use biographical evidence to explain the roles Pennsylvania delegates played in framing the Constitution.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Think of a group project. Who talked the most? Who wrote the final draft? Who quietly kept the group together? Are those always the same person?
Pennsylvania sent eight delegates. Do you think they all played big roles?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
What is a framer? A framer is a person who helped write, or frame, the Constitution. The word comes from building: a frame is the structure that holds a house up. Today we ask what Pennsylvania’s framers actually contributed, using evidence rather than legend.
Different roles. At the Convention, some delegates proposed ideas, some drafted text, some negotiated compromises and some mainly voted. All of these are real roles. A quiet delegate who attended every session still helped decide the outcome.
Worked example 1: making a role card. Aaliyah reads about James Wilson. She writes: “Role: drafter and debater. Evidence: served on the Committee of Detail; influence second only to Madison’s. Later: Supreme Court justice.” Every part of her card comes from the source.
Worked example 2: avoiding a legend. Diego has heard that Franklin “ran the whole Convention.” The biography says he lent prestige, eased tensions and settled disputes, but also disapproved of parts of the plan. Diego writes: “Franklin was a respected peacemaker who still had doubts.” That is more accurate and more interesting.
A Pennsylvania perspective. Pennsylvania’s delegates came mostly from Philadelphia’s world of merchants, bankers and lawyers. That shaped their concerns, such as trade and a strong national government. People in western Pennsylvania farm country, including our region, often saw things differently, which matters when we study who was and was not in the room.
Who was missing? All the delegates were white men. Women, free and enslaved Black people, and Native nations had no seats. A complete explainer says so plainly.
Each team takes two delegates and makes evidence-based role cards.
Finish your role cards.
Make role cards for two framers: name, role at the Convention, one piece of evidence, and one later job. Then write a sentence comparing them.
We know who helped build the frame. Next we open the blueprint itself: the seven articles.
Exit ticket: why is it misleading to say that one person wrote the Constitution?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, role cards 13, closure 5.
Accuracy: facts come from the National Archives Pennsylvania biographies. Gouverneur Morris was born in New York; the Archives lists him under Pennsylvania, which he represented. Robert Morris and Gouverneur Morris share a surname but were not related; avoid implying they were family.
Perspective note: the statement about western Pennsylvania views is a general framing; keep it brief and avoid inventing specific quotations.
Supports: provide a role-card template. Stretch: compare Franklin’s abolition work with the Convention’s compromises over slavery, which students revisit in 2.14.
Answer guide: exit tickets should mention committees, many delegates and the lack of a single recorded author.
National Archives, America's Founding Documents, The Founding Fathers: Pennsylvania · U.S. government work, public domain
Pennsylvania sent eight delegates to the Convention. Their roles were very different.
Gouverneur Morris, a lawyer born in New York, gave 173 speeches, more than anyone else. He served on the Committee of Style and is believed to have actually drafted the final wording. James Wilson, a lawyer born in Scotland, had influence second only to James Madison’s. He served on the Committee of Detail and later became a justice of the U.S. Supreme Court.
Benjamin Franklin, born in Boston in 1706, was the oldest delegate. Though in poor health, he missed few sessions. He helped ease tensions and settle disputes, even though he disapproved of parts of the final plan. In 1787 he also became the first president of the Pennsylvania Society for Promoting the Abolition of Slavery.
Others played quieter roles. Robert Morris, a financier, attended nearly every meeting but spoke only twice. Thomas Mifflin made no speeches but later became Governor of Pennsylvania. George Clymer, Thomas Fitzsimons and Jared Ingersoll attended regularly, spoke seldom, and went on to serve in Congress or in state legal offices.
Source: National Archives, America's Founding Documents, The Founding Fathers: Pennsylvania (archives.gov)