review the unit by explaining the roles of Pennsylvania framers and comparing the powers of Congress, the President and the federal courts.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The Constitution was written in Philadelphia, and eight of its signers came from Pennsylvania. Name any one of them you remember, then read short profiles from the National Archives.
According to the reading, which Pennsylvania delegate gave the most speeches at the Convention?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review lab rules. Today you rotate through four stations: Framers, Branches, Checks, and Systems. At each station, answer from evidence, not memory alone. Bring your notes from the whole unit.
National and Pennsylvania views. From a national view, the framers built a stronger central government than the Articles allowed. From a Pennsylvania view, delegates like Wilson then had to persuade their own state to ratify, and Pennsylvania ratified on December 12, 1787, the second state to do so.
Worked example 1: Camila explains a role. Camila writes: “James Wilson helped write the Constitution on the Committee of Detail and then led Pennsylvania’s ratification drive. So he shaped both the document and its approval.” She names two roles and cites the Archives.
Worked example 2: Jordan compares powers. Jordan makes a chart. Congress: makes laws, approves the budget, declares war, the Senate confirms judges. President: carries out laws, commands the armed forces, vetoes bills, nominates judges. Federal courts: interpret laws, apply them to cases, and decide whether laws break the Constitution.
Watch for mix-ups. The President does not make laws. The Supreme Court does not choose its own members. Congress does not run trials of ordinary crimes. Each mistake mixes up two branches.
This is a flex lesson. If your class is ready, spend extra time at the station where you feel least sure.
Station work. Answer on your own, then compare with your partner.
Self-check against the unit targets.
For each of these, rate yourself 1-3 and write one piece of evidence: systems of government; limited government; federalism; local government; branches; checks; rights and the common good; court cases; famous writings; symbols and days; framers.
Write one question you still have. Find the answer in your notes or a reading, and write where you found it.
Review is not repeating. It is checking what you know against what the evidence says.
Exit ticket: which station was hardest, and what will you study before the checkpoint?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 5, four stations 6 minutes each, self-check 6, closure 2. Flex lesson: use it as written, or shorten stations and add re-teaching where exit tickets show gaps.
Likely misconceptions: that Franklin wrote the Constitution; that every framer agreed with every part; mixing up which branch nominates and which confirms judges.
Supports: station cards with sentence frames; a partially filled branch chart. Stretch: research one non-signing Pennsylvania voice from the ratification debate.
Answer guide: framer comparisons should name a role for each (for example, Gouverneur Morris drafted wording; Wilson shaped the draft and led ratification; Franklin eased tensions). Branch charts as in Jordan’s example. The December 12, 1787 ratification date is basic established knowledge and is not on the reading page.
National Archives, America's Founding Documents: Founding Fathers, Pennsylvania · U.S. government work, public domain
Pennsylvania sent eight delegates to the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in 1787. The National Archives profiles each one, and their roles were very different.
Gouverneur Morris spoke more than any other delegate, 173 times, and served on several committees, including the Committee of Style. The Archives says he apparently drafted the final wording of the Constitution. James Wilson rarely missed a session and served on the Committee of Detail. His influence was probably second only to James Madison’s, and he later led the drive to get Pennsylvania to ratify.
Benjamin Franklin, the oldest delegate, missed few sessions despite poor health. He disliked parts of the finished plan, but he lent his fame to it, calmed tempers and helped settle disputes.
Others played quieter parts. George Clymer spoke rarely but well. Jared Ingersoll missed no sessions but seldom spoke. Robert Morris attended nearly every meeting but spoke only twice. Thomas Mifflin and Thomas Fitzsimons attended regularly without major speeches. A framer’s role could be writing, arguing, calming others, or persuading voters back home.
Source: National Archives, America's Founding Documents: Founding Fathers, Pennsylvania (archives.gov)