explain how local, state and national governments are structured and how each one turns an idea into a law or policy.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of one rule you would change, such as park hours or a crosswalk near school. Which government would make that rule: the nation, Pennsylvania, or the county or borough? Then read how a federal law is made, and look for steps that might work the same way closer to home.
Where does a federal law start?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Same pattern, three levels. At each level of government, one part makes rules and another carries them out. Nationally, Congress makes laws and the President carries them out. In Pennsylvania, the General Assembly (a Senate and a House of Representatives) makes laws and the Governor carries them out. In Allegheny County, as we read in lesson 2.09, a 15-member County Council makes local laws, called ordinances, adopts a balanced budget each year, and hears public comment, while an elected County Executive leads the county’s departments.
Courts appear at every level too. Federal courts decide federal cases. Pennsylvania has its own courts, topped by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. The Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas hears many local trials.
Even closer to home. Our school district sits inside boroughs and a township. Boroughs elect a borough council and a mayor; townships elect commissioners or supervisors. An elected school board sets policy for our schools.
Worked example 1: Jada traces a policy. Jada imagines a sample issue: a county park needs new lighting. She writes the steps: a council member proposes an ordinance or budget change; residents comment at a public meeting; council votes; if it passes, county departments carry it out. She labels her example sample, because it is made up.
Worked example 2: Owen compares levels. Owen makes a chart. Lawmakers: Congress, the General Assembly, County Council. Leader who carries out laws: the President, the Governor, the County Executive. He notes that council confirming appointments is like the U.S. Senate confirming judges.
Policy has two scales. Domestic policy deals with life inside the country, such as schools, roads and health. National policy also includes foreign policy, such as treaties and defense, which only the federal government handles. Local governments make domestic choices for their own communities.
Use the reading and Owen’s chart.
Write the How to Take Part box for the explainer.
Make a side-by-side flow chart: how a federal law is made (from the reading) and how a county ordinance is made (from lesson 2.09). Circle one step that is alike and one that is different.
Explain how a local policy, such as park hours, would be made, from an idea to action, and name one place a new voter could speak up. Label any invented details as sample.
The government closest to us is often the easiest one to reach.
Exit ticket: why might a new voter care about a county council meeting as much as a national election?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 13, How to Take Part box 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that local government is part of the federal government; that only Congress makes laws; that public meetings are closed.
Supports: provide a blank three-level chart and a borough list for the district (East McKeesport, Wall and Wilmerding boroughs and North Versailles Township). Check current local forms of government before class; do not name current officeholders. Meeting times can change; tell students to check the county site before attending.
Answer guide: federal flow: member writes bill, both houses vote, President signs or vetoes, Congress may override by two-thirds of each house. County flow: proposal, public comment, council vote, carried out by departments. Alike: a vote by elected lawmakers; different: county council is one body, Congress has two houses. Speaking up: public comment at a council meeting or contacting a representative. County facts recalled here come from the County Council page read in 2.09; the elected County Executive under the Home Rule Charter (in effect since 2000) is widely documented but not on that page. Ben’s Guide does not cover committees; mention them only as an extra step.
U.S. Government Publishing Office, Ben's Guide: How Laws Are Made · U.S. government work, public domain
Federal laws start in Congress. A senator or a representative writes a bill, which is a draft of a proposed law. Each Congress lasts about two years, and during that time members may introduce thousands of bills. Only some of them ever become laws.
To move forward, a bill must win a vote in both houses of Congress: the House of Representatives and the Senate. If either house votes it down, the bill does not become law.
When both houses approve a bill, it goes to the President. The President has a choice. Signing the bill makes it a law. Vetoing the bill, or rejecting it, sends it back to Congress.
A veto does not have to be the end. Congress can override the veto if two-thirds of the House and two-thirds of the Senate vote to do so. Then the bill becomes a law even without the President’s signature.
These steps show checks and balances at work. Two separate houses must agree, the President can say no, and Congress can still overrule the President with a large enough vote.
Source: U.S. Government Publishing Office, Ben's Guide: How Laws Are Made (bensguide.gpo.gov)