evaluate evidence on both sides of the debate over whether the Haudenosaunee Confederacy influenced American government, and explain why historians disagree.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Two friends argue about whether a new video game copied an older one. One says the games look alike. The other says looking alike does not prove copying. What evidence would settle the argument?
In 1988, the U.S. Congress passed a resolution about the Haudenosaunee, also called the Iroquois Confederacy. What do you think it said?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Who are the Haudenosaunee? The Haudenosaunee, or People of the Longhouse, are a confederacy of Native nations whose homelands include much of present-day New York and reach into northern Pennsylvania. The Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga and Seneca joined long before Europeans arrived; the Tuscarora joined in the early 1700s, making Six Nations. Their Great Law of Peace united the nations under a Grand Council while each nation kept its own affairs. Clan mothers choose chiefs and can remove them.
Evidence of contact. Colonial leaders knew the Confederacy well. At a treaty council in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, in 1744, the Onondaga leader Canassatego urged the colonies to unite as the Six Nations had. Benjamin Franklin’s press printed the treaty records. In 1754, Franklin helped write the Albany Plan of Union, a proposal to unite the colonies under a Grand Council, drafted at a meeting held largely to make a treaty with the Iroquois.
Why historians disagree. Supporters of strong influence point to this contact, to the founders’ admiration, and to the 1988 resolution. Skeptics point out that the records of the 1787 Constitutional Convention say little about the Confederacy, and that the founders’ writings cite English law and European thinkers far more often. They also note real differences: the Confederacy decided by consensus and gave clan mothers a role in choosing leaders, while the Constitution used majority votes and left women out of voting.
Worked example 1: a careful claim. Noor writes, “The Constitution was copied from the Great Law of Peace.” Her partner asks for proof of copying. Noor revises: “Colonial leaders like Franklin knew and admired the Confederacy, and it may have influenced ideas about uniting the colonies, but historians disagree about how much.”
Worked example 2: weighing a source. Daniel sources the 1988 resolution: Congress, 200 years after 1787, honoring the Six Nations. He writes, “The resolution is strong evidence of how Congress viewed this history in 1988. It is not itself a record from 1787, so I also need evidence from that time.”
Respect in our exhibit. Whatever the answer to the influence question, the Haudenosaunee had a working constitution and confederacy long before 1787, and their nations govern themselves today. Our panel will present the debate fairly and let visitors weigh it.
Use the reading and the evidence in the mini lesson. Keep both sides in view.
Draft a fair debate card for the Document Timeline.
Write a card titled “A Debated Influence.” Include one paragraph on evidence for influence, one on reasons for doubt, and a closing sentence that states your own careful conclusion using the word “may” or “likely” only if the evidence supports it.
We have gathered the roots: thinkers, English documents, colonial self-government, Pennsylvania’s first laws, and Native governments. Next we see these ideas come together in the Declaration of Independence.
Exit ticket: why is it important for our exhibit to call this influence “contested” instead of stating it as fact either way?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 12, guided practice 10, panel 5.
Accuracy: H.Con.Res.331 passed the House on October 4, 1988; the Onondaga posting gives the resolution’s wording. The Albany Plan facts follow the U.S. Office of the Historian page “Albany Plan of Union, 1754.” Canassatego’s 1744 Lancaster speech is widely documented in the treaty minutes Franklin printed. Do not teach either “the Constitution was copied” or “there was no influence” as settled fact.
Respect: no role-play of councils or ceremonies. Use the nations’ names. Speak of the Haudenosaunee in the present tense.
Likely misconceptions: that a congressional resolution settles a historical question; that Native governments were informal or simple.
Supports: provide a T-chart, “Evidence for” and “Reasons for doubt.” Stretch: ask what kind of 1787 source would change the debate.
Answer guide: strong panels give real evidence on both sides (contact and admiration, Albany Plan, 1988 resolution; thin convention record, European sources, structural differences) and a measured conclusion.
Onondaga Nation, Congress' 100th Session Acknowledges Haudenosaunee Influence (posting of H.Con.Res.331, 1988) · Copyright Onondaga Nation; resolution text is a U.S. government work; summarized in our own words with a link
The Onondaga Nation is one of the Six Nations of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, a union of Native nations that still exists today. On its website, the Onondaga Nation shares the text of a resolution passed by the U.S. Congress in 1988. A resolution is a formal statement of Congress’s opinion; it is not a law that changes how government works.
The resolution, numbered H.Con.Res.331, was passed by the House of Representatives on October 4, 1988, for the 200th anniversary of the Constitution. It says that George Washington and Benjamin Franklin greatly admired the ideas of the Six Nations. It states that the joining of the original thirteen colonies into one republic “was influenced by” the political system the Confederacy developed.
The resolution also does more than look back. It reaffirms the trust responsibility of the United States toward Native nations, meaning the duties the federal government owes them, and the government-to-government relationship between tribes and the United States.
By posting the resolution, the Onondaga Nation shows that this history matters to Haudenosaunee people today.
Source: Onondaga Nation, Congress' 100th Session Acknowledges Haudenosaunee Influence (posting of H.Con.Res.331, 1988) (onondaganation.org)