interpret how Pennsylvania’s Constitution of 1790 changed the 1776 plan and explain how principles such as checks and balances shaped the change.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Recall the 1776 constitution from lesson 1.01: one lawmaking house, no governor and a Council of Censors. If you were redesigning it in 1789, what one change would you make first?
What do you think the 1790 constitution added?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Checks and balances. A system of checks and balances gives each part of government ways to limit the others. The 1776 plan had few: one house made laws, and no governor could veto them. The 1790 plan added a Senate to check the House, a governor to check the legislature, and courts that could check both.
Classical republicanism. Many founders admired the ancient Roman republic. Classical republicanism is the idea that a republic works only if citizens put the common good ahead of private interest and take part in public life. Both sides in Pennsylvania’s fight claimed to defend the republic. They disagreed about how to protect it.
Worked example 1: comparing two documents. Ethan builds a chart. 1776: one house, council instead of governor, Council of Censors. 1790: two houses, strong governor, judicial review soon after. He writes, “The 1790 constitution spread power among more parts of government, so each could check the others.”
Worked example 2: noticing continuity. Zara reads that the Declaration of Rights was copied into later constitutions without major change. She writes, “Even when Pennsylvanians rewrote the structure of government, they kept their list of rights. Change and continuity happened at the same time.”
Two viewpoints in 1776. Supporters of the 1776 plan valued putting power close to ordinary voters in a single elected house with short terms. Critics feared that an unchecked single house could act rashly. Our exhibit should present both views, then show what Pennsylvanians chose in 1790.
Connection to the nation. James Wilson, a leading critic of the 1776 plan, was also a main architect of the U.S. Constitution in 1787. Ideas tested in Pennsylvania helped shape the national design, and the national design shaped Pennsylvania’s 1790 plan.
Use the reading and your chart. Talk through each answer.
Write a comparison panel.
CER: Why did Pennsylvania replace the 1776 constitution in 1790? Use at least two details from the reading and explain the principle each change reflects.
The 1790 constitution lasted almost fifty years. Next we see the 1838 constitution, which gave voters more power and also took the vote away from Black Pennsylvanians.
Exit ticket: name one thing that changed and one thing that stayed the same from 1776 to 1790.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, panel 5.
Accuracy: the 1776-1861 PHMC era page has been removed from the live PHMC site; the Internet Archive copy preserves the official text. James Wilson’s role in 1787 is from the same page. Judicial review: the PHMC page says the 1791 court “implied” the power; keep that careful wording.
Likely misconceptions: that the 1776 constitution was simply “bad” (it widened voting and kept rights the state still uses); that the 1780 law freed everyone at once (it was gradual).
Supports: a two-column 1776/1790 chart. Stretch: ask why a single house with one-year terms might appeal to frontier voters.
Answer guide: strong CERs cite the Senate, the governor or judicial review and tie each to checks and balances. Exit tickets: change (two houses, governor) and continuity (Declaration of Rights).
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Pennsylvania History: 1776-1861 (Internet Archive copy) · Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (PHMC) web page, Internet Archive copy; summarized in our own words with a link
During the Revolution, Pennsylvania went through its own internal revolution. Local committees took over from the old Provincial Assembly and called a convention in July 1776. The constitution it adopted on September 28, 1776, created a one-house Assembly and a Supreme Executive Council instead of a governor. Its Declaration of Rights has been copied into every later Pennsylvania constitution without major change.
Many patriot leaders, including John Dickinson, James Wilson, Robert Morris and Frederick Muhlenberg, opposed the 1776 plan. Its supporters, called the Constitutionalists, governed until 1790. Among their achievements was a 1780 law for the gradual abolition of slavery.
By 1789 the critics felt strong enough to rewrite the constitution, and the Assembly called a convention. Both sides compromised. The new constitution was adopted with little objection. It created a second lawmaking house, the State Senate, and a strong governor with wide power to appoint officials. Thomas Mifflin became the first governor under it.
In 1791 the state Supreme Court suggested it could strike down laws that broke the constitution. This power, called judicial review, has been used ever since.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Pennsylvania History: 1776-1861 (Internet Archive copy) (web.archive.org)