interpret how the Constitution of 1838 changed voting in Pennsylvania and analyze how Black Pennsylvanians argued against the change.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Pennsylvania’s 1790 constitution let “freemen” who paid taxes vote. It did not mention race. In 1838, a single word was added to that rule. Predict what the word was and what it did.
What did the word added in 1838 do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
More power for voters, but not all voters. The state’s official history explains that the 1838 constitution reduced the governor’s power to appoint officials, made more offices elected and shortened terms of office. Voters gained a greater voice. At the same time, free African Americans were disfranchised, despite protests from Black communities in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia.
A time of hostility. In May 1838, a mob burned Pennsylvania Hall in Philadelphia, a new building meant for meetings of reformers, including people working to end slavery. The PHMC history connects the new constitution with a rising hostility toward abolition and racial equality.
Worked example 1: analyzing an argument. Kayla studies the Appeal’s strategy. She writes, “Purvis used historical evidence, that ‘white’ was not in the 1776 or 1790 constitutions, to argue that the change broke with Pennsylvania’s own tradition. He also used numbers to answer the claim that Black residents were a burden.” She named the evidence and its purpose.
Worked example 2: weighing a close vote. Jamal notices the vote: 113,971 to 112,759. He subtracts and finds a margin of 1,212 votes. He writes, “The constitution passed by about half of one percent of the votes cast, which shows Pennsylvanians were deeply divided about the new plan.” He used the number as evidence instead of guessing.
Rights and the rule of law. The rule of law says laws should be applied equally. The 1838 constitution was adopted through legal steps, yet it wrote inequality into the law. This shows why people also look to written protections of rights, and why Black Pennsylvanians kept organizing until the Fifteenth Amendment restored the vote in 1870.
For our exhibit. Our panel on 1838 must show both sides of this change: more voice for many voters, and the loss of the vote for Black men. It should center the Black Pennsylvanians who argued for their rights, in their own words where possible.
Use the reading and the mini lesson. Cite your evidence.
Write the 1838 card for the Pennsylvania’s Changing Constitutions panel.
Write a card titled “1838: Who Counts?” Explain what changed, how Robert Purvis and the committee argued against it, and what happened in 1870. Use at least one number from the reading.
Pennsylvania still had two more constitutions to write. Next we look at 1874 and 1968 and pull our evidence together to answer the unit puzzle.
Exit ticket: what does the story of 1838 teach visitors about why constitutions change?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, panel 5.
Accuracy: the mini lesson’s summary of 1838 changes and the burning of Pennsylvania Hall (May 17, 1838) follow the PHMC 1776-1861 history page (Internet Archive copy). Party labels from the 1837-38 convention are left out to keep the focus on the change and the response; the encyclopedia essay gives them if students ask.
Sensitivity: teach this directly. Center the agency of Robert Purvis and the Black community. Do not role-play the convention or the vote.
Likely misconceptions: that voting rights only ever expand; that Northern states always protected Black voting.
Supports: provide a three-part organizer: change, argument, outcome. Stretch: ask why the Appeal used census data instead of only moral arguments.
Answer guide: strong panels name the added word, Purvis’s evidence (earlier constitutions, census data), the 113,971 to 112,759 vote and 1870. Exit tickets should note that changes can reflect who holds power and who is left out.
The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia, David Reader, Appeal of Forty Thousand Citizens · Copyright Rutgers University; summarized in our own words with a link
In 1837, a convention met in Harrisburg to revise Pennsylvania’s constitution. It later moved to Philadelphia for its final sessions. A delegate from Montgomery County, John Sterigere, proposed adding the word “white” before “freemen” in the article on voting. That would keep Black men from voting even if they paid taxes or owned property. Thomas Earle of Philadelphia objected, but a majority of delegates approved the change.
Black Philadelphians organized. At a public meeting in February 1838, they formed a committee led by Robert Purvis, a well-known Philadelphia leader. Purvis wrote the Appeal of Forty Thousand Citizens, Threatened with Disfranchisement. To be disfranchised is to lose the right to vote.
The Appeal used history, numbers and reasoning. It pointed out that the word “white” did not appear in the 1776 or 1790 constitutions. It used a census to show that Black Philadelphians paid more toward aid for the poor than they received.
On October 9, 1838, voters approved the new constitution by a narrow margin, 113,971 to 112,759. Black men in Pennsylvania did not regain the vote until the Fifteenth Amendment in 1870.
Source: The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia, David Reader, Appeal of Forty Thousand Citizens (philadelphiaencyclopedia.org)