
calculate allele and genotype frequencies with the Hardy-Weinberg equations, test whether a population is in equilibrium, and model how genetic drift and bottlenecks change allele frequencies in small populations.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Flip a coin 10 times and record the heads. Your neighbor does the same. Why do your results differ, and would they differ as much with 1,000 flips each?
Five populations of 10 individuals and five of 100 all start with an allele at frequency 0.5. No selection acts. After 10 generations, which group's frequencies will be most spread out?
Evolution as a change in allele frequencies. In a population, each gene has alleles at certain frequencies. If a gene has two alleles, A and a, their frequencies are p and q, with p + q = 1. Population geneticists define evolution as a change in allele frequencies from one generation to the next.
The Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. If mating is random and nothing changes the frequencies, the genotype frequencies in the next generation are p2 (AA), 2pq (Aa) and q2 (aa), and p2 + 2pq + q2 = 1. The frequencies then stay the same generation after generation. This equilibrium holds only when five conditions are met: no mutation, no migration (gene flow), a very large population (no drift), random mating, and no natural selection. Real populations rarely meet all five, and that is what makes the model useful: when a population departs from equilibrium, one of the five is at work. It is a null model, like the 50 : 50 expectation in the pill bug lab.
Worked example 1: from a recessive phenotype. In a population, 4% of individuals show a recessive trait. So q2 = 0.04 and q = 0.2; then p = 0.8. Carriers (Aa) are 2pq = 2 × 0.8 × 0.2 = 0.32, or 32%. Notice that most copies of the recessive allele are hidden in carriers, not in individuals who show the trait.
Worked example 2: testing equilibrium. A sample of 1,000 individuals has 360 AA, 480 Aa and 160 aa. Count alleles: p = (2 × 360 + 480) ÷ 2,000 = 1,200 ÷ 2,000 = 0.6, so q = 0.4. Expected genotypes: 360, 480 and 160. They match exactly, so the sample is consistent with equilibrium. Now a sample of 100 with 50 AA, 20 Aa and 30 aa: p = (100 + 20) ÷ 200 = 0.6 again, so expected counts are 36, 48 and 16. χ2 = 196/36 + 784/48 + 196/16 ≈ 5.44 + 16.33 + 12.25 = 34.0. With 1 degree of freedom (three genotypes, minus one, minus one for estimating p), the critical value is 3.84, so this population is far from equilibrium. There are too few heterozygotes, which could mean non-random mating or a mixed sample from two populations.
Genetic drift and bottlenecks. In a small population, chance alone changes allele frequencies, a process called genetic drift. A standard result from population genetics is that each generation a population of N breeding individuals keeps, on average, a fraction 1 − 1/(2N) of its heterozygosity. With N = 20 that is 0.975 per generation, and after 10 generations 0.97510 ≈ 0.78: about a fifth of the variation lost to chance alone. With N = 100, five generations keep about 0.975 of it. A bottleneck, like the one the elephant seals passed through, cuts variation sharply, and it does not come back quickly even when the population grows again, because new variation arises only slowly by mutation.
Bead model procedure. (This workshop spans two 50-minute periods.)
| Generation | Small pop. red drawn (of 10) | Small pop. p | Large pop. red drawn (of 50) | Large pop. p |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | — | 0.50 | — | 0.50 |
| 1 | ||||
| … | ||||
| 10 |
Selection versus drift. HS-LS4-3 asks you to show statistically that advantageous traits increase in proportion. Drift makes that harder to see in small populations: chance can outweigh a small advantage. Large samples and repeated populations, as in your bead model, separate the steady push of selection from the random wander of drift.
Reading: OpenStax Biology 2e, Sections 19.1–19.2 (Population Evidence of Evolution; Population Genetics) and Section 45.7 (Behavioral Biology); OpenStax Concepts of Biology, Chapter 11. CC BY 4.0.
Work the calculations, then use the bead data.
Model analysis (in your Colony Notebook).
Graph p against generation for your small and large bead populations on the same axes. Use the range and the number of populations that lost an allele to compare drift at the two sizes.
Test this sample for equilibrium: 70 AA, 60 Aa, 70 aa. Calculate p, the expected counts and χ2, and decide whether one of the five conditions is being broken. Suggest which one.
We can now measure whether a population is evolving and why chance matters in small ones. Next: we put behavior, numbers and genes together.
Exit ticket: explain why a population that grows from 100 to 200,000 does not regain the genetic variation it lost in a bottleneck.
How confident are you that you can use Hardy-Weinberg equations and a drift model to decide whether and why a population is evolving?
Timing: spans two 50-minute periods: day 1 is Hardy-Weinberg and the equilibrium test; day 2 is the bead model and analysis.
Materials: about 200 beads in each of four colors per group, cups, trays, calculators, a class spreadsheet.
Data note: the bead results quoted are illustrative. Independent practice key: p = (140 + 60) ÷ 400 = 0.5; expected 50, 100, 50; χ2 = 400/50 + 1,600/100 + 400/50 = 8 + 16 + 8 = 32, so too few heterozygotes, suggesting non-random mating or a mixed sample.
Listen for: “dominant alleles become more common” (they do not, without selection); confusing allele and genotype frequencies.
Support / stretch: give a step card (count alleles → p and q → expected → χ2). Stretch: simulate drift in a spreadsheet with RAND() and run 50 populations.