explain how American political ideas and an American leader helped shape the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and write a clear exhibit label about it.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In 1948, after a world war, delegates from many nations wrote one statement of rights for every person on Earth. Predict: would they want it to sound American?
Who chaired the United Nations Human Rights Commission that drafted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Ideas that traveled, part two. In 1789 American ideas helped shape France’s declaration. In 1948 an American leader helped shape a declaration for the whole world. Both stories belong on our Ideas That Traveled panel.
What came from American traditions? The Universal Declaration lists civil and political rights that Americans know from the Bill of Rights, such as freedom of speech and religion and a fair trial. It opens with the idea that all people are born free and equal in dignity and rights, an idea that echoes the Declaration of Independence.
What did not? The Universal Declaration also lists economic and social rights, such as education. Delegates from many nations, including China, Lebanon, France and others, shaped its words. So the fair claim is that American ideas and an American leader helped shape it, alongside many others.
Worked example 1: Hannah’s first label (sample). “The U.S. wrote the human rights rules for the world in 1948.” Her team marks it inaccurate: the U.S. did not write it alone, and it is not a set of rules nations must obey.
Worked example 2: Hannah revises. “In 1948 the United Nations adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Eleanor Roosevelt of the United States chaired the commission that drafted it. Rights like free speech and fair trials echo the U.S. Bill of Rights, but delegates from many nations shaped the final words. Source: National Park Service.” Now the label is accurate, fair, clear and connected.
Label rules. Keep sentences under 20 words when you can. Use active voice: say who did what. Explain any hard word. End with your source.
Use the reading, Hannah’s labels and the label rules.
Finish the Ideas That Traveled main label.
Write a main label of 120 words or fewer that explains the effects of U.S. political ideas on other nations. Use both examples: France in 1789 and the Universal Declaration in 1948. Include one limit or other influence.
Which career from today's career box would help most with our exhibit? Explain.
Ideas travel, mix and come back changed. A fair label shows all three.
Exit ticket: name one effect American political ideas have had on another nation or on the world, with evidence.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, career box 3, guided practice 11, label 7, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that the Universal Declaration is a law every nation must follow; that the United States wrote it alone; that influence means control. The mini lecture’s note that delegates from China, Lebanon and France helped shape the wording is established history (for example, P. C. Chang, Charles Malik and René Cassin); the NPS page names C. L. Hsia of China as the delegate who nominated Roosevelt.
Supports: give a label frame: “In ___, ___. ___ shaped it by ___. Like the U.S. ___, it ___. But ___.” Stretch: find one right in the Universal Declaration that is not in the U.S. Bill of Rights.
Answer guide: main labels (assess 5.4.9.C:1a) include both examples with dates, one effect each (France adopted a rights declaration influenced by U.S. documents; the UN adopted a declaration shaped in part by an American chair and Bill of Rights ideas) and one limit or other influence. Career BLS figures come from the Occupational Outlook Handbook page for archivists, curators and museum workers (bls.gov/ooh/education-training-and-library/curators-museum-technicians-and-conservators.htm).
National Park Service, Eleanor Roosevelt National Historic Site, Eleanor Roosevelt and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights · U.S. government work, public domain
In December 1945, President Harry Truman named Eleanor Roosevelt to the U.S. delegation to the new United Nations. In 1946 delegates chose her to lead the group that would form a Human Rights Commission. A delegate from China, C. L. Hsia, nominated her. The permanent commission then elected her chair, and she also led the smaller group that drafted the declaration.
The work was hard. Drafting took 85 working sessions, and Cold War tensions between nations caused repeated delays.
Roosevelt wanted the declaration written in clear language. She also did not want it to look like an American or Western document, so that people of every nation could accept it. She persuaded the U.S. State Department to include economic, social and cultural rights, such as education and an adequate standard of living, not only political and civil rights.
The UN General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in December 1948. It has thirty articles. It was not a law that nations had to obey. Roosevelt hoped instead that it would have “moral force,” the power to guide what nations think is right.
Source: National Park Service, Eleanor Roosevelt National Historic Site, Eleanor Roosevelt and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (nps.gov)