show what I have learned about why people create governments, the roots of American and Pennsylvania government, rights, systems of government, the Flag Code and American ideas abroad.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have been working like a civic investigator for weeks. Read the passage first. You will use it as evidence on the checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to use evidence from the reading and from our unit.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
This checkpoint is your chance to show your thinking. It covers every target in our unit: why government, the rule of law, principles, Pennsylvania’s documents, U.S. founding documents, two lists of rights, the Flag Code, systems of government and ideas that traveled.
For written answers, use claim, evidence, reasoning. State your answer. Give a fact, date or document. Explain how the fact supports your answer.
Worked example 1: Isaiah answers a change question. Question: how did voting change in 1776? Isaiah writes: “Voting expanded. The reading says the 1776 constitution let all tax-paying free men vote, while earlier plans required property. This shows more men gained a voice, though women and enslaved people still could not vote.”
Worked example 2: Ava answers a systems question. Question: was the 1776 plan more democratic than the 1790 plan? Ava writes: “Yes in one way. Members faced voters every year, so the people had frequent control. But critics said it lacked balance because it had no governor or upper house.” She gives both sides with evidence.
Be fair and precise. When a question asks you to contrast, name both things. When it asks about influence, name the source of the idea and the place it reached.
Part A. Answer on your own. Use the reading and what you remember.
Part B. Answer each question in 3 to 5 sentences with evidence.
1. Explain one major argument for why people need government. Compare Hobbes with Locke or the Declaration of Independence.
2. Describe one historical example that shows the importance of the rule of law. Then analyze how Magna Carta, the English Bill of Rights or the Mayflower Compact influenced American government.
3. Analyze one principle (constitutional government, federalism or classical republicanism). Explain how it shapes both the U.S. and Pennsylvania governments. Use today's reading if it helps.
4. Interpret one significant change in Pennsylvania's governing documents between the Great Law of 1682 and the Constitution of 1968. Then contrast one right in the Pennsylvania Constitution with the U.S. Constitution.
5. Analyze the Articles of Confederation, the Federalist and Anti-Federalist debate and the U.S. Constitution. What problem did each step try to solve?
6. Contrast the rights and responsibilities of citizens in an autocracy, an oligarchy, a democracy and a republic. Use at least two systems in detail.
7. Describe two National Flag Code rules and explain how American political ideas have influenced another nation or the world.
Look back through your answers. Add evidence wherever you can.
Which answer best shows your growth as a civic investigator? Why?
How confident are you that you can I can explain why people create governments and where our ideas of government came from.
Pacing: reading 6 minutes, directions and examples 4, Part A 10, Part B 18, closure 2. Allow extended time as needed; Part B may be split across two days.
Evidence map: Part A: Locke 5.1.9.A:1a; rule of law 5.1.9.B:1a; Section 27 5.1.9.F:1a; Flag Code 5.1.9.G:1a; republic 5.2.9.A:1a and 5.1.9.C:1a; France 5.4.9.C:1a; 1776 governor 5.1.9.D:1a. Part B: Q1 5.1.9.A:1a; Q2 5.1.9.B:1a and 5.1.9.E:1a; Q3 5.1.9.C:1a and 5.1.9.C:2a; Q4 5.1.9.D:1a and 5.1.9.F:1a; Q5 5.1.9.E:2a; Q6 5.2.9.A:1a; Q7 5.1.9.G:1a and 5.4.9.C:1a.
Supports: read aloud, allow oral responses and provide sentence frames and the criteria handout. Keep the four-box systems chart available for students with that accommodation.
Answer guide (3 points each): 3 = correct answer, specific evidence and clear reasoning; 2 = correct with limited evidence; 1 = partly correct or unsupported. Q1: Hobbes, order and safety; Locke, natural rights and consent. Q3: federalism, both levels have constitutions; constitutional government, both limit power in writing; classical republicanism, elected representatives and civic duty. Q4: for example 1838 disenfranchisement or 1874 elected judges; contrast Section 5, 27 or 28. Q5: Articles too weak; Constitution stronger; Anti-Federalists won a Bill of Rights. Q6: must address both rights and responsibilities. Q7: Flag Code sections 7, 8 or 9; France 1789 or the Universal Declaration 1948.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776 · Pennsylvania state government page; retold in our own words with a link to the source
In July 1776, delegates met in Philadelphia to write a constitution for the new state of Pennsylvania. Benjamin Franklin led the meetings. George Bryan, James Cannon and Franklin appear to have been the main authors. They finished on September 28, 1776. The constitution was not sent to the people for a vote.
The plan put most power in a one-house legislature, called unicameral. Its members were elected for one-year terms. There was no governor with a veto and no upper house. Instead, a twelve-member Supreme Executive Council ran the government. A Council of Censors, elected every seven years, checked whether the government had followed the constitution.
The document listed rights, including freedom of religion, trial by jury, freedom of the press and the right to bear arms. It allowed all tax-paying free men to vote. Earlier plans had limited voting to men who owned property.
Some have called it the most democratic constitution in America. Critics said it lacked balance. Required oaths kept some opponents from taking part. After the Revolutionary War, Pennsylvania replaced it in 1790 with a new constitution that balanced government power and citizens’ rights more evenly.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776 (phmc.state.pa.us)