write a claim, evidence and reasoning response explaining how the Declaration of Independence uses earlier ideas about the purpose of government.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your Hobbes and Locke comparison card. Predict: which thinker’s ideas will you find in the Declaration of Independence, and why?
Was the Declaration signed by everyone on July 4, 1776?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
An argument in five parts. The Declaration is built like a strong essay. Its claim is that the colonies have the right to be independent. Its reasoning is a theory of government. Its evidence is a long list of the king’s actions.
The theory of government. The second paragraph says that all men are created equal, that they have unalienable rights including “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness,” that governments are created to secure these rights, and that they get “their just powers from the consent of the governed.” When a government destroys these ends, the people may alter or abolish it. These lines closely match Locke’s ideas of natural rights, consent and the right to replace a government.
Worked example 1: a full CER. Bryce writes: “Claim: the Declaration uses Locke’s ideas to justify independence. Evidence: it says governments get ‘their just powers from the consent of the governed’ and that people may ‘alter or abolish’ a government that destroys their rights. Reasoning: Locke argued that power requires consent and that rulers who abuse power lose authority, so the Declaration applies his theory to King George III.”
Worked example 2: fixing weak reasoning. Isabel’s first reasoning says, “This proves Jefferson read Locke.” She realizes the evidence shows the ideas match, not what Jefferson read. She revises: “The ideas closely match Locke’s, which shows how widely those ideas were shared in the colonies.”
Equal, but not for all. The Declaration says all men are created equal, yet in 1776 slavery was legal in every colony, and women and many others could not vote. Enslaved and free Black Americans, such as the poet Phillis Wheatley and petitioners in Massachusetts, used the Declaration’s own words to demand freedom. Its ideals became a tool people used to push the nation to live up to them.
What came next. Declaring independence was one thing; building a national government was another. The Declaration created no government plan. Next lesson, we examine the first one, the Articles of Confederation.
Use the reading and the quotations in the mini lesson. Build your CER step by step.
Write your first full CER for the exhibit.
Answer in a full claim, evidence and reasoning paragraph: how does the Declaration of Independence explain why people create governments? Use at least one quotation and connect it to Locke or Hobbes.
The Declaration explained why. Next we see how Americans first tried to build a national government, and why it struggled.
Exit ticket: how did people who were denied rights in 1776 use the Declaration's words?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, CER 7.
Accuracy: quotations from the Declaration follow the National Archives transcription. The National Archives history page does not mention Locke; the Locke connection is the course’s analysis, which students should frame as a match of ideas. Phillis Wheatley and the 1777 petition of enslaved Black Massachusetts residents are well documented examples.
Likely misconceptions: that independence began on July 4 with everyone signing; that the Declaration is a law or plan of government.
Supports: provide a CER frame with sentence starters. Stretch: ask students to find a grievance in the body that connects to Magna Carta or the English Bill of Rights, such as taxes without consent or trial by jury.
Answer guide: a strong CER makes a clear claim, quotes accurately, and explains the link to consent, natural rights or the right to alter government without overstating what the evidence proves.
National Archives, America's Founding Documents: The Declaration of Independence: A History · U.S. government work, public domain
In June 1776, the Continental Congress met in Philadelphia, in the building we now call Independence Hall. On June 7, Richard Henry Lee of Virginia proposed that the colonies declare independence. Congress named a Committee of Five to write a statement explaining the decision to the world: John Adams, Roger Sherman, Benjamin Franklin, Robert R. Livingston and Thomas Jefferson. The others left the writing to Jefferson, and Franklin and Adams suggested changes.
On July 2, twelve colonies voted for independence, with New York not voting. Congress then edited Jefferson’s draft and adopted the Declaration on July 4. The handwritten parchment copy was signed on August 2. John Hancock signed first, and 56 delegates signed in all.
The National Archives explains that the Declaration has five parts: an introduction, a preamble stating principles, a two-part body listing wrongs by King George III and failed appeals to the British people, and a conclusion declaring the colonies free and independent states. The preamble’s principles were ideas that most English people of the time already saw as “self-evident.”
“these United Colonies are, and of Right ought to be Free and Independent States” (the Declaration’s conclusion, as quoted by the National Archives)
Source: National Archives, America's Founding Documents: The Declaration of Independence: A History (archives.gov)