
show what I learned about ecosystem stability and regime shifts, designing solutions to human impacts, and using simulations to evaluate them, with data questions and constructed responses.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Back to our phenomenon: kelp forests became urchin barrens and stayed that way. In two sentences, explain why returning the water to normal was not enough.
A stable ecosystem keeps roughly consistent numbers and kinds of organisms even though individuals are born and die.
Biologists and engineers, this is the unit checkpoint. Part A is multiple choice with data and a scenario set. Part B is short constructed responses, each scored 0 to 3. Read each question twice and show your reasoning.
How a 0–3 answer is scored. 3: a correct claim, accurate evidence or calculation, and reasoning that links them with a science idea. 2: claim and evidence with weak reasoning. 1: partly correct. 0: incorrect or blank.
Worked example: a 3-point answer. Question: “Why might removing a non-native predator from a lake not restore its native fish?” Diego wrote: “If the lake is also warmer and its spawning gravel is buried (claim), removing the predator leaves two other limits (evidence from our estuary debate). When several causes act together, fixing one may leave the others limiting, so the fish may stay in a new, low state (reasoning).”
Scenario set for questions 6–10 (sample data). A grassland is home to a threatened ground-nesting bird. Housing development has removed some habitat. A conservation group built a simple simulation and tested three solutions.
| Solution | Birds after 10 years (simulation) | Cost (units) | Plant species per plot | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No action | 40 | 0 | 6 | — |
| A: Buy and protect 200 ha | 180 | 9 | 11 | Land price uncertain |
| B: Delay mowing on farms until chicks fledge | 150 | 3 | 9 | Farmers lose some hay quality |
| C: Predator fencing around nests | 210 | 6 | 6 | Fences block other wildlife |
The simulation includes habitat area, mowing date and nest predators. It does not include drought years or disease.
Part A: answer on your own. Your teacher reviews answers after everyone finishes.
Part B: constructed responses, each scored 0–3.
14. Using the kelp coast, explain how complex food-web interactions kept the ecosystem stable, and evaluate the argument that it changed because the degree of change was extreme. Identify the claim, the evidence and the reasoning, and judge one strength and one weakness. (0–3)
15. Scenario set. Recommend one solution for the grassland bird. Quantify two criteria, name two constraints, and evaluate cost, reliability, and one social or cultural impact. Explain how you would refine it by prioritizing criteria. (0–3)
16. Describe how the group's simulation represents the human activity and biodiversity, which inputs they chose, one limitation, and how you would revise it to give enough information to evaluate solution B. (0–3)
17. Using evidence from two different ecosystems in this unit (field case, lab or model), explain why a small change in a condition can sometimes cause a large, lasting change in biodiversity. Judge how valid and reliable your evidence is. (0–3)
Unit 2 complete. Next unit: evolution, the deep-time story of how biodiversity arose.
Exit ticket: which idea from this unit are you most confident about, and which do you want to review?
How confident are you that you can explain ecosystem stability and evaluate solutions to human impacts with evidence and simulations?
Answer key, Part A: 1 B; 2 B; 3 B; 4 A; 5 B; 6 C; 7 B; 8 A; 9 A; 10 A; 11 4.1 (2.0 + 1.5 + 0.6); 12 False; 13 B.
Coverage: questions 1–4, 14 and 17 assess HS-LS2-6 (stability, claims, additional evidence, strengths and weaknesses, validity and reliability, degree of change); 5–8, 11, 12 and 15 assess HS-LS2-7 (design, criteria and constraints, trade-offs, evaluation, refinement); 4, 9, 10, 13 and 16 assess HS-LS4-6 (simulation parts, inputs, variables, consequences, comparing with expectations, enough information, limitations, predictions, revision).
Scoring Part B (0–3): 3 = claim + accurate evidence or calculation + reasoning with a science idea; 2 = claim + evidence, weak reasoning; 1 = partial; 0 = incorrect or blank.
Support: read-aloud and a calculator for any student whose plan allows it; the scenario table may be printed separately.