
construct and defend a report, with mathematical models, that explains how carrying capacity, limiting factors and energy flow shaped the growth and decline of the peninsula elk herd, and present our plan to the board.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The board has four minutes for your team. Write the one sentence you most want them to remember.
If the herd grew exponentially from 10 to 540 in 34 years, the per-capita rate r is about:
The question. Why did the peninsula elk herd grow from 10 animals to several hundred, level off, and then lose nearly half its members in a two-year drought, and how should the reserve plan for the next one? You are writing for the reserve’s advisory board: people who care about the elk and the land, but who want the mathematics explained.
What a strong report contains.
Worked example: one link. Claim: the drought lowered the carrying capacity of the peninsula. Evidence: the herd fell by nearly half while the area and the absence of hunting stayed the same; grass production fell by more than half (sample data); in the duckweed lab, cups with fewer nutrients leveled off at 80 fronds instead of 200. Reasoning: carrying capacity depends on resources; drought reduced forage and fresh water, so the same herd was suddenly far above the new K, and deaths exceeded births. Every section of your report needs this structure.
Sensitivity and accuracy. People disagree about how herds should be managed. Represent the facts accurately, label every number you did not measure as sample data or cite it, and keep your recommendation to what the evidence supports.
Presentation. In four minutes, live or recorded, present your model and plan, and answer one question about it.
Rehearse and check your report with your team.
After the presentations, reflect.
What question did the board ask, and how well did your model answer it? What would you change in your report?
Name one idea from another team's plan that you would borrow, and explain the evidence behind it.
Write a report of 900–1,300 words, with at least two data displays, for the reserve’s advisory board. Explain the growth, leveling-off and drought decline of the peninsula elk herd. Include a fitted growth model with a carrying-capacity estimate, at least one density-dependent and one density-independent factor, an energy pyramid calculation, a plan for monitoring plant diversity, your version 2 management plan with its decision matrix and stress-test result, and one management question with the data needed to answer it. Use evidence from the duckweed, seed-heat and sampling labs. Hand-drawn graphs are fully acceptable. Then present in four minutes, live or recorded.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Growth model (HS-LS2-1) | Fits an exponential or logistic model correctly, estimates K, and explains the model’s assumptions and limits. |
| Limiting factors (HS-LS2-1) | Explains density-dependent and density-independent factors and how drought changed carrying capacity, with lab evidence. |
| Energy flow and matter cycling (HS-LS2-4) | The energy pyramid calculation is correct, connected to why herbivores need large areas of producers, and distinguishes energy flow from matter cycling. |
| Biodiversity and revision (HS-LS2-2) | Explains how grazing and drought could change plant diversity, how it could be measured, and how the plan was revised after the stress test. |
| Plan and management question | The plan follows from the decision matrix and test results; the question follows from the evidence and names the data that would answer it. |
| Evidence and communication | Every number sourced or labeled sample data; clear for a non-specialist; the presentation answers a question accurately. |
You gave the reserve real, evidence-based advice. Next: the unit checkpoint.
Exit ticket: which Wonder Board question can you now answer best? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can use mathematical models and lab evidence to explain what limits a real population?
Timing: the task spans about three periods (planning, peer review, presentations); this lesson is the presentation day, with drafting done in class and at home.
Setup: invite staff or family to role-play the advisory board, in person or by video. Visitors can score the communication row.
Listen for: reports that quote numbers without labels or sources; “the elk ate everything” with no role for rainfall; energy and matter treated as the same thing.
Support / stretch: give a section-by-section outline with sentence frames. Stretch: add a second growth model (Ricker or a stochastic drought year) and compare its fit.