interpret how Brown v. Board of Education changed a principle of government and explain judicial review as a check on other branches and on the states.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In lesson 2.12 we saw that Marbury v. Madison gave courts the power of judicial review. Write one sentence explaining that power. Then read about a case where the Supreme Court used it to strike down state laws that kept children apart by race.
In 1954, how many Supreme Court justices do you think agreed that state-required school segregation was unconstitutional?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Checks and balances, all three ways. The President can veto a bill. Congress can override a veto by a two-thirds vote in each house, and the House can impeach officials while the Senate tries them. The President nominates judges, and the Senate confirms them. Since Marbury v. Madison (1803), courts can rule that a law breaks the Constitution. Brown shows that check reaching state laws too.
Read a case like a historian. Ask four questions. What happened? What was the legal question? What did the Court decide? What changed because of it? These questions keep us from repeating headlines without understanding them.
Worked example 1: Grace’s case card. Grace writes: “Facts: states required separate schools for Black and white children. Question: does that violate the Fourteenth Amendment’s equal protection? Decision: yes, 9 to 0. Change: ‘separate but equal’ no longer applied to public schools.” Each line traces to the reading.
Worked example 2: Malik’s diagram. Malik draws three boxes with arrows. Congress to President: override a veto. President to Congress: veto. President to courts: nominate judges. Senate to courts: confirm judges. Courts to Congress, the President and the states: judicial review. He adds Article III, Section 1, which begins “The judicial Power of the United States, shall be vested in one supreme Court.”
Courts depend on others. A court decides real cases brought to it, but it has no army and no budget of its own. Other officials must carry out its rulings, which is why the case study matters.
Fair wording. People have long disagreed about how often courts should strike down laws. Some praise courts for protecting rights. Others warn that unelected judges should be careful about overruling elected lawmakers. Our section can name both views while stating the facts of segregation plainly.
Use the reading, the case study and Malik’s diagram.
Draft the checks part of the Separation and Checks section, or a court card for the Rights section.
Draw or describe a checks-and-balances diagram with at least five arrows. Label each arrow with the power and the branch that holds it.
Interpret: how did Brown v. Board of Education change the principles of our government? Use one detail from the reading and one from the case study, and connect it to Marbury v. Madison.
A court ruling does not carry itself out. After Brown, the Supreme Court heard arguments about how to end segregation. On May 31, 1955, Chief Justice Warren read a second unanimous decision, known as Brown II. It told states to desegregate “with all deliberate speed.”
The National Archives notes that segregationists resisted the decision. In many places, school boards, state officials and courts moved slowly, and change took years of further lawsuits, protests and action by the other branches of government.
Brown shows judicial review as a powerful check. It also shows that the courts rely on the executive branch, on state and local officials, and on citizens to turn a ruling into real change.
Think about it: Why might “with all deliberate speed” have led to slow change? What does Brown II show about how the branches depend on each other?
Black families who went to court changed the meaning of equal protection for every public school in the nation.
Exit ticket: in one sentence, why does checks and balances need all three branches to have a check?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 7, case study 7, guided practice 11, diagram 5, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that segregation was only custom, not law; that Brown ended segregation immediately; that judicial review is written in Article III; that courts can strike down laws without a case.
Supports: a four-box case organizer (facts, question, decision, change) and a blank three-branch diagram. Teach segregation directly and center the Black families, students and lawyers who organized to end it. Stretch: compare Brown with Marbury (2.12): both are judicial review, but Marbury voided part of a federal law and Brown voided state laws.
Answer guide: diagrams should include veto, override, impeachment, nomination and confirmation of judges, and judicial review. Brown changed a principle by ending “separate but equal” in public education under equal protection. Brown II shows that courts depend on other officials to carry out rulings. All facts come from the National Archives Brown page.
National Archives, Milestone Documents: Brown v. Board of Education (1954) · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1896, in Plessy v. Ferguson, the Supreme Court allowed a rule called “separate but equal” in a case about railroad travel. For nearly 60 years afterward, many states used that idea to require Black and white children to attend separate public schools.
Black families in Kansas, South Carolina, Virginia and Delaware challenged school segregation in court. The Supreme Court joined their cases together. On May 17, 1954, Chief Justice Earl Warren read the Court’s unanimous decision.
The Court ruled that state-required segregation in public schools violated the Fourteenth Amendment, which promises every person equal protection of the laws. It said segregation could make Black children feel inferior, or less valued, in their community, and that public education must be available to all on equal terms. The ruling overturned “separate but equal” in public education.
Reactions were divided. Segregationists resisted. Some legal scholars said the Court relied on social science instead of earlier cases, and some argued it had gone too far. Civil rights supporters were encouraged, and the decision helped spark the civil rights movement of the 1950s.
“Separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.” (Brown v. Board of Education, opinion of the Court, as quoted by the National Archives)
Source: National Archives, Milestone Documents: Brown v. Board of Education (1954) (archives.gov)