
The Colony Comeback Plan
How do behavior and population size shape a species’ survival, and how should a sanctuary protect a colony that came back from near extinction?
The mystery: Northern elephant seals were hunted until only a small remnant survived; today a coastal elephant seal colony crowds its beach, where a few dominant males father most pups and the whole species carries little genetic variation.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
explain the sanctuary’s request, our driving question and need-to-knows, and organize and describe colony count data over time.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Read the letter from the sanctuary’s management team. Underline what they want, and circle what they are worried about.
“Our elephant seal colony has grown from a handful of pups to thousands. Visitors love it, and some get too close. We have heard the seals have very little genetic variety. Before next breeding season we need a Colony Comeback Plan: a clear explanation of the recovery for our visitor center, a viewing plan that does not disturb breeding, and a monitoring plan that tracks the colony’s numbers and genetic health.”
Which request is the sanctuary actually making?
Meet the client. The management team of a coastal marine sanctuary includes a marine mammal biologist, a visitor-center educator, a volunteer docent coordinator and a representative of the nearby town. They want the colony to stay healthy, visitors to stay safe and the science explained in plain words.
Driving question. How do behavior and population size shape a species’ survival, and how should a sanctuary protect a colony that came back from near extinction?
The product. Each team writes a Colony Comeback Plan: a report for the visitor center with a growth model, behavior evidence and a genetics calculation, plus a viewing-and-monitoring plan chosen with a decision matrix. You present it to the sanctuary in the Prove It phase.
Organizing data over time. HS-LS4-3 starts with organizing data about a population over time in tables and graphs, and describing what each dataset shows. The colony table gives pups born each season (sample data). Pups born is a good index of the breeding population, because each adult female has at most one pup a year.
Worked example 1: describe each interval. From year 0 to 5 the count rose from 10 to about 60, six times larger. From year 10 to 15, 300 to 900: three times larger. From year 20 to 25, 1,600 to 2,000: only 1.25 times larger. The growth factor per five years falls, even though the number added is still large. That pattern, plotted, is the S-curve of logistic growth you met in Unit 1.
Worked example 2: a second dataset. The sanctuary also recorded the share of pups that survived to weaning in a crowded and an uncrowded part of the beach (sample data): crowded section 0.82 (410 of 500), uncrowded section 0.91 (455 of 500). Organized side by side in a bar graph, the data suggest that crowding has a cost. A good description names both numbers and the comparison: “Survival to weaning was 9 percentage points lower in the crowded section.” Whether crowding caused the difference is a question for later.
Need-to-knows and teams. We form teams of four with rotating roles: Data Lead (checks every number and label), Modeler (spreadsheets, graphs, genetics calculations), Field Lead (lab materials, animal care and safety) and Communicator (writing and sanctuary contact). Roles rotate each phase.
Use the colony table and the weaning data. Discuss, then answer.
Graph, charter and Wonder Board.
Graph the colony table and the weaning data. Under each graph, write two sentences describing what the dataset shows, naming at least two numbers.
Write your team charter and add three questions to the Wonder Board: one about behavior, one about numbers and one about genes.
Our project is launched. Next: a behavior investigation with a small animal you can find in any schoolyard.
Exit ticket: describe the colony's growth in one sentence using a growth factor, and name one need-to-know for the Colony Comeback Plan.
Materials: the sanctuary letter (printed), team role cards, graph paper or spreadsheets, the Wonder Board from 4.01.
Setup: the sanctuary is fictional and generic. A staff member can read the letter as the sanctuary’s biologist. Keep the Wonder Board posted; 4.06 and 4.09 return to it.
Data note: the colony and weaning numbers are sample data.
Listen for: “more seals means more genetic variety”; treating a difference between beach sections as proof of cause.
Support / stretch: give graph axes pre-labeled. Stretch: fit a logistic curve to the colony table and estimate the beach’s carrying capacity.