analyze the powers and weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation and explain why leaders replaced them with the Constitution.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Imagine a student council that can make decisions but cannot collect dues, cannot make anyone follow its rules, and needs nine of thirteen homerooms to agree on anything big. What problems would it run into?
The Articles of Confederation gave Congress many jobs. Which power did it lack?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why so weak? Americans had just fought a war against a government they saw as too powerful. Many feared a strong central government would become a new tyranny. So the Articles kept most power in the states. That choice made sense to many people at the time, but it caused real problems.
Problems pile up. Without taxes, Congress could not pay soldiers or debts. States quarreled over trade and borders. In 1786 and 1787, farmers in western Massachusetts, many of them veterans deep in debt, rose up in what is called Shays’ Rebellion. Congress had no army ready to respond. Leaders such as James Madison and George Washington worried the union might fall apart.
| Under the Articles | Effect |
|---|---|
| No power to tax | Empty treasury, unpaid debts |
| One vote per state | Large and small states equal in Congress |
| Nine states for big decisions | Hard to act |
| All states to amend | Nearly impossible to fix |
Worked example 1: cause and effect. Mei writes, “Because Congress could not tax, it depended on the states for money. When states did not pay, the treasury ran low.” She linked a weakness to its effect with the word “because.”
Worked example 2: two viewpoints. Darius compares two views from the ratification debate after 1787. Federalists, such as Alexander Hamilton and James Madison, argued that the nation needed a stronger central government. Anti-Federalists, such as George Mason, feared a strong central government would threaten the states and people’s rights. Darius writes, “Both sides wanted to protect liberty. They disagreed about whether the bigger danger was a weak government or a powerful one.”
Federalism. The Constitution’s answer was federalism, dividing power between a national government and the states, each with real powers. We will study that design closely in Unit 2.
Use the reading and the table. Discuss before you choose.
Write a CER for the exhibit.
CER: Why did American leaders replace the Articles of Confederation? Use at least two weaknesses from the reading as evidence and explain how each caused a problem.
The nation rewrote its plan once and then kept it. Pennsylvania kept rewriting. Next we see why Pennsylvania replaced its 1776 constitution in 1790.
Exit ticket: how does the story of the Articles help explain why a government might rewrite its constitution?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, CER 7.
Accuracy: Congress was sitting in York from October 1777 to June 1778 (PHMC); the Articles were adopted November 15, 1777. The National Archives page does not mention Shays’ Rebellion; it is standard history and is kept in the mini lesson. Mason refused to sign the Constitution partly because it lacked a bill of rights.
Nonpartisan reminder: Federalists and Anti-Federalists were founding-era viewpoints, not today’s parties. Ask students to describe both sides fairly.
Likely misconceptions: that the Articles did nothing (Congress won the war and passed the Northwest Ordinance); that the 1787 delegates were sent to write a new constitution (they were sent to revise).
Supports: a cause-effect organizer. Stretch: ask why a loose union seemed safer to people in 1777.
Answer guide: strong CERs name weaknesses such as no taxing power, one vote per state or the unanimous amendment rule and trace each to a specific problem.
National Archives, Milestone Documents: Articles of Confederation (1777) · U.S. government work, public domain
In June 1776, the Second Continental Congress set up a committee to plan a union of the states. John Dickinson of Delaware was the main writer. Congress adopted the Articles of Confederation on November 15, 1777, while it was meeting in York, Pennsylvania. All thirteen states had to approve them, which took until March 1, 1781, when Maryland agreed. Arguments over representation, voting and western lands caused the delay.
The Articles created a confederation, a loose union in which each state kept its “sovereignty, freedom and independence.” Each state had one vote in Congress, no matter its population. Congress could make war and peace, sign treaties, coin and borrow money, build a navy and run post offices.
But Congress could not tax, and it had little control over trade. The treasury ran low, and paper money lost value. Major decisions needed nine states, and changing the Articles needed every state. In May 1787, delegates met in Philadelphia to revise them. Instead, they wrote the Constitution, which replaced the Articles in 1789.
Source: National Archives, Milestone Documents: Articles of Confederation (1777) (archives.gov)