interpret the changes made by Pennsylvania’s 1874 and 1968 constitutions and write a claim, evidence and reasoning answer to the unit puzzle.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at our Pennsylvania timeline: 1682, 1701, 1776, 1790, 1838. Write one pattern you notice about why Pennsylvania changed its government each time.
Pennsylvania's current constitution dates from 1968. What do you think it changed?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
1874: a constitution against corruption. The state’s official history says the fourth constitution grew from a nationwide reform movement in the 1870s and from corrections to the 1838 plan. Special laws for single places or interests were banned in 26 areas. The legislature was doubled in size, to 200 House members and 50 senators, on the theory that more members would be harder for special interests to buy. The governor’s term grew to four years, but he could not serve two terms in a row, and he gained a line-item veto over spending bills.
1968: a modern update. The 1968 constitution kept much of 1874 but modernized the courts, added civil rights protection and allowed governors a second term. The state courts describe the 1968 plan as creating the Commonwealth Court and reorganizing the judiciary into the Unified Judicial System.
| Constitution | Main reason for change |
|---|---|
| 1776 | Independence; replace colonial rule with a democratic plan |
| 1790 | Add checks and balances |
| 1838 | More elected offices; also took the vote from Black men |
| 1874 | Reform against corruption and special interests |
| 1968 | Modernize courts and government; protect civil rights |
Worked example 1: a puzzle CER. Leah writes: “Claim: Pennsylvania rewrote its constitution because each version solved problems people saw in the last one. Evidence: in 1790 it added a Senate and a governor to check a single house, and in 1874 it banned special laws and enlarged the legislature to fight corruption. Reasoning: when people decided their plan of government was not working, they used conventions to rewrite it.”
Worked example 2: adding the national comparison. Marcus adds a second reason. “Pennsylvania’s constitutions are very detailed, so they need updating often. The U.S. Constitution sets out broad principles and is changed with amendments instead.” He labels this as his inference and asks the class to test it in Unit 2.
Principles that last. Across all five constitutions, some principles stayed: popular sovereignty, a written constitution that limits government, and a Declaration of Rights. These are the same principles that shape the U.S. government. Our exhibit will show visitors both what changed and what endured.
Use the reading, the table and your timeline. Answer with evidence.
Answer the unit puzzle for our exhibit.
CER: Why has Pennsylvania had five constitutions while the United States has had one since 1789? Use evidence from at least three of Pennsylvania's constitutions and explain your reasoning.
Plan for Part 2: rank the three of our five team panels your team most wants to build, and name one source from Part 1 that each would use.
You have gathered and made sense of the evidence. In Part 2 you will build, critique and revise the Roots of Government Exhibit for our community.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence for visitors: “Pennsylvania rewrote its constitution because…”
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 8, CER and plan 9.
Accuracy: 1874 facts come from the PHMC 1861-1945 history page (Internet Archive copy, https://web.archive.org/web/20230204111750/http://www.phmc.state.pa.us/portal/communities/pa-history/1861-1945.html). The courts statement follows the Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania’s history page (pacourts.us/learn/history). The convention was voted on and approved in 1968; the General Assembly calls the result the 1874 constitution as amended, so some sources count four constitutions.
Nonpartisan reminder: the reading notes support from both major parties; do not extend into present-day debates about constitutional changes.
Likely misconceptions: that the U.S. Constitution has never changed (it has 27 amendments); that each Pennsylvania constitution threw out everything before it.
Supports: provide the five-row table as a graphic organizer. Stretch: ask students to test Marcus’s inference by comparing the length of the two constitutions in Unit 2.
Answer guide: strong CERs cite at least three constitutions with specific changes, explain fixing problems or responding to new ideas, and contrast the national use of amendments. Keep plans for Part 2.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Pennsylvania History: 1945-2013 (Internet Archive copy) · Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (PHMC) web page, Internet Archive copy; summarized in our own words with a link
By the 1960s, many Pennsylvanians believed the 1874 constitution needed updating. With support from both major parties, Governor Raymond P. Shafer won approval for a convention limited to specific problems in the old document. The Constitutional Convention of 1967-1968 revised the 1874 constitution.
An important new provision says no person may be denied his or her civil rights. The governor and other elected state officers could now serve one more term in a row. Milton J. Shapp became the first governor able to succeed himself under the 1968 constitution, and voters re-elected him in 1974.
The convention also created a unified judicial system under the Supreme Court, added a Commonwealth Court, and modernized the lower courts. Counties and towns gained more power to govern themselves through home rule. The House of Representatives was set at 203 members. State borrowing was limited, all departments had to be audited, and the governor had to send the legislature a budget every year.
Change continued afterward. In 1971, voters amended the constitution so that equal rights could not be denied because of sex.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Pennsylvania History: 1945-2013 (Internet Archive copy) (web.archive.org)