interpret a Pennsylvania student-speech case and explain how the law balances individual rights with the common good.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A student posts an angry message about school on a weekend, from off campus. Should the school be able to punish her? Write yes, no or it depends, with one reason. Then read a real case from Mahanoy Area High School in Pennsylvania.
How do you think the U.S. Supreme Court decided this case?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rights and the common good. Laws protect individual rights, like free speech. Laws also protect the common good, the safety and well-being of everyone. Many court cases ask how to balance the two. The First Amendment says Congress shall make no law “abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.” Courts have applied that protection to state and local governments, including public schools.
Precedent: Tinker. In 1969, in Tinker v. Des Moines, the Court said schools may limit student speech that seriously disrupts class or invades the rights of others. In Mahanoy, the Court used that earlier case and asked how it applies off campus.
Worked example 1: Hannah weighs both sides. Hannah makes a T-chart. School’s side: schools teach good manners, keep teams working together and protect students from bullying. B.L.’s side: she spoke off campus, on her own time, to her friends, and did not target anyone. Hannah writes, “The Court decided B.L.’s interest in free speech was stronger here.”
Worked example 2: Luis writes a limit. Luis notices the Court did not say schools can never act on off-campus speech. He writes: “Schools may still respond to serious bullying, threats aimed at teachers or students, or breaking rules for online schoolwork.” Explaining limits makes his page accurate.
Why it matters to new voters. Free speech protects the right to criticize people in charge, including schools and governments. Justice Breyer wrote that protecting unpopular speech helps prepare young people for democracy. Justice Thomas saw it differently. A fair page shows both.
Use the reading and Hannah’s T-chart.
Draft the Mahanoy card for the Rights section.
In 60 words, interpret Mahanoy: facts, question, decision and what it changed for students in Pennsylvania and across the country.
Explain how this law protects both individual rights and the common good. Use one detail from each side.
A case that started over a cheerleading team reached the highest court in the nation. Rights are tested in everyday life.
Exit ticket: do you think the Court struck the right balance? Give one reason from the majority or the dissent. Any reasoned answer is acceptable.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 8, career 3, guided practice 12, card draft 6, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that students have no rights at school, or that students can say anything with no consequences; that the ruling means schools can never act on online speech.
Supports: do not display or repeat B.L.’s vulgar words; describe them as “vulgar language and gestures,” as the syllabus does. Do not project the full opinion, since the dissent quotes the posts. Provide a T-chart and the frame “The Court decided ___ because ___, but it also said ___.” Stretch: read the syllabus’s three features of off-campus speech.
Answer guide: facts and decision as in the reading (8-1, June 23, 2021, Breyer for the Court, Thomas dissenting). Rights and common good: free speech for B.L.; school interests in order, manners and protection from bullying. Exit tickets are opinions: grade the reasoning, not the side chosen. Career facts come from the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook page on paralegals and legal assistants.
Supreme Court of the United States, Mahanoy Area School District v. B.L., No. 20-255, slip opinion and syllabus · U.S. government work, public domain
B.L. was a student at Mahanoy Area High School in Pennsylvania. She did not make the varsity cheerleading team. That weekend, at a local convenience store, she posted two images on Snapchat to her friends. The posts showed frustration with the school and the team, and one used vulgar language and gestures. School officials suspended her from the junior varsity team for a year.
B.L. and her parents went to federal court, arguing the punishment violated the First Amendment’s protection of free speech. A federal district court and then the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit agreed with her.
On June 23, 2021, the Supreme Court also ruled for B.L., by a vote of 8 to 1. Justice Stephen Breyer wrote for the Court. He said schools may still have reasons to act on some off-campus speech, such as serious bullying, threats or cheating. But B.L. spoke off campus, on her own time, without naming the school or targeting anyone. The record showed only a few minutes of class discussion and some upset teammates, not a serious disruption.
Justice Clarence Thomas dissented. He argued that schools have long had authority to discipline students in situations like this one.
“America’s public schools are the nurseries of democracy.” (Justice Stephen Breyer, opinion of the Court)
Source: Supreme Court of the United States, Mahanoy Area School District v. B.L., No. 20-255, slip opinion and syllabus (supremecourt.gov)