present our exhibit to a community audience and explain how old ideas and documents shape U.S. and Pennsylvania government today.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Our welcome table will show a picture of the Liberty Bell. Many visitors know the bell but not its words or its Pennsylvania roots. Read the short reading and choose one fact to share at the door.
The Liberty Bell's inscription may have marked the 50th anniversary of which Pennsylvania document?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Opening day. Our audience of families, neighbors and new voters arrives today. Every team has a panel, the Document Timeline is on the wall and the Flag Display follows the Flag Code. Your job is to explain, listen and answer with evidence.
The visitor walk. Visitors start at the welcome table, then follow the timeline from Magna Carta in 1215 to Pennsylvania’s Constitution of 1968. Each team gives a two-minute talk: big idea, best evidence and one connection to government today.
Answer the unit puzzle. Visitors will ask why Pennsylvania has had five constitutions. A strong answer says Pennsylvanians kept changing how power was arranged and who could take part: adding a governor and a second house in 1790, making more offices elected in 1838 and 1874, taking away and later regaining Black men’s votes, and modernizing in 1968. The U.S. Constitution, instead, changes through amendments.
Worked example 1: Ravi’s two-minute talk (sample). “Our big idea is that rights in Pennsylvania come from two lists. Section 27 of our state constitution protects clean air and pure water, a right the U.S. Constitution does not list. Federalism means both lists protect you. Source: Article I and the National Archives.”
Worked example 2: Brianna answers a tough question. A visitor asks, “Which party is right about the flag-burning ruling?” Brianna says, “Our exhibit doesn’t take sides. The Supreme Court ruled in 1989 that flag burning as protest is protected speech, and Americans still disagree about it. Here is the ruling and the Flag Code, so you can decide.”
Speaking checklist. Face the visitor. Point to evidence on the panel. Use plain words. Say “I’m not sure, but here is where we could check” when you do not know.
Rehearse with a partner before visitors arrive.
During the opening, record your visitor conversations.
Write how you explained the unit puzzle to a visitor. Include at least two dated changes in Pennsylvania's constitutions.
Explain to a visitor how a principle such as federalism or constitutional government shapes both U.S. and Pennsylvania government, and how the Liberty Bell or another symbol carried American ideas beyond Pennsylvania. Write what you said.
Thank your visitors. You helped neighbors see where their government came from.
Exit ticket: what was the best question a visitor asked? How did you answer it?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 6 minutes, mini lecture 5, rehearsal 8, opening 18, closure 3. If families attend in the evening, use the class period for rehearsal and set-up.
Likely misconceptions: that the Liberty Bell rang on July 4, 1776 (a popular legend; avoid repeating it); that the bell was always called the Liberty Bell; that the U.S. Constitution never changes.
Nonpartisan note: rehearse Brianna’s response so every student can decline to take a side politely. Panels must not support or oppose a party, candidate or current policy.
Supports: provide talk cue cards; allow pairs to present together. Stretch: students prepare one extra fact for each other panel.
Answer guide: puzzle explanations (assess 5.1.9.D:1a) include two dated changes and why they mattered. Principle and symbol responses (assess 5.1.9.C:2a and 5.4.9.C:1a) explain the principle at both levels and an effect of U.S. ideas beyond Pennsylvania, for example the bell as a worldwide symbol of liberty, France’s 1789 declaration or the Universal Declaration.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1751 Isaac Norris, Speaker of the Pennsylvania Assembly, ordered a bell for the State House in Philadelphia, now called Independence Hall. It came from a foundry in London. The bell cracked the first time it was rung, so two Philadelphia metalworkers, John Pass and John Stow, melted it down and recast it.
The bell carries words from the Bible, from Leviticus 25: “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof.” Norris may have chosen them to mark the 50th anniversary of William Penn’s 1701 Charter of Privileges. That charter granted Pennsylvanians religious liberty and self-government.
Later Americans gave the bell new meaning. Abolitionists, people working to end slavery, used its words as a rallying cry. An antislavery publication first called it the “Liberty Bell” in 1835. In 1915 Pennsylvania women seeking the vote toured the state with a copy called the Justice Bell. It stayed silent until the Nineteenth Amendment passed in 1920.
Today the National Park Service calls the bell a symbol of liberty around the world. Visitors can see it in Philadelphia without a ticket.
“Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof.” Liberty Bell inscription, quoted by the National Park Service
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell (nps.gov)