contrast the individual rights created by the Pennsylvania Constitution with those in the U.S. Constitution and its Bill of Rights.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Look at your section card from last lesson. Do you think the U.S. Bill of Rights protects the same right? Write yes, no or “not sure,” then read to check.
How many amendments make up the U.S. Bill of Rights?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two governments, two lists. Pennsylvanians live under two constitutions at once. The U.S. Constitution limits the national government. Pennsylvania’s constitution limits the state and local governments. Sharing power this way is called federalism.
Where the lists came from. When the U.S. Constitution was written in 1787, it had no bill of rights. Anti-Federalists warned that a strong national government could threaten liberty. Supporters such as James Madison agreed to add amendments, and the Bill of Rights was ratified in 1791. Pennsylvania already had a Declaration of Rights in its 1776 constitution.
Many rights match. Both protect freedom of worship, a free press, peaceful assembly and petition, protection from unreasonable searches and trial by jury. Both bar titles of nobility. Pennsylvania’s Section 2 sounds much like the Declaration of Independence: power belongs to the people.
Some rights are different. Pennsylvania’s Section 5 says elections shall be free and equal; the Bill of Rights has no section about elections. Pennsylvania’s Section 27 promises a right to clean air and pure water. Section 28 says equality of rights under the law cannot be denied because of a person’s sex. The U.S. Constitution has no sections with these words. Both Sections 27 and 28 were added in 1971.
Worked example 1: Aisha’s T-chart. Aisha lists “Free press” in both columns. Then she notes a difference in wording: the First Amendment protects the press in general, while Pennsylvania’s Section 7 names the right to examine the Legislature and every branch of government.
Worked example 2: Connor’s contrast sentence. Connor writes: “Pennsylvania’s constitution creates a right to clean air and pure water in Article I, Section 27, but the U.S. Bill of Rights has no environmental right. So a Pennsylvanian has a state constitutional right that the national Constitution does not list.” He names both documents and the exact section.
One rule to remember. A state may add rights, but it may not take away a right the U.S. Constitution protects.
Use the reading, the case study and your Article I cards.
Draft the “Two Lists of Rights” card for the Pennsylvania panel.
Write a contrast paragraph (4 to 5 sentences) like Connor's. Name one right the two documents share and one right that is different. Cite both documents.
Explain how the debate between Federalists and Anti-Federalists led to the Bill of Rights.
On May 18, 1971, two new sections were added to Article I of the Pennsylvania Constitution. Section 27 says the people have a right to clean air, pure water and the preservation of the natural, scenic, historic and esthetic values of the environment. It calls the state’s public natural resources the common property of all the people, including generations yet to come. Section 28 says equality of rights under the law cannot be denied because of a person’s sex.
Changing the Pennsylvania Constitution is meant to be hard. The General Assembly must pass a proposed amendment in two sessions in a row, and then the voters must approve it. So these rights were added by the people’s vote, not by one official.
People still disagree about how far Section 27 reaches, and courts have heard many cases about it. Our panel can explain the right without taking a side in those disputes.
Think about it: What does the 1971 change show about how a state constitution can grow? Why does it matter that voters approved it?
Two lists, one person. Every Pennsylvanian is protected by both.
Exit ticket: why might a visitor be surprised that Pennsylvania lists rights the U.S. Constitution does not?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, case study 6, guided practice 10, paragraph 5, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that the Bill of Rights was part of the original 1787 Constitution; that a state can override federal rights; that “no section with these words” means no protection at all. Later U.S. amendments, such as the Fourteenth, Fifteenth and Nineteenth, protect equal protection and voting in other words; strong students may raise this, and it is a good point to add carefully.
Nonpartisan note: Section 27 is part of ongoing court cases and public debate. Present the text and the process; do not ask students to take a position on current environmental policy.
Answer guide: contrast paragraphs (assess 5.1.9.F:1a) name both documents, one shared right with citations (for example First Amendment and Section 7) and one difference (Sections 5, 27 or 28). The Federalist and Anti-Federalist response (assesses 5.1.9.E:2a) should say Anti-Federalists demanded protections against a strong national government and that the Bill of Rights was added, ratified in 1791.
National Archives, The Bill of Rights: What Does it Say? · U.S. government work, public domain
The Bill of Rights is the first ten amendments to the U.S. Constitution. An amendment is a change or addition. Here is what each one protects.
The First Amendment protects speech, the press, the right to gather in groups and the right to ask the government to fix problems. It protects religious beliefs and practices, and it stops the government from creating or favoring a religion. The Second protects the right to keep and bear arms. The Third says homeowners cannot be forced to house soldiers. Before the Revolution, British soldiers had been allowed to take over private homes.
The Fourth protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. The Fifth protects people from being tried twice for the same crime and from being forced to speak against themselves. It also promises due process, meaning fair legal steps. The Sixth gives people accused of crimes a speedy, public trial, a fair jury and a lawyer. The Seventh allows jury trials in many federal civil cases. The Eighth bans excessive bail and fines and cruel and unusual punishment.
The Ninth says that listing some rights does not erase others. The Tenth says powers not given to the national government belong to the states or the people.
Source: National Archives, The Bill of Rights: What Does it Say? (archives.gov)