
revise my explanation of the herd’s growth and crash when new evidence about a disturbance arrives, connect carrying capacity, energy and biodiversity in one model, and brainstorm management ideas.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Reread the CER you wrote in 1.03 about duckweed. Then read the new evidence card from the reserve biologist (sample data):
| Year | Winter rain (cm) | Grass produced (kg dry mass per hectare) | Elk counted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 32 | 60 | 2,400 | 520 |
| Year 33 | 58 | 2,300 | 535 |
| Year 34 | 55 | 2,200 | 540 |
| Year 35 | 22 | 900 | 430 |
| Year 36 | 25 | 1,000 | 290 |
In years 35 and 36, grass production fell by about what fraction compared with year 34?
Scientists revise. A good explanation is not a final answer; it is the best account of the evidence so far. HS-LS2-2 asks you to revise your explanation when new evidence, such as data on a disturbance, arrives. Today we pull together growth models, energy flow and biodiversity into one revised model of the herd.
Modest and extreme disturbances. Ecosystems face disturbances all the time. A modest disturbance, such as one dry summer, lowers resources a little; populations dip and recover, and the ecosystem returns to roughly its old state. An extreme disturbance, such as a multi-year drought, can push populations so far that the ecosystem takes years to recover, or becomes a different ecosystem. Resilience is the ability to return to the original state after a disturbance.
Worked example 1: a revised claim. Our first claim was: the herd crashed because it ran out of food. The new card adds detail. Revised claim: a two-year drought cut grass production by more than half, lowering the peninsula’s carrying capacity well below the herd’s size, so deaths exceeded births until the herd fell toward the new K. Evidence: grass fell from 2,200 to 900–1,000 kg per hectare while the herd fell from 540 to 290 (sample data); duckweed cups with fewer nutrients leveled off at 80 instead of 200. Reasoning: K depends on resources. Grass production set the energy available to the herd; when it halved, K roughly halved too. The fence kept the elk from moving to wetter ground, so a density-independent factor (drought) and a density-dependent one (competition for scarce grass) acted together.
Worked example 2: the energy link. Suppose (sample numbers) the peninsula’s grass stores 2.0 × 109 kJ in a normal year, and herbivores can turn about 10% of producer energy into their own biomass. The herbivore level can then store about 2.0 × 108 kJ. In a drought year with 45% of normal grass, producers store 9.0 × 108 kJ and herbivores at most 9.0 × 107 kJ. The carbon in grass the elk do not eat is not wasted: decomposers return it to the soil and air for next year’s plants. Energy flows; matter cycles.
Effects across scales. A crash at one scale can feed back to another. With fewer elk grazing, tall grasses may shade out small wildflowers, or shrubs may spread; a quadrat survey would show Simpson’s index changing. The herd and the plant community are linked, and both respond to rainfall at the regional scale.
Ideate. We end by brainstorming management ideas for the board. Rules: no judging yet, build on others’ ideas, aim for quantity, and tie each idea to the science (which factor does it change: resources, boundaries, herd size or monitoring?).
Build the revised model with your team, then check your thinking.
Revised CER and Ideate.
Write your revised CER for the herd's crash. Use at least two numbers from the new evidence card and one result from a lab. Explain in your reasoning how the drought (a disturbance at the regional scale) changed the herd, and what might happen to the plant community next.
Ideate: list at least five management ideas for the board. For each, name the factor it changes (resources, boundaries, herd size or monitoring) and one piece of evidence that suggests it could help.
Our model now ties growth, energy and biodiversity together. Next: the Build phase, where we turn ideas into competing plans and test them.
Exit ticket: which Wonder Board question can you now answer? Write the question and your answer in two sentences.
How confident are you that you can revise an explanation about populations and biodiversity when new evidence about a disturbance arrives?
Materials: the new evidence card (printed or projected), students’ 1.03 CERs, chart paper and sticky notes for Ideate.
Data note: the rainfall, grass and elk numbers are sample data built to be internally consistent; label them as such.
Listen for: “the elk ate all the grass” with no role for rain; confusing energy and matter in the decomposer step; brainstorms that judge ideas too early.
Support / stretch: give a revision frame: “I used to think ___. The new evidence ___ shows ___. Now I think ___.” Stretch: estimate the new K if K is proportional to grass production (about 540 × 0.43 ≈ 230).