
give and use peer critique, test our herd plan against the criteria with a drought scenario, and revise the plan and its explanation into version 2.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read two pieces of feedback on a plan: (1) “It’s good.” (2) “I like your spreadsheet. I wonder why you assumed water raises K to 350. What if you used the grass data to estimate it?” Which helps the team more, and why?
Which feedback follows the “I like, I wonder, what if” protocol best?
Gallery critique. Teams post version 1: the spreadsheet graph, the matrix, and the food-web energy model. Visitors leave sticky notes in three colors: I like…, I wonder…, What if…. Every note must point to a number, a graph or a criterion.
The stress test. Each plan is tested against the class criteria with a harder scenario: a three-year drought, with K falling to 200 for all three years (sample scenario). Does the herd stay above 250? Does the plan cut deaths by half compared with no action? A plan that passes the two-year test may fail the three-year one.
Worked example 1: a failed test. Team Ava ran option A with drought K = 350. Under the stress test, the water stations raise K only to 280 (sample assumption). With r = 0.2, starting at 500: year 1, ΔN = 0.2 × 500 × (1 − 500/280) ≈ −79, so N ≈ 421; year 2, ΔN ≈ −43, so N ≈ 379; year 3, ΔN ≈ −27, so N ≈ 352. The herd stays above 250 in the model, but the team notices that 352 is still far above K = 280, so heavy grazing continues around the water points.
Worked example 2: version 2. Team Ava revised: combine water stations with relocating 100 elk in a forecast drought year, and fence small “exclosures” around wildflower patches so the board can compare grazed and ungrazed Simpson’s indexes. Their explanation changed too: “We used to think water alone could hold the herd up. The stress test showed that grass, not water, becomes the limit in a long drought.” That is revision based on evidence.
Iterate. Engineers rarely get it right the first time. They test, learn, change one thing, and test again, keeping a record of what changed and why.
After the gallery walk, test and revise.
Version 2.
Write your change log: two pieces of feedback you used, what you changed, and the new test result.
Write the revised explanation paragraph for your plan using the frame “We used to think… The new evidence… Now we think…” Explain which factors most affect the herd's carrying capacity and how they interact.
In 1944, 29 reindeer were released on St. Matthew Island, a remote island in the Bering Sea with no wolves and thick mats of lichen. With food plentiful and no predators, the herd grew to about 6,000 by 1963. Biologist David Klein had warned that the lichen, which grows back very slowly, was being overgrazed. During the severe winter of 1963–64, most of the herd starved, and a survey in 1966 found only 42 animals. Klein’s study concluded that food shortage, made worse by deep snow, caused the crash. The island could not move its reindeer elsewhere, and the slow-growing lichen meant the carrying capacity had been badly lowered by the herd itself.
Think about it: How is the island like our fenced peninsula, and what does the case suggest about waiting until a crash to act?
Version 2 is tested and explained. Next: the Prove It showcase for the reserve board.
Exit ticket: what is the single most important change between your version 1 and version 2, and what evidence caused it?
How confident are you that you can revise a plan and its explanation using test results and feedback?
Materials: posted version 1 work, sticky notes in three colors, the stress-test card, devices with team spreadsheets.
Case study check: the St. Matthew Island figures (29 reindeer in 1944, about 6,000 in 1963, 42 counted in 1966 after the 1963–64 winter die-off) come from David Klein’s 1968 study, widely cited in ecology texts.
Listen for: vague feedback (“good job”); revisions that change looks but not evidence; teams that refuse to report a failed test.
Support / stretch: give sentence starters for each note color. Stretch: find the K at which the herd just stays above 250 after three years, by trial in the spreadsheet.