Supreme Court and to lower courts that Congress creates.
Later articles explain how states relate to each other, how the Constitution can be changed and why it is the highest law in the land. At the end, delegates signed it on September 17, 1787. Eight signers came from Pennsylvania, including Benjamin Franklin, James Wilson and Gouverneur Morris.
“All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives.” (Article I, Section 1)
Source: National Archives, The Constitution of the United States: A Transcription (archives.gov)