compare confederal, federal and unitary systems and explain why the framers replaced the Articles of Confederation with a federal system.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Imagine a club where every member must agree before anything changes, and the club cannot collect dues. What problems might it have?
Under the Articles of Confederation, could Congress collect taxes?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three ways to arrange power. In a confederal system, strong states share a weak central government, as under the Articles. In a unitary system, the central government holds most power and local governments get only what it gives them. Many nations, such as France, are unitary. In a federal system, the national government and state governments each have their own powers. The Constitution created a federal system, called federalism.
Who does what? The Constitution gives some powers to the national government, such as coining money and declaring war. Some powers are shared, such as taxing. The Tenth Amendment says: “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” States run things such as public schools and driver’s licenses.
Advantages and disadvantages. A confederal system protects local control but can leave the nation weak. A unitary system can act quickly and uniformly but may ignore local needs. A federal system balances both, but it can create confusion or conflict about who is responsible.
Worked example 1: sorting a power. Mei asks who prints money. She remembers Article I lets Congress coin money, so she sorts it as national. Then she sorts “setting school calendars” as state and local.
Worked example 2: weighing a system. Darnell writes: “Under the Articles, Congress could not tax, so it could not pay for the war. A federal system fixed that, but states kept many powers, so Pennsylvania still makes its own school laws.” He named a disadvantage, a fix and a trade-off.
Supremacy. When national and state laws truly conflict, Article VI makes the Constitution and federal laws made under it supreme. Federalism is a partnership, but it has a tiebreaker.
Use the reading and a three-column system chart.
Make a federalism sort for our explainer.
Sort these into national, state or shared: coining money, declaring war, running public schools, issuing driver's licenses, collecting taxes, making treaties. Then write two sentences explaining one advantage of federalism for a new voter.
We saw why the framers moved from confederation to federalism. Next we look inside Pennsylvania’s own three branches.
Exit ticket: what was the biggest weakness of the Articles, in your view, and how did the Constitution address it?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 9, mini lesson 10, chart 12, closure 5.
Accuracy: dates and weaknesses come from the National Archives milestone page. The Tenth Amendment is copied from the National Archives Bill of Rights transcription. France as a unitary example is general knowledge; any current unitary nation works.
Likely misconceptions: that “federal” means only the national government (in everyday speech it often does, but a federal system includes both levels); that states have no real power.
Supports: pre-sorted examples with picture cues. Stretch: find the Article I clause that lets Congress coin money.
Answer guide: national: money, war, treaties; state: schools, licenses; shared: taxes.
National Archives, Milestone Documents, Articles of Confederation (1777) · U.S. government work, public domain
In June 1776, the Second Continental Congress formed a committee to plan a union of the colonies. John Dickinson of Delaware was the main writer. Congress adopted the Articles of Confederation on November 15, 1777, but all 13 states had to approve them. Arguments over representation and western lands delayed that until Maryland approved on March 1, 1781.
The Articles created a confederation, a loose union of independent states. Each state kept every power not clearly given to Congress, and each state had one vote in Congress no matter how many people lived there. The Articles did give the nation its name, “The United States of America.”
The national government was weak. Congress could not tax and had little power over trade. It struggled to pay for the war, paper money lost value, and Congress could do little to settle disputes between states. Changing the Articles required every state legislature to agree.
In May 1787, delegates met in Philadelphia to revise the Articles. By mid-June they decided to design a whole new government instead.
“With the states retaining considerable power, the central government had insufficient power to regulate commerce.”
Source: National Archives, Milestone Documents, Articles of Confederation (1777) (archives.gov)