
define criteria and constraints for the Colony Comeback Plan, model the breeding population’s genetic future, and choose among viewing-and-monitoring options with a weighted decision matrix.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. From the Ideate list, the class shortlisted three options: A a raised boardwalk overlook at a fixed distance; B a seasonal beach closure with small docent-led walks to a viewing point; C remote cameras with a livestream in the visitor center and only a small open viewing area. Which do you favor, and why?
Which is a CONSTRAINT rather than a criterion for the colony plan?
Engineers, define success first. Class criteria (sample targets): (1) breeding protection: fewer than 2 disturbance responses (seals lifting heads in alarm or moving away) per hour, measured at the viewing point; (2) visitor experience: visitors can see harems and pups and learn the comeback story; (3) monitoring: weekly pup counts and a genetic sample large enough to track heterozygosity. Constraints: follow marine mammal protection law (no feeding, touching or harassing); stay within the sanctuary’s budget; keep the public beach open outside the breeding season.
Behavior evidence for the design (sample data). Volunteers recorded disturbance responses per hour at different viewing distances: 10 m, 12; 25 m, 5; 50 m, 1. In a crowded and an uncrowded beach section, survival to weaning was 0.82 and 0.91. Any plan must keep people far enough away that the group behavior of the colony, harems guarded by a dominant male, mothers nursing pups, is not broken up.
Worked example 1: the effective population size. The number of seals that actually pass on genes is smaller than the colony. With unequal numbers of breeding males (Nm) and females (Nf), Ne = 4NmNf ÷ (Nm + Nf). Sample colony: 10 breeding males, 400 breeding females. Ne = 4 × 10 × 400 ÷ 410 ≈ 39. Using 1 − 1/(2Ne) = 1 − 1/78 ≈ 0.987 per generation, after 10 generations 0.98710 ≈ 0.88 of the heterozygosity remains. If 100 males bred, Ne = 320 and about 0.98 would remain. The mating system, a group behavior, sets the genetic clock. (The sanctuary cannot change who mates; the point is to know the risk and monitor it.)
Worked example 2: a weighted decision matrix. Weights (team choice): breeding protection 0.35, visitor experience 0.20, monitoring quality 0.25, cost 0.20.
| Option | Breeding protection (0.35) | Visitor experience (0.20) | Monitoring (0.25) | Cost (0.20) | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Boardwalk overlook | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3.35 |
| B Closure + docent walks | 5 | 4 | 4 | 2 | 3.95 |
| C Cameras + livestream | 5 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 3.75 |
Option B leads; option C protects breeding as well and costs less to run, but visitors see the seals only on a screen. The team must explain its trade-offs.
Monitoring genes without harm. Elephant seals shed skin and hair in their yearly molt. Collecting shed samples after the seals leave a section gives DNA without handling the animals; the plan must say how many samples to collect, which is a statistics question you test in the next lesson.
Build your matrix and genetic model with your team.
Version 1 of the plan.
Write your team's version 1 recommendation: the option you chose, its matrix total, the behavior evidence behind your viewing distance, and the trade-off the sanctuary should know about.
Find one additional piece of evidence (a reliable source or your own data) about how group breeding affects pup survival, and explain how it supports or challenges your plan.
Version 1 is ready for critique. Next: a gallery walk, a stress test and version 2.
Exit ticket: which number in your plan are you least sure of, and what data would make you more confident?
Materials: beach map templates, matrix templates, calculators, devices with a spreadsheet.
Data note: disturbance rates, survival figures, breeder numbers and matrix scores are sample numbers. The Ne formula for unequal sex ratios is a standard textbook result. In the United States, marine mammals are protected by federal law; keep that constraint general.
Listen for: plans that manage seal mating (not the sanctuary’s role); “a bigger colony fixes the genes”; treating the matrix as an answer machine.
Support / stretch: give the Ne formula with a worked row. Stretch: find how many breeding males are needed for 0.95 of heterozygosity to remain after 10 generations with 400 females.