explain why national symbols and holidays were created and compare how different groups used the Liberty Bell to argue for the ideals it honors.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Think of a symbol that matters to you: a team logo, a family keepsake, a flag. Why does an object come to stand for an idea?
Who first called the Philadelphia State House bell the “Liberty Bell”?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why create symbols and holidays? Ideas such as liberty, justice and self-government are hard to see. Symbols and holidays give them a shape and a date. They help people remember shared ideals and remind them when those ideals have not yet been met.
Constitution Day. Every September 17 is Constitution Day and Citizenship Day, marking the signing of the Constitution in Philadelphia on September 17, 1787. A 2004 federal law set up the observance. Many new citizens take their oath around this date. The holiday honors both the document and the people who choose to join the nation.
A symbol’s meaning can grow. The Liberty Bell was first just a State House bell. Abolitionists, women seeking the vote and civil rights activists used its inscription to argue that liberty should reach everyone. The symbol became a way to hold the nation to its own words.
Worked example 1: symbol, ideal, why. Amara fills in a chart. Symbol: Liberty Bell. Ideal: liberty for all the inhabitants of the land. Why created or adopted: abolitionists in the 1830s used it to oppose slavery. Every part comes from the reading.
Worked example 2: separating legend and evidence. Connor has heard that the bell rang on July 4, 1776, to announce independence. The Park Service says there is no evidence for that. Connor writes: “Popular story, not supported by evidence.”
For our explainer. New voters see symbols everywhere: on money, in Philadelphia and on Constitution Day posters. A short section can explain what they honor and how different groups have used them.
Use the reading and a symbol-ideal-why chart.
Design a symbols page for our explainer.
Complete a symbol-ideal-why chart for the Liberty Bell and Constitution Day. Then write a short caption for new voters explaining one of them.
We know what our symbols honor. Next we return to our big puzzle and build the explainer’s big ideas.
Exit ticket: how did the meaning of the Liberty Bell change between 1753 and the 1900s?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 9, mini lesson 9, chart 12, closure 6.
Accuracy: Liberty Bell facts and the inscription come from the NPS page; the inscription is copied exactly in the version the page displays. Constitution Day facts (September 17; Public Law 108-447, enacted December 8, 2004) are from the National Archives page archives.gov/news/topics/constitution-day. The link between Constitution Day and naturalization ceremonies is common practice, not a legal requirement.
Accuracy and dignity: name slavery directly when discussing the abolitionists. Center the people who used the symbol to claim their rights.
Likely misconceptions: that the bell cracked on July 4, 1776; that it was always called the Liberty Bell.
Answer guide: its meaning grew from a State House bell to a national symbol used by abolitionists, suffragists and civil rights activists.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1751, Isaac Norris, Speaker of the Pennsylvania Assembly, ordered a bell for the State House in Philadelphia from a foundry in London. It cracked on its first test ring. Two local metalworkers, John Pass and John Stow, recast it in 1753.
The bell carries a line from the Bible’s book of Leviticus about proclaiming liberty throughout the land. The Park Service says there is no evidence that the bell rang on July 4 or 8, 1776, though it did ring for other public events.
In the 1830s the bell began to stand for liberty. In 1835, an anti-slavery publication first called it the Liberty Bell. Abolitionists, people working to end slavery, used its words as a rallying cry. Later, Pennsylvania women seeking the vote toured the state with a copy called the Justice Bell, and it stayed silent until women won the vote in 1920. Civil rights movements also used the bell for protest and celebration.
The famous wide crack is actually from a repair attempt in 1846. Soon after, a new crack appeared, and the bell has not rung freely since.
“Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof”
Ask: in 1835, who did not yet have liberty in the land?
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell (nps.gov)