explain how Marbury v. Madison established judicial review and evaluate how it completed the system of checks and balances.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Two classmates disagree about what a school rule means. Who should decide: one of them, the person who wrote the rule, or someone neutral? Why?
Does the Constitution clearly say the Supreme Court can strike down a law passed by Congress?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Interpreting the Constitution. The Constitution’s words are short and general. Real cases ask what they mean in specific situations. In Article III, the “judicial Power” is placed in the courts. Marbury v. Madison explained that this includes deciding when a law conflicts with the Constitution.
A clever decision. Marshall gave the other side what it wanted: Marbury did not get his job. But in doing so, Marshall claimed a lasting and important power for the courts. A small dispute produced a big principle.
Worked example 1: CER on a case. Isabella writes: “Claim: Marbury v. Madison made the courts a full partner in checks and balances. Evidence: the Court declared part of the Judiciary Act unconstitutional, the first time it had struck down a federal law. Reasoning: now courts could check Congress and the President when they go beyond the Constitution.”
Worked example 2: checking the checker. Mateo asks, “Who checks the courts?” He lists: the President nominates judges, the Senate confirms them, Congress can impeach judges, and the people can amend the Constitution through Article V. Judicial review is strong, but it is not unlimited.
Interpretation changes. Courts sometimes reverse earlier decisions. Dred Scott (1857) denied citizenship to Black Americans; the Fourteenth Amendment later overturned that result. This is why we call landmark cases interpretations: people and courts can revisit them. In Part 2 we study major court decisions more deeply.
Fair disagreement. Americans have long debated how courts should read the Constitution: by the words’ meaning when written, or with more attention to changing times. Our explainer can name this debate without taking a side.
Use the reading and the challenge quotation.
Write a claim, evidence and reasoning paragraph.
Answer: How did Marbury v. Madison change the balance among the three branches? Use at least two facts from the reading and one check on the courts.
We know who interprets the Constitution. Next we ask why Americans honor it with symbols and a holiday.
Exit ticket: should our explainer say the Supreme Court has the final word on the Constitution? Explain carefully.
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 9, mini lesson 10, practice 8, writing 9.
Accuracy: facts and the quotation come from the National Archives milestone page. The Dred Scott detail is from the same page; the Fourteenth Amendment’s role is standard history. Keep the landmark-case discussion brief; 5.1.9.L is developed in Part 2.
Nonpartisan note: present interpretive approaches neutrally. Do not connect them to current justices or parties.
Likely misconceptions: that Marbury won his job; that judicial review means courts can rule on anything without a case.
Answer guide: the exit ticket should note that amendments, appointments and later rulings can change outcomes, so “final” needs care.
National Archives, Milestone Documents, Marbury v. Madison (1803) · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1801, as his term ended, President John Adams signed a commission, an official paper, naming William Marbury a justice of the peace. The new Secretary of State, James Madison, did not deliver it. Marbury sued and asked the Supreme Court to order Madison to hand it over.
Chief Justice John Marshall wrote the Court’s opinion in 1803. He said Marbury had a right to the commission. But the Court still would not order Madison to deliver it. Why? The part of a 1789 law, the Judiciary Act, that let Marbury bring his case straight to the Supreme Court gave the Court more power than the Constitution allowed. So that part of the law was unconstitutional, and the Court could not use it.
This was the first time the Supreme Court declared a law passed by Congress and signed by the President to be unconstitutional. The Constitution does not state this power directly. The power of courts to decide whether actions of other branches follow the Constitution is called judicial review.
The National Archives says the decision completed the system of checks and balances by giving the courts a clear role. The Court did not strike down another federal law until the Dred Scott case in 1857.
“A Law repugnant to the Constitution is void.”
Repugnant here means in conflict with. Void means having no legal force.
Source: National Archives, Milestone Documents, Marbury v. Madison (1803) (archives.gov)