describe the National Flag Code’s rules for using, displaying and respecting the flag, set up our Flag Display, and critique exhibit panels against our criteria.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Our exhibit will include a U.S. flag. You see three choices for hanging it on the wall behind the welcome table. Before you decide, read the part of federal law that explains how to respect the flag.
When the flag hangs flat against a wall, where should the blue field of stars, called the union, be?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
The flag is a symbol, and the Flag Code is a set of customs written into law. Congress wrote these rules so that people across the country would show respect in the same ways. Our Flag Display must follow them exactly.
Display rules (Section 7). Against a wall, the union goes at the top, on the observer’s left. In a group of state or local flags, the U.S. flag goes in the center and highest. On a speaker’s platform, the flag on a staff goes on the speaker’s right. At half-staff, it is first raised to the peak and then lowered.
Time and conduct (Sections 6 and 9). The flag is usually displayed from sunrise to sunset; it may fly all night if it is properly lit. It should be displayed in or near every schoolhouse on school days and at polling places on election days. During the raising or passing of the flag, civilians face it, stand at attention and put the right hand over the heart. People in uniform give the military salute, and veterans may salute too.
Code and freedom. Most Flag Code rules are guidance for civilians and list no punishment. In Texas v. Johnson (1989), the Supreme Court ruled that burning a flag as a political protest is speech protected by the First Amendment. The vote was 5 to 4: the majority said government may not ban an idea because people find it offensive, while the dissenting justices argued the flag is a unique national symbol that the law may protect. Many Americans strongly disagree with that ruling, and others strongly support it. Our exhibit explains the rules and the ruling without telling visitors what to think.
Worked example 1: Luis checks the display. Luis’s team tapes a paper sketch of the wall. The union is on the right. He checks Section 7, moves it to the top left, and adds a note: “Union on observer’s left, 4 U.S.C. § 7(i).”
Worked example 2: Jada gives a critique. Jada reviews the Pennsylvania panel using the criteria. She writes one glow and one grow: “Glow: your Two Lists card cites Section 27 and the First Amendment. Grow: your headline says Pennsylvania is ‘better’ than the U.S.; that is an opinion. Try ‘Pennsylvania adds rights the U.S. Constitution does not list.’”
Gallery critique protocol. Each team posts its draft panel. Reviewers rotate, read silently, then leave one glow and one grow tied to a criterion. Comments are about the work, never the person.
Part A: Flag Code. Part B: critique practice.
Write the Flag Code card for our Flag Display.
In 60 words or fewer, describe three Flag Code rules: one for display, one for respect and one for conduct during the Pledge or the raising of the flag. Cite the section number for each.
Choose one principle, such as constitutional government, federalism or classical republicanism. Explain how it shapes both the U.S. and the Pennsylvania governments, using a panel from our gallery as evidence.
A symbol earns respect through shared customs. A panel earns trust through careful evidence.
Exit ticket: write the one change your team will make after today's critique, and the criterion it improves.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 9, Part A practice 8, gallery critique 12, Flag Code card 2 (finish at home if needed), closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that breaking a Flag Code rule always brings a fine (most rules list no penalty for civilians); that the union should be on the viewer’s right; that every student must salute. The Pledge is voluntary for students; the Supreme Court ruled in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette (1943) that schools may not force students to recite it. Treat students’ choices with respect.
Nonpartisan note: present Texas v. Johnson as a real disagreement. Do not ask students to state a personal view in front of the class. Display facts from 4 U.S.C. §§ 4, 6, 7, 8 and 9 (Cornell LII).
Answer guide: Flag Code cards (assess 5.1.9.G:1a) name three correct rules with sections, for example union top left on a wall (§ 7), never touch the ground (§ 8), right hand over heart (§ 9). Principle responses (assess 5.1.9.C:2a) explain how the principle works at both levels, for example federalism: the U.S. and Pennsylvania each have a constitution and their own rights lists.
Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 4 U.S. Code Section 8, Respect for flag · Text of the U.S. Code is a U.S. government work, public domain; page hosted by Cornell LII
The National Flag Code is part of federal law, in Title 4 of the U.S. Code. Section 8 is called “Respect for flag.” It opens by saying that no disrespect should be shown to the flag of the United States.
The section lists many rules. The flag should never be flown upside down except as a signal of serious danger. It should never touch anything beneath it, such as the ground, the floor, water or merchandise. It should be carried raised and open, not flat, except in some respectful ceremonies.
The flag should not be used as clothing, bedding or decoration. For decorating a stage or desk, the code suggests red, white and blue bunting instead. The flag should not be stored or displayed where it could be easily torn or dirtied. Nothing such as words, pictures or marks should be placed on it.
The code says the flag should never be used for advertising or printed on throwaway items like paper napkins or boxes. It should not be worn as a costume or athletic uniform, although a flag patch may be worn by members of the military, firefighters, police and patriotic groups.
When a flag is worn out, it should be destroyed in a dignified way, preferably by burning.
Source: Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 4 U.S. Code Section 8, Respect for flag (law.cornell.edu)