explain how American political ideas influenced France’s Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. An idea is not like a package; no one has to mail it. How could an idea about rights travel from Philadelphia to Paris in the 1780s? List two ways.
Who did the Marquis de Lafayette ask for comments on his French declaration of rights in July 1789?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Today we start the Ideas That Traveled panel. The standard asks us to explain the effects American political ideas have had on other nations. Influence is a claim, so it needs evidence: a letter, a draft, a shared phrase or a person who carried the idea.
The France connection. Lafayette fought beside Americans and knew their ideas firsthand. He drafted a declaration of rights with Jefferson’s advice. On August 26, 1789, France’s National Assembly adopted the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen. The Library of Congress says it followed the model of the U.S. Declaration of Independence and the Virginia Declaration of Rights.
Influence is not copying. French writers had their own Enlightenment thinkers, and Americans had borrowed from English and French ideas too. Ideas moved in more than one direction. A careful label says American ideas shaped or influenced a document, not that Americans wrote it.
Worked example 1: Grace’s evidence chain. Person: Lafayette fought in the American Revolution. Contact: he consulted Jefferson in Paris. Document: the July 9, 1789 letter asks for Jefferson’s observations on his bill of rights. Effect: France adopted a declaration of rights on August 26, 1789. Each link names a source.
Worked example 2: Omar checks the limits. Omar adds a “Be careful” note: Jefferson’s attempts to spread republican ideas in Russia, Poland, Greece and South America had mixed results. Omar’s label stays honest: American ideas inspired many people, but each nation’s struggle was its own.
Connect to the roots. The same idea we studied with Locke, that people have natural rights and government should protect them, is the idea that traveled.
Use the reading and Grace’s evidence chain.
Draft the France card for the Ideas That Traveled panel.
Write a card of 60 words or fewer explaining how American ideas influenced France in 1789. Use the word “influenced,” not “copied.”
Which idea from Locke or the Declaration do you think traveled to France? Explain your choice.
Ideas travel with people: soldiers, diplomats and letter-writers.
Exit ticket: why is “influenced” a more accurate word than “copied” for this story?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 13, card 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that Jefferson wrote the French declaration; that influence runs only one way; that the French Revolution was simply a copy of the American Revolution. Jefferson later wavered during the most violent phases of the revolution, and Americans split over it (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State).
Supports: provide a four-link chain organizer. Stretch: compare the opening of the French declaration with the Declaration of Independence’s second paragraph.
Answer guide: this lesson develops 5.4.9.C; formal assessment comes in 1.21. The open response on which idea traveled is a check on 5.1.9.A:1a. Strong chains name Lafayette, Jefferson, the July 9, 1789 letter and the August 26, 1789 adoption. Idea choices may be natural rights, government by consent or people as the source of power, with a reason.
Library of Congress, Thomas Jefferson exhibition: A Revolutionary World · U.S. government work, public domain
In the 1780s Thomas Jefferson lived in Paris as the U.S. minister, or official representative, to France. As France moved toward revolution in 1789, Jefferson became a strong supporter. He let his home serve as a meeting place for reformers led by the Marquis de Lafayette.
Lafayette was a French noble who had fought in the American Revolution and admired George Washington. In Paris he became Jefferson’s friend and partner. While Lafayette drafted a French declaration of rights in July 1789, he often consulted Jefferson. In a letter of July 9, 1789, Lafayette asked for Jefferson’s observations on “my bill of rights” before presenting it to France’s National Assembly.
Jefferson believed the Declaration of Independence would be a beacon, or guiding light, for liberty around the world. In 1795 he predicted that the “ball of liberty” would roll around the world.
His influence had limits. He also tried to share republican ideas with people in Russia, Poland, Greece and new South American nations, with mixed results. In 1823 he warned John Adams that winning self-government in Europe and Spanish America would take a long and bloody struggle.
Source: Library of Congress, Thomas Jefferson exhibition: A Revolutionary World (loc.gov)