The Roots of Government Exhibit
Why do people create governments, and which older ideas and documents shaped the governments of the United States and Pennsylvania?
The mystery: Pennsylvania has had five constitutions since 1776, while the United States has used one Constitution since 1789. Why would a state rewrite its constitution so many times?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
describe Pennsylvania’s first constitution from a primary-source record and explain why our exhibit must answer the puzzle of Pennsylvania’s five constitutions with evidence.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. The United States has used one Constitution since 1789. Pennsylvania has had five: 1776, 1790, 1838, 1874 and 1968. Write one reason a state might decide to throw out its rulebook and write a new one.
Why do you think Pennsylvania wrote its first constitution in 1776?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Welcome, civic investigators. This unit gives you a real job. You will build The Roots of Government Exhibit for families, neighbors and new voters in the East Allegheny community. Visitors will want to know why people create governments and where the ideas behind our governments came from. They will trust what you show them, so every panel must rest on evidence.
Our five team panels. In Part 2 each team builds one panel: Why Government?, Roots of the Rule of Law, Pennsylvania’s Changing Constitutions, Who Holds Power? and Ideas That Traveled, plus a shared Document Timeline and a Flag Display. The cards and drafts you write in Part 1 become evidence for those panels. Every panel will be judged on four criteria (accurate, fair, clear and connected) and a short list of constraints, such as a main label of 120 words or fewer.
Our puzzle. The United States has used one Constitution since 1789 and changed it with amendments. Pennsylvania has written five constitutions. Why would a state keep rewriting its rulebook? By the end of this unit you will be able to answer that question with evidence.
Key words. A government is the group of people and institutions with the authority to make and enforce rules for a society. A constitution is the basic plan of a government. It sets up the parts of government, says what each part may do, and often lists rights the government must respect.
Worked example 1: turning a detail into evidence. Priya reads that the 1776 constitution had a one-house legislature and no governor. She writes, “Pennsylvania’s first government put most power in one lawmaking body, so there was little to check it.” She named the detail, then explained what it shows.
Worked example 2: separating a fact from a judgment. Mateo writes that the 1776 constitution “was a failure.” His partner asks, “Says who?” Mateo checks. The reading says critics thought it weakened government, and it also calls it the most democratic in America. Mateo rewrites: “Some leaders saw it as too weak, while others valued how many men it let vote.” Now his sentence is fair to both views.
Our promise to visitors. We will say who made each source and when. We will separate facts from opinions. When people in the past disagreed, or historians disagree today, we will show both sides fairly and let visitors think for themselves.
Keep the reading open. Work with a partner and point to the sentence that gives each answer.
Start your investigator’s notebook and the class Wonder Board.
Write two details from the reading. After each, finish this sentence: “This shows that Pennsylvania's first government…”
Write one question you wonder about why governments exist or why Pennsylvania rewrote its constitution. Put it on a sticky note for the Wonder Board.
We met our puzzle and our audience. Next time we look at the purposes of government, starting with the first words of the U.S. Constitution.
Exit ticket: what is one thing a constitution does, and why would visitors need to know it?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, Wonder Board 5.
Accuracy: some sources say Pennsylvania has had four constitutions, because a 1968 law calls the 1874 document as amended through 1968 the Constitution of 1968. This course uses the common count of five. The 1776 document let tax-paying free men vote; it did not let women vote. Note this if students overstate “most democratic.”
Likely misconceptions: that a constitution and the government are the same thing; that a newer constitution is always better; that one document explains everything about a government.
Supports: offer the frame “The reading says ___, which shows ___.” Stretch: ask why the convention may not have asked voters to approve the document.
Answer guide: strong responses use a specific detail (one house, no governor’s veto, one-year terms, test oaths) and connect it to a weakness or a strength. Exit tickets should name a job of a constitution such as setting up government, limiting power or listing rights.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage: Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776 · Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (PHMC) web page; summarized in our own words with a link
In the summer of 1776, a convention met in Philadelphia. A convention is a meeting called to make big decisions, such as writing a constitution. It met from July 15 to September 28, 1776. Benjamin Franklin chaired it. George Bryan, James Cannon and Franklin are seen as its main authors. The people did not vote to approve the finished document.
Before this, Pennsylvania had been run under frames of government that favored property owners and a small group of mostly Quaker leaders. The new constitution let tax-paying free men vote and listed citizens’ rights in detail. The state archives page calls it the most democratic constitution in America at the time.
Power rested in a unicameral legislature, meaning a lawmaking body with only one house. Members served one-year terms. Instead of a governor, a twelve-member Supreme Executive Council ran the government. Every seven years voters chose a Council of Censors to check whether the constitution was being followed.
Critics said the one-house design, with no governor’s veto, made government weak and unbalanced. Oaths also kept opponents out of office. In 1790 a new constitution replaced it.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage: Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776 (phmc.state.pa.us)