describe the individual rights in Article I of the Pennsylvania Constitution and explain how Pennsylvania’s governing documents grew to include them.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Most people know the U.S. Constitution has a Bill of Rights. Fewer know that Pennsylvania’s constitution opens with its own list of rights. Predict what that list puts first.
Where in the Pennsylvania Constitution is its list of rights?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Today we build part of the Pennsylvania’s Changing Constitutions panel. Pennsylvania has had five constitutions, written in 1776, 1790, 1838, 1874 and 1968. Each one kept a Declaration of Rights, and each one reached back to earlier Pennsylvania documents.
The roots go back to William Penn. The Great Law of 1682 protected freedom of worship for people who believed in God and set out trial by jury. Penn’s Charter of Privileges of 1701 granted religious liberty and self-government. The 1776 constitution then listed rights such as freedom of religion, trial by jury and freedom of the press.
Read a constitution like a historian. Ask three questions about each section: What right does it protect? Who does it protect, and from whom? Is this right old, or was it added later? A state constitution limits what state and local governments may do, just as the U.S. Constitution limits the national government.
Worked example 1: Priya’s section card. Priya reads Section 7. She writes: “Right: a free press. Protects: any person who wants to examine the Legislature or any branch of government. From: laws that would restrain the press. Why it matters: citizens can only judge their government if they can report on it.”
Worked example 2: Mateo’s change chain. Mateo traces religious freedom. 1682: the Great Law protects worship for believers in God. 1701: the Charter of Privileges grants religious liberty. Today: Section 3 protects freedom of worship, and Section 4 says no person who believes in God can be barred from office because of religion. Mateo notes that the 1682 protection had limits, and that the right grew over time.
Next lesson we will set this list beside the U.S. Bill of Rights and look for what is the same and what is different.
Use the reading and the worked examples.
Add to your Pennsylvania evidence folder.
Make a change chain like Mateo's for one right. Show how Pennsylvania's documents changed from the Great Law of 1682 to today.
Why do you think Pennsylvania's constitution puts the rights first, before it describes the branches of government? Use the reading.
Pennsylvania’s constitution starts with the people and their rights. The government comes second.
Exit ticket: which Article I right would matter most to a new voter at our civics night? Explain in two sentences.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 9 minutes, mini lecture 8, guided practice 13, change chain 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that only the U.S. Constitution protects rights; that a state constitution can take away rights the U.S. Constitution protects; that rights in 1682 were the same as today. The Great Law’s religious protection covered people who believed in God, so it was broad for its time but not universal.
Supports: give a printed copy of Article I Sections 1-7, 20 and 26 with a vocabulary strip. Stretch: compare Section 2 with the Declaration of Independence’s paragraph on changing a government.
Answer guide: change chains (assess 5.1.9.D:1a) should show at least two dated documents and say what changed. Strong answers note that the 1701 Charter of Privileges granted religious liberty and self-government (National Park Service, Liberty Bell page) and that Article I keeps that tradition. Responses about rights first should mention that rights limit government or that power belongs to the people.
Duquesne University Kline School of Law, The Pennsylvania Constitution: Constitution of 1968 (official text) · Constitution text is a government edict and not copyrighted; site copyright Duquesne University; retold in our own words with a link
Pennsylvania’s constitution begins with Article I, called the Declaration of Rights. Putting rights first shows how important they were to the people who wrote it.
Section 1 says that all people are born equally free and independent. They have inherent rights, meaning rights they are born with. These include enjoying and defending life and liberty, owning and protecting property and reputation, and pursuing happiness. Section 2 says that all political power belongs to the people, who may change or abolish their government.
Many sections protect familiar freedoms. Section 3 protects freedom of worship. Section 5 says elections shall be free and equal. Section 7 says the printing press shall be free to anyone who wants to examine what the Legislature or any branch of government is doing. Other sections protect trial by jury, protect people from unreasonable searches and let people gather peacefully and petition the government.
Section 26 says neither the state nor any local government may deny a person a civil right or discriminate against a person using one. Section 25 says the rights in Article I stay with the people. The government’s general powers do not reach them.
“All men are born equally free and independent, and have certain inherent and indefeasible rights,” Pennsylvania Constitution, Article I, Section 1
Source: Duquesne University Kline School of Law, The Pennsylvania Constitution: Constitution of 1968 (official text) (paconstitution.org)