interpret significant changes in Pennsylvania’s constitutions and revise our panels so they are accurate, fair, clear and connected.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Remember our unit puzzle: Pennsylvania has had five constitutions, while the United States has used one since 1789. Write your best answer so far in one sentence. Today’s reading adds new evidence.
Did every new Pennsylvania constitution expand voting rights?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision studio. Today you revise with evidence. Our Pennsylvania panel must explain the unit puzzle, so its Document Timeline must be accurate and fair.
Pennsylvania’s documents, in order. Great Law (1682). Charter of Privileges (1701). Constitution of 1776: a one-house Assembly, one-year terms, no governor and a twelve-member Supreme Executive Council. Constitution of 1790: a governor and a two-house legislature, much like the new U.S. Constitution. Then 1838, 1874 and 1968.
Change is not always progress. In 1838 the new constitution limited voting to white men, taking the vote from free Black Pennsylvanians who had voted in some counties. Black Pennsylvanians resisted. Robert Purvis and others published the Appeal of Forty Thousand Citizens Threatened with Disfranchisement in 1838. Black men in Pennsylvania did not regain the vote until the Fifteenth Amendment in 1870.
Worked example 1: Caleb interprets a change. Caleb writes: “The 1874 constitution gave the governor a four-year term and a line-item veto. This was significant because it changed how power was balanced between the governor and the legislature.” He uses the word significant and explains why.
Worked example 2: Zara revises for fairness. Zara’s draft timeline said, “Each new constitution gave people more rights.” She checks the reading and revises: “Some changes expanded the vote and elected offices, but the 1838 constitution took the vote from free African Americans, who fought to win it back.”
Revision checklist. Read your panel against each criterion. Accurate: does every date and claim have a source? Fair: are people who lost rights named? Clear: can a neighbor read every sentence? Connected: does the panel link to government today? Constraints: is the main label 120 words or fewer?
Check the timeline facts, then revise.
Revise and finalize.
Interpret two significant changes in Pennsylvania's governing documents between 1682 and 1968. For each, say what changed and why it mattered, and name who gained or lost.
Revise your Two Lists of Rights card (or a teammate's) so it clearly contrasts one Pennsylvania right with the U.S. Constitution. Paste the before and after versions.
A state that rewrites its constitution is a state still arguing about who holds power, and who gets a voice.
Exit ticket: update your answer to the unit puzzle. Why has Pennsylvania rewritten its constitution so many times?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, revision 12, closure 2.
Flex lesson. This is the revision flex lesson. Teams that finish early can extend with the 1776 Council of Censors: should a state have a body that checks the constitution? Present both sides.
Likely misconceptions: that history always moves toward more rights; that the U.S. Constitution has never changed (it has 27 amendments; Pennsylvania rewrote whole documents); that 1968 replaced everything (many Article I rights carried forward).
Sources: 1776 details come from PHMC’s Our Documentary Heritage page on the Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776; 1838 and 1874 changes from PHMC RG-5. The Purvis Appeal and the Fifteenth Amendment (1870) are established history. Nuance on judges: an 1850 amendment to the 1838 constitution first made Pennsylvania judges elected; the 1874 constitution carried that forward, which is why RG-5 lists it. Accept either framing from students.
Answer guide: interpretations (assess 5.1.9.D:1a) name two dated changes with significance and who gained or lost, for example 1790 adds a governor and two-house legislature; 1838 disenfranchises free African Americans; 1874 elects judges. Revised contrast cards (assess 5.1.9.F:1a) cite a Pennsylvania section and a U.S. amendment or the absence of one.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Pennsylvania State Archives, RG-5: Records of the Constitutional Conventions and the Council of Censors · Pennsylvania state government page; retold in our own words with a link to the source
The Pennsylvania State Archives keeps the records of the conventions that wrote the state’s constitutions. A convention is a meeting of delegates chosen to write or change a constitution.
The 1776 constitution created a Council of Censors. It was elected every seven years to check whether the other branches had followed the constitution. It could call a convention to change it. In 1789, however, the General Assembly called a convention on its own, and the 1790 constitution removed the Council of Censors.
The 1838 constitution cut the governor’s power to appoint officials, made more offices elected and shortened terms of office. It also took away the vote from free African Americans.
The 1874 constitution made judges, the state treasurer and the auditor general elected by the people. It created the office of lieutenant governor, gave the governor a four-year term and a line-item veto, and limited special laws written for one place or person. It also set a limit on state debt.
A fifth convention met in 1967 and 1968. Its work produced the constitution Pennsylvania uses today.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Pennsylvania State Archives, RG-5: Records of the Constitutional Conventions and the Council of Censors (phmc.state.pa.us)