interpret what Pennsylvania’s earliest governing documents established and how they limited government power.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. In 1681, King Charles II gave William Penn a huge piece of land in America, partly to pay off a debt the king owed Penn’s father. If you were given land to found a colony, what would be the first three laws you would make?
Penn was a Quaker, a member of a religious group that was often punished in England. What do you think his first laws said about religion?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A colony with a plan. King Charles II granted the Pennsylvania Charter on March 4, 1681. It let Penn make laws “with the advice, assent, and approbation of the freemen,” as long as they fit English law. In 1682 Penn wrote a Frame of Government, and the first legislature passed the Great Law. In 1701 the Charter of Privileges gave the elected Assembly more power and served as the colony’s plan until 1776.
Limits on power. Look at the tax rule in the Great Law: money could be raised only by law, with the freemen’s consent, for one year at a time. That is the rule of law and consent in action, in our own state, eight years before Locke’s book.
Worked example 1: reading a law as evidence. Camila reads that laws had to be printed and taught in schools. She writes, “This shows Penn’s government wanted people to know the law, which is part of the rule of law: laws must be public.”
Worked example 2: seeing both strength and limit. Elijah first writes that the Great Law gave “total religious freedom.” Then he rereads it. Only people who acknowledged God were protected, and officeholders had to be Christian. He revises: “The Great Law offered more religious freedom than most places then, but it still excluded some people.”
The land was not empty. The Charter granted land where the Lenape (Delaware), Susquehannock and other Native nations already lived and governed themselves. The Charter even described its aim of drawing “the Savage Natives” to English ways, language we now see as disrespectful. Penn made treaties with the Lenape, but later colonial leaders took land unfairly, as in the Walking Purchase of 1737.
For our exhibit. Pennsylvania’s governing story does not start in 1776. Our timeline should begin with the Charter and the Great Law and show what carried forward.
Use the reading and the mini lesson. Agree as a team.
Begin the Pennsylvania timeline for our exhibit.
Start a timeline strip with 1681, 1682 and 1701. For 1682, list two rights or limits from the Great Law and one way it excluded people.
We have seen English and colonial roots. Next we examine a question historians still debate: did the Haudenosaunee Confederacy influence American government?
Exit ticket: name one idea from the Great Law that still shapes government today.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, timeline 5.
Accuracy: the Charter facts (March 4, 1681; laws with the freemen’s assent) come from the PHMC page on the Pennsylvania Charter. The Walking Purchase is listed on PHMC’s documentary heritage pages. The Great Law did not follow the Frame of Government’s procedures exactly, because the legislature had not yet organized into two houses.
Likely misconceptions: that Penn’s Pennsylvania had full religious freedom; that Penn “bought” all land fairly forever; that Native nations disappeared. The Lenape and other nations continue today.
Supports: give a plain-English list of five Great Law rules. Stretch: ask students to compare the Great Law’s tax rule with the English Bill of Rights.
Answer guide: timeline entries should list rights such as jury trials, limits on taxes or protection of conscience, and an exclusion such as the Christian requirement for officeholders. Exit tickets may name juries, public laws or tax limits.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage: The Great Law · Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (PHMC) web page; summarized in our own words with a link
William Penn arrived in America on October 30, 1682. That December, Pennsylvania’s first legislature, or lawmaking body, met at Chester, which was also called Upland. From December 4 to 7 it passed a set of laws known as the Great Law. Penn acted as proprietor and governor “with the advice and Consent” of deputies chosen by the freemen. The legislature also turned down twelve laws Penn had proposed.
The Great Law said no one who acknowledged one Almighty God could be harmed for his or her religious beliefs or forced to support a church. But officeholders and voters had to profess belief in Jesus Christ.
Other laws set up trials by twelve-man juries in civil cases. The death penalty was limited to premeditated murder, with houses of correction for other crimes. Taxes could be raised only by a law made by the government and the freemen, and no tax could last more than a year. Bribery in elections was banned.
The laws were to be printed and taught in the colony’s schools, so people could know the rules they lived under.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage: The Great Law (phmc.state.pa.us)